@rubberluffy: As a guy who had nearly zero exposure to anime, I was more or less mesmerized at the time by how different it was from western animation. Does it hold up? Obviously not. But it takes me back to the time when DBZ and Ronin Warriors were part of a subtle Japanese invasion of American children's television, along with Power Rangers.
@chainreaction01: Personally I thought the third Madoka movie was hot garbage, but I can't really say why without spoiling it. That's coming from someone who had to be more or less forced at gunpoint to get over the magical girl setting until the show picks up, but oh boy, did I love it when it got going.
I also thought the 2nd season of Psycho Pass was a letdown. Letting the bad guy escape on a boat? A totally bullshit explanation for why the bad guy can do what he does, that stretches the fiction to a breaking point? I was disappointed by the middle of the season, and it never redeemed itself.