My list and Brad's list share 7 games, if he got rid of Dead Rising, Zelda, and Brothers for Guacamelee, Spelunky, and The Swapper, we'd have the exact same games, just ordered differently. But our #1 and 2 picks are the same. So, good job on have excellent taste, Mr. Shoemaker.
As long as Dota 2 makes an appearance on the top 10 overall list, I'll be fine. Although it would be extremely hilarious if the only way Brad could get everyone to agree to put Dota on the list was to get rid of Brothers.