Good games that X-Play hates

Over the years I've gotten the impression that X-Play has given decent games low praise either to start controversy, or overly silly reasons. It's funny that games that are generally well received are maligned by them, and in honor of their recent Metroid review, let's look back at what else they've bashed.  
Are there any other good games you remember X-Play hating?

List items

7 Comments Refresh
Posted by Hailinel

This is an entertaining idea for a list.

Posted by Bones8677

I like this list, I know there are other games like this, but it's been a while since I have seen X play.

Posted by aurahack

I don't care what Metacritic says: Crisis Core is an awful, awful game.
That being said, I miss Extended Play. :(

Posted by Daveyo520

The new Silent Hill is good.

Posted by mylifeforAiur
@Daveyo520: Agreed. Shattered Memories is a fantastic game, not that it really matters, who the hell cares about X-Play anyway ;)
Edited by ZombiePie

I love X-Play and side with Jeff in saying that Adam Sessler is one of the only person on TV that I trust to represent video games properly.
As for suggestions I remember X-play giving Metal Gear Solid 3 a 4 out of 5 and the internet exploding when they published that review. Not a good game that they hated but definitely a fond memory.
Edit: Also this whole Metroid thing reminds me of this classic video from way back when: 

Posted by Apparatus_Unearth

I understand the one about Metroid: Other M. That game's just not for everyone.