A few small quibbles in no particular order after spending a hot minute on the side, (that said, I'm a developer who works with designers a lot, but not a designer myself, so take these with a grain of salt):
- The top nav hover tray open state should preserve when mousing between tabs, and only swap out content when scanning across, looks a bit lame right now
- Similarly, but an existing issue, the top nav doesn't avoid the mouse corridor issue, which makes them feel a bit fiddly: https://css-tricks.com/dropdown-menus-with-more-forgiving-mouse-movement-paths/
- The home page middle responsive break points have the tweet tile content break out of the background. Looks like you might need to narrow the community tile there (e.g. put the list below the featured image?)
- Don't put a play icon on hovering content if clicking isn't going to start playing! You already have the video/audio circle icons for the podcast page, you should preserve that visual language.
- I think the flat design is probably closer to the right direction, but to my eye it needs either some very strong spacing and color usage; or some parallax or light effects or something to give it visual hierarchy. You don't need to go full Material or Fluent here, but the push is toward semi-flat for a reason, good pure flat is very hard, and right now, for example, your headers are disappearing between the content. (Netflix have a similar design, but they largely get away with this by not having any text other that headers and "continue watching" details)
- Might just be me, but when following a show link, I just get the page for the latest episode: I feel this should be something like the existing home page card with a short blurb about the show, then the grid view of episodes.. The main problem for me is ATM you go to what could be a show page, that shows the latest episode then a list of other episodes, then a comment section which could be for the show, but is actually for the latest episode.
Log in to comment