Something went wrong. Try again later

DevourerOfTime

This user has not updated recently.

771 7079 42 103
Forum Posts Wiki Points Following Followers

The Femboys of Fighting Games

At EVO 2022, fan-favourite Bridget was added to Guilty Gear Strive. After years of fan requests and Bridget missing the roster entirely in Xrd, the fans got what they wanted.

Personally, I was very against adding Bridget into Guilty Gear Xrd. Bridget's story is... somewhat of a mess. Being born a boy, but forced to live life as a girl because of a superstition in the community about twins, Bridget went out on a quest to become stronger and assert that "I am a boy!"... while doing so in a hyper-feminine outfit with a stuffed bear.

So while Bridget became a femboy icon across the game's fanbase (and just the internet in general), you can see how I had mistrust over a video game company, let alone a Japanese video game company, being able to handle that gender minefield.

But I underestimated Arc System Works. They added Testament to the game earlier this year (another character that didn't show up during Xrd) and knocked it out of the park with them. Testament went on a journey of self-discovery after their angsty phase in XX, rejected gender in its entirety, and have been living their best life as an agender immortal.

And everyone loved it. Arc System Works did a phenomenal job in reimagining this character in such a positive light, a character that was defined as struggling and not being accepted. And people (including me!) became hopeful that Bridget might just return after all and be handled well when added.

You'll notice I didn't use pronouns for Bridget. That's because, with this new release, Bridget has gone through some changes. See with Guilty Gear Strive, characters have all been redesigned to "strive" to be the best versions of themselves. Which is a fantastically positive design philosophy in a world that is sorely lacking in that. Now whether they hit that mark is up to debate (poor Faust), but they certainly did with many characters, including one of the toughest ones so far.

And with Bridget? Soul-searching was also on the menu and, after obtaining strength and dispelling the superstition around twins, Bridget still didn't feel right about Bridget. After some support from Ky and Goldlewis in the new story mode, Bridget comes to terms with that and decides not to run away, proclaiming: "I am a girl".

And the internet exploded. While Bridget has certainly been a femboy icon for years, she has also been a huge icon for transgender players. Transmasc players see themselves in this character who was forced to be femme for her entire life now trying to burst out of that and be a man and Transfemme players see themselves in this character who likes traditionally feminine things, but was unfortunately assigned the wrong sex. Even Gender Non-Conforming (GNC) people as a whole, not just femboys, liked Bridget for what she represented.

(Obviously that's oversimplifying quite a bit and there is a lot of nuance and differing opinions, but you can see how some groups would be *incredibly* enthusiastic about this change and others... not so much.)

While I understand those who loved this femboy icon not being too enthused by Bridget being a canonically trans woman, there has been some pushback that has been, to be blunt, transphobic as fuck.

  • You can disagree with a writing choice for a character without being transphobic about it.
  • You can disagree whether the choice to make a character trans is what you would have done with the character without rejecting the notion that Bridget could possibly be trans.
  • You can mourn the loss of a femboy icon without going for the throat of every trans person celebrating this change.
  • You can not be a dick, a complete piece of shit, a complete transphobic asshat, and still say why this design decision hurts you.

But this is the internet and people inevitably didn't do that. So, to both help those mourning and those who are being attacked, I thought I would shift the attention away from Bridget (as much as I am happy for her) to other femboys in fighting games. Bridget's backstory might be... unique, but having men that are femme (or at least GNC) in fighting games is not.

So let's look at some of them!

UNDER CONSTRUCTION

List items

  • What? Puyo Puyo Tetris isn't a fighting game you say?

    Clearly you haven't been watching the Evo tournaments.

    Jay and his twin sister Elle are Tetris side of characters in Puyo Puyo Tetris.

  • Yep, sorry for spoiling part of Persona 4, but if its in his win pose in Persona 4 Arena, I think the secret is out: there's a boy in that bear.

    And that boy is very cute in a non-traditionally masculine way. And, while it can somewhat be explained by Teddie's naivety that he doesn't understand why dressing up feminine is not conforming to gender stereotypes, he still takes to dressing in girls clothing rather well, making a very convincing Alice.

  • Oh Chris. While Ash and Shion might fit the femboy label more nowadays, you were the first one in the King of Fighters series to wear it.

