Most of my nominations are 5 games each. I did make an exception for a few because man...there was a lot of good games this year 

Best Re-Make (To define re-make, I mean games like Wolfenstein, etc. But straight up re-makes such as Punch Out!! still count)

Boy and His Blob
Punch-Out!!
New Super Mario Bros.
Monkey Island Special Edition
Trials HD

Best Sequel

Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
Skate 2
50 Cent Blood on the Sand
Red Faction: Guerrilla
Call of Juarez BiB
Assassins Creed II
Modern Warfare 2
Killzone II

Best New Franchise

Dragon Age: Origins
'Splosion Man
Shadow Complex
Brutal Legend
Borderlands

Best War Game

Halo 3: ODST
Operation Flashpoint Dragon Rising  
 Battlefield 1943
Modern Warfare 2
Killzone II

Best Shooter

Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
50 Cent Blood on the Sand
Call of Juarez: BiB
Modern Warfare 2
Borderlands

Best Extreme Sports/Traditional Sports Game

Skate 2
Madden NFL 10
NHL 10
Fifa 10
The Bigs 2

Most Disappointing

 Prototype
Bionic Commando
Ninja Blade
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
Academy of Champions: Soccer

Best Music/Rhythm game

 The Beatles: Rock Band
Guitar Hero 5 

Most Surprising

50 Cent Blood on the Sand
Red Faction: Guerrilla
'Splosion Man
Brutal Legend
Torchlight

Best Fighting Game

WWE Smackdown vs. Raw 2010
Legends of Wrestlemania
Street Fighter IV
King of Fighters XII

Best Graphics/Art Style

Pixel Junk Shooter
Uncharted 2: Among Thives
Modern Warfare 2
Red Faction: Guerrilla
A Boy and His Blob

Best 360 Game

Shadow Complex
 'Splosion Man
Left 4 Dead 2
Rocket Riot
Grand Theft Auto: Episodes From Liberty City

Best PS3 Game

Pixel Junk Shooter
inFamous
Fat Princess
Killzone 2
Ratchet and Clank FutureL A Crack in Time

Biggest Announcement

Something probably happened.

Best Soundtrack

Assassins Creed II
The Beatles: Rock Band
Brutal Legend
'Splosion Man
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

Best Storyline

Batman: Arkham Asylum
Assassins Creed II
Brutal Legend
Call of Juarez: BiB
Dragon Age: Origins

Best New Video Game Character

Ezio
'Splosion Man
Eddie Riggs
Cole
Afro Samurai

Best Co-op Game

Borderlands
 New Super Mario Bros.
Pixel Junk Shooter
Unncharted 2: Among Thieves
South Park: Tower Defense Go

Worst Game This Year

Eat Lead: The Return of Matt Hazzard
Prototype
Damnation
Wheelman
Backyard Football '10

Game of the Year

Batman: Arkham Asylum
Modern Warfare 2
Assassins Creed II
The Beatles: Rock Band
Torchlight
Brutal Legend
Call of Juarez: BiB
Red Faction: Guerrilla
50 Cent Blood on the Sand
New Super Mario Bros.
Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time
Borderlands
Left 4 Dead 2 
 
Winners will be announced on Christmas Day.

Why the fuuuuuck is Ceville not on there?

Uncharted 2 at most disappointing? I lol'd.

Dude. Where is Claptrap in the best new character section?
 
Also, I vote Red Faction: Guerrilla in everything it's nominated in.

So Uncharted 2 is not a candidate for best sequel but it is a candidate for most disappointing? Nice try. 

" Uncharted 2 at most disappointing? I lol'd. "

 Best 360 Game

Shadow Complex
 'Splosion Man
Trials HD
Rocket Riot
Grand Theft Auto: Episodes From Liberty City
 
 
Uhh...what the fuck is this?

this is weird. your categories are whacky. 

Everyone is absolutely entitled to their own opinion. 
 
