Something went wrong. Try again later

Giant Bomb Review

261 Comments

Halo 3: ODST Review

4
  • X360

If you like the way Bungie makes first-person shooters, you'll enjoy Halo 3: ODST.


You've got a tough mission ahead of you... but first you'll have to make it out of your drop pod. 
You've got a tough mission ahead of you... but first you'll have to make it out of your drop pod. 
If you're still trying to wrap your mind around what, exactly, Halo 3: ODST is, perhaps it'll help you to think of it as if  it were a PC-style expansion that doesn't require the original game to play. It uses a lot of the same technology that powered Halo 3 back in 2007, and it tells a story that exists concurrently with some of the events of Halo 2 and Halo 3. It makes some interesting changes to Bungie's battle-tested design style, but at its core, it still maintains that Halo feel. If you liked Halo 3 and have any interest in the expanded Halo universe, you'll enjoy the new things that ODST has to offer.

In ODST, you'll play as an ODST--that's Orbital Drop Shock Trooper. These are the guys that launch down from the sky in pods, and they represent some of Earth's best soldiers. But the key is that the ODSTs are still merely human. They aren't genetically engineered badasses like the Master Chief. So the characters you play as here are a little more fragile than the shielded and armored super trooper you're used to controlling in Halo games. They aren't tough enough to dual-wield weapons. They aren't rough enough to hijack enemy vehicles. They aren't strong enough to pull off that huge, floaty jump that the Master Chief has. They aren't crafty enough to collect and deploy equipment like you could in Halo 3. And they don't have health that automatically recharges when you take damage. That said, the ODSTs still have shields of some sort. It's referred to as "stamina" in-game, but it serves the same purpose as the Chief's shields and recharges when you stay out of battle for a few seconds. Your health meter--the one that gets rocked when you get caught while out of stamina--doesn't recharge on its own. To rectify health issues, you'll have to seek out medkits, which are usually plentiful enough to make health loss a non-issue. Beyond these changes, the ODSTs you'll control in the campaign are roughly equivalent to the big Spartan.

The other big change in ODST is that these guys are equipped with different helmet-based heads-up displays. The new HUD--which comes from your visor and is helpfully called VISR--comes with a light amplification option that brightens things up and enhances the edges of objects. This is handy, as significant portions of the campaign are done under cover of darkness. The edge enhancement is especially cool in the darkest areas. The lines it draws around the edges of things makes the game look like some kind of militaristic Tron arena or something. While you don't have a motion sensor, hitting the back button brings up a map of the city, showing you where you need to go, nearby enemies, and more. The map screen, also, looks really nice. The key reason for having a map--as well as an on-screen compass that directs you to waypoints--is that a chunk of ODST is played in a sort of open-world hub that links the game's missions together.

 Who is The Rookie?
 Who is The Rookie?
The open nature of the New Mombasa streets makes sense in the context of the game's story. Five ODST troops drop into New Mombasa with a Naval Intelligence officer named Dare. She doesn't really get into the specifics of the mission, and things go wrong almost immediately because your insertion pods are knocked off course when a Covenant cruiser positioned above the city jumps into slipspace. This rips up the city and sends your team's pods careening off-course, separating the crew. The game opens with you in control of a character known only as The Rookie. He immediately hooks up with the city's computers, giving you map data and navigation points that point you in the direction of the rest of your team. When you get to the proper location (usually by finding a key item, like Dare's helmet, or a bent-up sniper rifle), the game switches into a flashback. These are the game's missions, and most of them put you in the role of one of the other members of your team. These missions are linear and very much designed in the Halo tradition. Once you complete a mission, The Rookie gets new data and moves to the next spot. The juxtaposition between the quiet, nighttime city, where The Rookie can stick to the shadows and avoid a lot of combat as he moves from spot to spot and the large, loud battles that you've come to expect from the Halo series is an interesting one. Even though there isn't that much to do when you're not in an active mission, the dark, open city gives ODST a very different atmosphere from the other games in the line. The game's great soundtrack really contributes to that feel, as well.

As you work your way through the city, you may run into one of the 30 audio clips hidden there. These are designed to be a basic collectible and to give you a reason to run around the entire city, rather than just sticking to the critical path and heading from one mission to the next. The clips string together to form a fairly interesting story that's set around the time of the Covenant first landing at New Mombasa. It also gives you some insight into the nature of the Superintendent, which is a city-wide AI that subtly guides you around the city by changing video screens around town to big detour arrows aimed in the direction of your next objective or a nearby audio log. The story that plays out in these audio logs is tied to the game's story, but it features more interesting characters than the actual game does. The Rookie doesn't speak, which sort of makes him the most interesting character by default. The rest of the ODST crew chats it up, but a lot of that dialogue feels forced, with plenty of generic-sounding military talk. And the all-too-convenient romantic past between the ODST squad leader and the female naval intelligence officer doesn't bring any heat to the proceedings.