    I know some players that played King of Fighters for years not knowing Chris was a man. I mean, I was one of them, always thinking Chris stood for Christina or something. (Then again, I never followed the games closely until long past the point where he had died in the story.)

    But resurrected now, Chris is back in the roster of the newest game and back in the fighting game playing public's consciousness.

    Fun fact - Chris has only been voiced by a man twice: once for a Otome side game directed at straight women and once because he was voiced by an actor who came out as a transgender man. While its more commonplace than you'd think for an actor of one gender to play a character of another, it is something SNK has been trying to keep with Chris for 25+ years.

  • Link is an awkward one to include because while Link is male, he's also a stand-in for the player in most games. And, as such, his gender can be malleable.

    This isn't true in Breath of the Wild though. Link is a real character with his own backstory, history with different characters, and personality. And in the sequence of gaining access to the Gerudo town, while leaning on some N o t G r e a t stereotypes, definitely sees Link sporting a very feminine look and rocking it confidently while looking very cute.

    Its a sequence that has struck a cord with many, given the amount of cosplay and art I've seen of Link with that outfit over the years.

    Unfortunately that outfit is not in Smash, but I'll include it anyway.

  • While not available in either Smash or Ergheiz, Cloud pulling off that dress in FF7 has definitely awakened something in a lot of people, especially GNC men.

11 Comments

Avatar image for zombiepie
ZombiePie

9285

Forum Posts

94844

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 19

Astolfo?

Avatar image for franzlska
franzlska

243

Forum Posts

138832

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 5

@zombiepie: Are there any Fate/ fighting games? It seems unthinkable that there wouldn't be, given Melty Blood, but I can't find any, and if they exist Astolfo doesn't seem to be in them.

Avatar image for prl412
prl412

47

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By prl412

There's not a ton of backstory but Fox/Hans from Bloody Roar 1 might qualify for this list.

Avatar image for devoureroftime
DevourerOfTime

771

Forum Posts

7079

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 65

@franzlska @zombiepie: There are Fate fighting games, but none of them have Astolfo.

I checked.

Avatar image for devoureroftime
DevourerOfTime

771

Forum Posts

7079

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 65

@prl412: Thanks! I'll add him to the list.

Avatar image for zombiepie
ZombiePie

9285

Forum Posts

94844

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 19

@zombiepie: Are there any Fate/ fighting games? It seems unthinkable that there wouldn't be, given Melty Blood, but I can't find any, and if they exist Astolfo doesn't seem to be in them.

@franzlska @zombiepie: There are Fate fighting games, but none of them have Astolfo.

I checked.

You know... I'm going to come clean and admit that I totally missed the "fighting game" part of this list and thought this was a definitive list of gaming's greatest femboys. MY BAD! In terms of Fate/Stay fighting games in general, you have to go back to those awful PSP games. That said, this is reminding me that I need to write about Type/Moon wanting you to forget about the Fate/Stay VNs even existing.

Anyway, I also want to say that whatever you think the reaction to Bridget has been on English-speaking Twitter; I can definitively confirm that the reaction is 100% WORSE on Japanese-Speaking Twitter.

Avatar image for franzlska
franzlska

243

Forum Posts

138832

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 5

@zombiepie: Good lord, is that so? What I've seen of the reaction has been extremely mercurial, so imagining it being twice as bad elsewhere is a scary thought. I guess it makes sense though, with what little I knew about the series before looking into it lately, my perception has been that Bridget was a bit of a mixed bag over here while she was the long-running fan favorite in Japan.

My bad on the Fate fighting games though, I scrolled through the franchise list and somehow completely missed 'em.

Avatar image for zombiepie
ZombiePie

9285

Forum Posts

94844

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 19

@zombiepie: Good lord, is that so? What I've seen of the reaction has been extremely mercurial, so imagining it being twice as bad elsewhere is a scary thought. I guess it makes sense though, with what little I knew about the series before looking into it lately, my perception has been that Bridget was a bit of a mixed bag over here while she was the long-running fan favorite in Japan.

My bad on the Fate fighting games though, I scrolled through the franchise list and somehow completely missed 'em.