But if you want to be taken seriously at all, I strongly suggest you take off probably the highest rated game this year as "most disappointing". 
Then again, half of your choices and even categories (Modern Warfare 2 and Halo ODST for..."Best war game"? Just war in general? Even fictional ones? How about Red Faction? There was a war in that. Or do you mean FPS? Or military themed FPS? That's a category?!) are practically nonsensical.

" Everyone is absolutely entitled to their own opinion. 
 
But if you want to be taken seriously at all, I strongly suggest you take off probably the highest rated game this year as "most disappointing". 
Then again, half of your choices and even categories (Modern Warfare 2 and Halo ODST for..."Best war game"? Just war in general? Even fictional ones? How about Red Faction? There was a war in that. Or do you mean FPS? Or military themed FPS? That's a category?!) are practically nonsensical. "

The validity of your list was ruined when Uncharted was nominated for most disappointing.

I've got to ask, did you seriously play all those games?

There were a lot of games worse than Prototype this year. 
 
And how could a game like Academy of Champions: Soccer be a disappointment? Was anyone hyped for that game?

" Uncharted 2 at most disappointing? I lol'd. "

If you're hating on my blog solely because of my opinion then you're a complete idiot. I didn't like Uncharted 2 much, fucking sue me. And you wanna know what? It's going to get my Most Disappointing award. Because the combat blowed and the platforming was all over the place in a terrible way. 
 
I also hated Prototype...a lot. And I want to express my hate by putting it in those categories. Fact of the matter is, I sat down and listed every game I had played this year, Prototype just happened to be in the top 5 that I hated. 
 
And @vidiot: ...you're right. Best War Game? What the fuck was I thinking. Will be removed. 
 
@extremeradical: The reason I put Academy of Champions: Soccer there isn't because I was extremely hyped before launch. It's because I realized how much potential it had and it didn't capitalize on any of that potential. 
 
@Maxszy: Yes. 
 
@NickNorman: I had 5 (or less) on all the categories besides 2. You make it sound like it was 4 on one, 8 on the other, 9 on the next. No, it was 5 on all besides "Best Sequel" because there was a lot of sequels released this year that were fantastic. "Best Music/Rhythm" because I only played 2 Music/Rhythm games this year. And "Game of the Year" because it's Game of the Year. 
 
@Milkman: Name 5 other nominees for Best 360 Game. Besides Halo ODST and Forza 3. I only played one of those and I did not enjoy it. 
 
@Coltonio7: Go die.

I do not agree with your 360 games at all. Therefore I will wait and see what people choose. You know, Best 360 Game doesn't necessarily have to be an exclusive title but if it is then you could have L4D2. Yes, that's on PC but it's 360-exclusive on the consoles.

" If you're hating on my blog solely because of my opinion then you're a complete idiot. I didn't like Uncharted 2 much, fucking sue me. And you wanna know what? It's going to get my Most Disappointing award. Because the combat blowed and the platforming was all over the place in a terrible way. 
 
I also hated Prototype...a lot. And I want to express my hate by putting it in those categories. Fact of the matter is, I sat down and listed every game I had played this year, Prototype just happened to be in the top 5 that I hated. 
 
And @vidiot: ...you're right. Best War Game? What the fuck was I thinking. Will be removed. 
 
@extremeradical: The reason I put Academy of Champions: Soccer there isn't because I was extremely hyped before launch. It's because I realized how much potential it had and it didn't capitalize on any of that potential. 
 
@Maxszy: Yes. 
 
@NickNorman: I had 5 (or less) on all the categories besides 2. You make it sound like it was 4 on one, 8 on the other, 9 on the next. No, it was 5 on all besides "Best Sequel" because there was a lot of sequels released this year that were fantastic. "Best Music/Rhythm" because I only played 2 Music/Rhythm games this year. And "Game of the Year" because it's Game of the Year. 
 
@Milkman: Name 5 other nominees for Best 360 Game. Besides Halo ODST and Forza 3. I only played one of those and I did not enjoy it. 
 
@Coltonio7: Go die. "

Heres an interesting question, if this is all stated as YOUR own personal opinion, why must we wait until Christmas to get results? It makes sense just to tell us.