The campaign kept me going for just under seven hours on the game's "heroic" difficulty setting. Like Halo 3 before it, the developers recommend that players familiar with the series start at this setting. On normal or lower, the combat is painfully easy--which is fine if you're a novice, but won't be much fun for anyone else. On the highest setting, again known as legendary, the game becomes much more of a challenge, making it something that's best suited for cooperative play. Like Halo 3 before it, ODST allows up to four players to play via Xbox Live or LAN. It's a fun way to play, though there's something cool about the solitary nature of The Rookie's portion of the journey that doesn't feel quite right when you're rolling around with three partners.

The squad, before everything goes wrong. 
The squad, before everything goes wrong. 
In addition to playing the campaign cooperatively, there's also a new co-op mode called firefight. This is a survival-type mode, which puts the players in a confined area and sets them against waves of Covenant enemies. The longer you last and the more enemies you take down, the higher you score. As you clear out waves, the game turns on more and more skulls, which are the secret items that you could use to modify the difficulty in Halo 3. In ODST, all of the skulls are the same, but they're all automatically unlocked from the get-go. Firefight encourages players to hunker down and defend small areas, sort of like the Gears of War 2 horde mode. For me, though, Halo is all about shooting on the move, not sitting down and controlling a specific spot. That's probably the reason why I don't find firefight to be very engaging, especially on its higher difficulty settings.

If that was the complete package, ODST would be a pretty good expansion type of package, provided it was available at an expansion sort of price. But there's a second disc in the package that offers every bit of Halo 3's competitive multiplayer, including all of the downloadable maps that have been made available via the Xbox Live Marketplace since Halo 3's release. It's a weird offering, because I find it hard to believe that anyone thinking about buying ODST doesn't already have Halo 3. And in the case of fanatical Halo fans, chances are they already paid for one or more of the map packs when they were released digitally. The one catch is that this disc, marked "Halo 3: Mythic," comes with three maps that will be exclusive to this collection. It's a convenient disc for Halo 3 multiplayer fans to own, but it feels like something that was tacked onto the collection in order to further justify the package's $59.99 price tag... and it's something that a sizable piece of the game's prospective audience probably already owns.

They're not the Master Chief, but they have most of his moves. 
They're not the Master Chief, but they have most of his moves. 
Though the technology that powered Halo 3 has aged, ODST still looks quite nice for a 2009 release. That's mostly thanks to the lighting. New Mombasa looks great at night, as the raging fires around the city give the sky a red glow, while the whole area is large enough to give you the sense of being stranded in a big, enemy-filled area. The video signs, which flicker to life as the Superintendent passes you messages, have a clean design style that really adds to the game's look and feel. The daytime missions look fine, as well.

Halo 3: ODST fills in a few interesting spots in the Halo timeline, even if the characters themselves aren't strong enough to carry the narrative. But it strikes a healthy balance between new twists and more content done in Bungie's trademark style. The more important thing is that if you've enjoyed playing Bungie's Halo games in the past, chances are you'll continue to enjoy that style in ODST. 
 
Disclosure: The game featured in this review is or was an advertised product on giantbomb.com.
Jeff Gerstmann on Google+

261 Comments

Avatar image for alcibiadesrex
AlcibiadesRex

103

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Fresh from the Halo: Infinite review - Jeff has the bona fides!

Avatar image for deactivated-5c7ea8553cb72
deactivated-5c7ea8553cb72

4753

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

Got it for 30$ today. WOOT!

Avatar image for adtr_zero
ADTR_ZERO

1122

Forum Posts

6

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By ADTR_ZERO
@ChopperDave47 said:
"i really don't understand this review. jeff says that he doesn't like the character development, the pricing, the firefight mode, the story, and he didn't even say whether he actually liked the campaign or not.  how did this get 9/10? "

It's actually an 8/10. And he didn't say he didn't like the game.
Avatar image for bybeach
bybeach

6754

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By bybeach

i`m about done with ODST, and well, it`s okay. I`m not saying anything by it, the review is acceptable to me, but in a 5 star review with no half stars, I personally would have given it a real reluctant 4 out of five. But damn, wish I could have taken another 1/2 star from it. it`s an 8 out of 10. Jeff mentioned on the bombast that one of the charactors at least did not agree with him. I concurr, think the same more or less of the others. The cut scenes are especially meh to me, I just don`t like the charactors much. But Iv`e learned to get into the combat  from Halo3 on. i also like the purty colors, and agree very much about turning the visr off at night when you can. Unlike Jeff, I went out of my way to pick off covenant in my rookie travels.  I really do not like brutes on my earth, so the game accomplished something there.
 
