Even as a self professed Mass Effect super fan, I was never mad about Mass Effect 3. I was disappointed in how the ending played out, mainly because of how well the other games wrapped up in comparison. Look at the second game and the final suicide mission. Everything fit together and the choices you made fed into that last push. It wasn't perfect, and once you knew how it worked you could break it and save everyone, but nothing in a game since has made me feel so powerful and so much like an actual leader. It was awesome. Even the first game had an epic ending filled with choices (save the council, etc) and to that end it also felt like you were in a universe where everything fit together properly. The promise of those two games and their endings was enough to make me envision an ending where all of your choices mattered. You saved the Rachni? That would come up. You settled the Geth vs Quarian conflict? That should be a big deal. And, as the credits rolled on that ending, I realized that I had become a victim of that hype. I was let down. I wasn't mad at all, just a little perplexed and a bit melancholy.
It doesn't help that so much of the third game hits the story beats so damn well. All the big moments of the game worked for me. Seeing Mordin, Grunt, Legion and Thane again, and the conclusions to their character arcs was super satisfying. With every major plot thread closed I actually got teary eyed. Everything seemed to be working out to make this the conclusion that I had thought about since I finished Mass Effect 2 and all of that games DLC. Almost everything up to the very last few minutes of the game was fine. I didn't like how the war readiness and assets ended panning out. Instead of seeing the Rachni come in guns blazing during that final fight they're just a number in the war asset list. I guess that's one of my main issues with the conclusion. I feel like that list could have been something really nifty. I mean, if they had the time, it could have been an epic cut scene (more epic than what they ended up making) or maybe something more. I don't know. As a fan I felt like there was this build up to something that was going to surpass the suicide mission, and it ended up kind of being a wet fizzle.
The final choices didn't bother me so much. My husband and I assumed that Shepard was going to turn into Space Jesus and jump into a beam of light (no joke, we both talked about this before the game dropped) so when it actually happened, I was pretty accepting of it. I was more put out by the weird conversation with the ghost kid and how it seemed that Shepard was pretty much giving up when it mattered the most. When I say giving up, I mean trusting the AI and just accepting three choices. With all the AI troubles that Shepard has had in all 3 games, I thought she might be a bit more reticent to trust ghost kid, but that's a relatively small quibble. Still, it was indicative of how rushed the ending felt. Yes, I felt in my guts that Shepard was going to die, but the way it happened was pretty uninspired, imo.
I will say that the amended ending was better. I played both and felt like the revamped one was a bit more complete. But I didn't need it to feel good about the series. The three games were almost perfect in my mind. They had their problems, but the story and characters were top notch and I felt like they managed to have more hits in the games than misses. The first game had glitches and the combat was rough around the edges, but the world building was fantastic and the RPG bits were great. The second game improved the game play mechanics but jettisoned the RPG elements. The story was great, if less epic in scope, and the characters really were center stage. The third game continued refining the game play and added in some of the lost RPG like mechanics. The conversations took a hit to make them more streamlined (my guess) and so the game seemed more set on a specific course. The story beats were fantastic and more character arcs had satisfying endings. The ending was not good, but I can forgive a fumble at the goal line in a game that's already a blowout for team ME.
So, long story short, I love the ME series and the ending of the third game, though disappointing in it's kind of slapdash, rushed conclusion, didn't anger me. It just made me feel a bit sad that it couldn't have landed on a better, more cohesive note and wrapped up in a way that was worthy of the series as a whole.
Log in to comment