Well... see... fuck. How do I put this. Everything I am going to present and say is meant to be taken as a purely educational exercise and that I do not actually believe any of the views I am about to review. Likewise, I understand that these reactions do not apply to the entirety of the Japanese people or Japanese FGC.

Bridget was a fan favorite in Japan because the character was associated with the "Otokonoko" or "otoko no ko" label. The online circles that fetishize and/or relate or associate strongly with communities connected with that identifying label have reacted in one of two ways.

Reaction #1: Dismiss this as another example of a Japanese developer placating "Western wokeness." If you find Japanese artists that are producing Bridget art, you're going to find a vast majority are continuing to bill the art with "Otokonoko" or "otoko no ko" label. On top of that, many account I'm looking at are using a popular meme which roughly translates to "Say something like you were born in the Showa era." In this context, it's being used to recall a supposed time when Japanese media was "its own thing" and absent from Western pressures.

Reaction #2: The Doujinshi Reaction. A friend of mine lives in Japan and went to Comiket 100 and observed a MASSIVE amount of fan art and manga related to Bridget. However, the depictions of Bridget are more closely related to older versions and perceptions of the character than what was attempted in Strive. Part of this is a production limitation as many of these printing were made months in advance for Comiket, but there's a sentiment in the Doujin circle that "Well, if they want to do that with the character, whatever, but I'm sticking to my old guns. The number of times they observed when the word "trap," and its associated Japanese stan-bys, when applied to Bridget memorabilia, was high.

Avatar image for devoureroftime
DevourerOfTime

771

Forum Posts

7079

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 65

Edited By DevourerOfTime

@zombiepie: Reaction #1 sounds like the same thing that's happening here: a good ol mix of internet douchebaggery, nationalist rose-tinted glasses for mythical "when times were good", and transphobia. Which, to be fair, is a venn diagram that looks almost like a single circle.

Still, I have seen quite a bit of Bridget art from Japan either through twitter searches for it, my own timeline, or through discords I'm on and I've been surprised to see quite a few Japanese creators being excited for Bridget's transition. Usually they deal with just as much support and shitbaggery as western art, though this is all going through machine translation so I have to speculate a bit.

Though there seems to be a lot of "I'm just not going to touch this and just post art without labels either way" going on. Which, fair, its nice not to put a target on your back, but its disappointing to see that's mostly the default.

Reaction #2 is not at all surprising.

With print like that, its going to be a very gradual whenever anything changes. I don't blame artists that had all these copies of their work printed, ready for Comiket, then Bridget is revealed and now all their work was outdated and now potentially offensive, but still going through with it because of the sunk cost in it all.

That said, I have no faith in the porn side of things changing. The use of the T-slur for femboys and trans women interchangeably is rampant, even with its 4chan (aka western) origins, and it takes pulling teeth for those industries to change their labels. Like, it took decades for PornHub to change their categories from the other t-slur to use for the transgender category and even to remove the slurs from some of the categories for ethnicity (like yikes).

It will be decades of similar pulling teeth for Japan porn circles to have the slurs (especially around trans women, which there are quite a few used, as following trans artists who do 18+ work has made me keenly aware) dropped from their categories , especially since Japan is behind a lot of the world in LGBTQ+ rights and acceptance.

Avatar image for devoureroftime
DevourerOfTime

771

Forum Posts

7079

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 65

Edited By DevourerOfTime
@franzlska said:

My bad on the Fate fighting games though, I scrolled through the franchise list and somehow completely missed 'em.

All good. I only knew about Fate Unlimited Code before making this list (apparently there was another one on the PSP) and I only know about that because A) a player I liked actually came from being really good in Fate to playing Mahvel 3 back in the day and B) I like trolling the Fate gacha game threads and channels with combo videos and tournament videos from the game because its "technically Fate content"

Avatar image for sirkinsella98
Sirkinsella98

47

Forum Posts

57142

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 18

If you think Bridget was trans from start? You're dead wrong, Daisuke completely censored Bridget's gender in favor for western people (mainly Twitter/X and (maybe) Tumblr) while Bridget's gender as a male and a femboy/otokonoko that is still existed in Japanese version of the Strive. I highly suggest you delete it, transphobic/bigot or not.

Also, I seen better trans representation than this character like Poison (Final Fight/Street Fighter) and Birdo (Super Mario).