And is GB gointg to ever advertise anything besides ODST, it really doesn`t deserve this amount of respect, love the mute button.
Avatar image for kardon16
kardon16

65

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By kardon16

I just finished the campaign and I found it a somewhat boring. It was very atmospheric but not very epic and little things like the red HUD when damaged and the dark buildings were very annoying.

Avatar image for chopperdave47
ChopperDave47

80

Forum Posts

5

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By ChopperDave47

i really don't understand this review. jeff says that he doesn't like the character development, the pricing, the firefight mode, the story, and he didn't even say whether he actually liked the campaign or not.
 
how did this get 9/10?

Avatar image for thrustmuscle
ThrustMuscle

53

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By ThrustMuscle
@quantumshift5:  dude at least try ODST, i had the same perspective as you before i played it, but it is just an awesome experience. Totally reminiscent of the first halo but with a way more engaging  mood and story. The game play is way funner then halo 2 and 3.
Avatar image for thrustmuscle
ThrustMuscle

53

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By ThrustMuscle

Just finished the game...have to say best experience i have had with halo in a looong time haha probably since my first time playing halo combat evolved. Loved it start to finish

Avatar image for giyanks22
giyanks22

2950

Forum Posts

816

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 17

User Lists: 5

Edited By giyanks22

I'm playing it now, and find it enjoyable.

Avatar image for seppli
Seppli

11232

Forum Posts

9

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 7

User Lists: 0

Edited By Seppli
@PlasmaBeam44 said:
" @Seppli said:

" More professionally produced video reviews please. Quicklooks are awesome,  but video reviews, like this one, are the bread and butter. Come on guys.   Less slacking off, more video reviews ;D. "

What was so unprofessional about the video review? "
Read again please. I like this video review and I'd like to have more video reviews, just like it. Like for every game. All we get these days are QuickLooks, which are awesome too, but it's very rare for a game to get a video review like Halo ODST, which I like a lot and thus wish to see more of.
 
Whatever man - learn to read.
Avatar image for willy105
Willy105

4959

Forum Posts

14729

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 1

Edited By Willy105

Sounds like Halo meets Metroid. Interesting.

Avatar image for sooty
Sooty

8193

Forum Posts

306

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 3

Edited By Sooty

ODST is good fun, especially co-op and firefight with 4 friends.
 
Just make sure you scream "HALT. HAMMERZEIT." every time a brute with a hammer takes you by surprise.

Avatar image for nifty_shark
Nifty_Shark

18

Forum Posts

96

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Nifty_Shark

Jeff maybe you weren't successful but you can jack all vehicles.

Avatar image for basshero
basshero

32

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By basshero

I love the endings to Giant bomb videos!

Avatar image for freakin
freakin

404

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By freakin
I don't know why reviewers don't call Bungie out for the lack of matchmaking.  Not having it for the single player is one thing, but for a multiplayer mode... I'm not sure I get the logic.  Jeff didn't even bring it up...
Avatar image for hydrafiend
Hydrafiend

8

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

Edited By Hydrafiend

One of the better reviews that I have seen, and he does mention that this is really an expansion pack.  The no matchmaking in firefight is really a killer, almost makes that part of the game worthless, if you dont have several friends who are at least into video games and, if so, want to buy this game.

Avatar image for meatsim
MeatSim

11201

Forum Posts

150

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 23

Edited By MeatSim

Sick of Halo 3 multiplayer, so it comes down to the single player campaign and the firefight co-op and I don't think I wanna pay 60$ just for that.

Avatar image for spiceninja
spiceninja

3286

Forum Posts

9105

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 18

User Lists: 2

Edited By spiceninja
@Seppli said:

" More professionally produced video reviews please. Quicklooks are awesome,  but video reviews, like this one, are the bread and butter. Come on guys.   Less slacking off, more video reviews ;D. "

What was so unprofessional about the video review?
Avatar image for bulletstorm
bulletstorm

552

Forum Posts

131

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 5

Edited By bulletstorm

"Kicks in the balls aren't for everybody, if you like kicks in the balls you might like ODST although it's kind of a kick just in a ball, you've already purchased the other kicks in the balls before so we decided to throw in just half of a kick but for the full retail price of 60 dollars"  

Avatar image for seppli
Seppli

11232

Forum Posts

9

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 7

User Lists: 0

Edited By Seppli

More professionally produced video reviews please. Quicklooks are awesome,  but video reviews, like this one, are the bread and butter. Come on guys. 
 
Less slacking off, more video reviews ;D.

Avatar image for deactivated-6296e29cde7c5
deactivated-6296e29cde7c5

297

Forum Posts

2116

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

Just got it today and it is terrific! Very engaging single player, which is why I liked the first Halo. I'm not that big on multiplayer, but it is nice to have all that stuff on one disc now!

Avatar image for thecleric
thecleric

814

Forum Posts

246

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By thecleric

There's only one rookie for me, and he busts ghosts.

Avatar image for duttyfoot
duttyfoot

60

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By duttyfoot

i haven't played halo online either and i have them all. odst looks interesting so i will get it for sure. I still play halo 3 every now and then.

Avatar image for hawk456
Hawk456

153

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Hawk456

Cool stuff - maybe a Black Friday special... I smell $35, before noon, while supplies last.
Avatar image for bybeach
bybeach

6754

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By bybeach

i turned around and bought this game. I`m kinda mad at myself because i should really try batman-asylum, but i have trouble with melee games. Wolfenstien i`m waiting for a while. But halo 3 really was okay, and the brutes were almost decent bad guys.("we`ll follow them back to the herd" and "this one soiled himself..harr harr!"..loved that) One of the few things i even liked about halo 2 was hearing the grunts grouse"Little People first!" though the vague cartoon alien look is still too wierd. 
 
Anyways I checked around all the positive reviews buried in the tons of ODST adverts on other sites. Microsoft/Bungee put quite a sell on this one,oh yes, MSNBC also. My advice to GB is tactical..have varied commercial vids. if you must have them at all. I was killing the sound and saying'Go Covenant, and Little PPL. yay!..but I most always kills the sound to commercials, anyways. Nice that mute button....
Avatar image for ismoochyi
ISmoochyI

281

Forum Posts

63

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 6

Edited By ISmoochyI
@stinky:  
 
that's kind of the point to enjoying a single player campaign dude
Avatar image for stinky
stinky

1564

Forum Posts

2

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By stinky
 @ISmoochyI said:
" picked up my copy today...it's going to be a loooong night :) "
not unless you put it on Legendary, and play alone.
Avatar image for nubmonk
NubMonk

210

Forum Posts

57

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By NubMonk

If so many of you people think that Giant Bomb is such an "Advertisement hungry money machine with dishonest employees" then what the fuck are you doing here? You're obviously "too good" for this site.

Avatar image for burdi1ar
burdi1ar

4

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By burdi1ar

just seems like a lot to pay for a 6-7 hour story and maps that most people already own.

Avatar image for ep_driver
ep_driver

568

Forum Posts

822

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 1

Edited By ep_driver

Threeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee stars onlyyyyyyyy...or so I hoped. Old maps = lame. Short campaign for $60 = mehhh. Firefight Mode without matchmaking multiplayer = most retarded fucking shit EVER. I never thought it would happen, but I'm really starting to hate all things Bungie. I hope Reach refreshes the series in some way.
Avatar image for ismoochyi
ISmoochyI

281

Forum Posts

63

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 6

Edited By ISmoochyI

picked up my copy today...it's going to be a loooong night :)

Avatar image for wiseblood
Wiseblood

900

Forum Posts

24218

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Wiseblood

If Jeff didn't give the game at least 4 stars he totally would have fired himself.

Avatar image for avd
AvD

309

Forum Posts

1328

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 4

Edited By AvD
@PolyesterPimp said:
"  @mythrol said:

" @PolyesterPimp said:

" Oh and something inside makes me feel like Jeff wanted to give this game a 3Star rating... but didnt because of the obvious ad's across the whole site... "
Yeah I mean it's not like Jeff was fired for being honest and not giving a game high ratings due to ads on a site or anything. . .   Oh wait. At this point, Jeff has to be one of the most trusted reviewers on the entire internet.   He might have certain preferences, but as far as honesty goes, Jeff is way up there. "
SO your honestly going to say just because he bit the hand that fed him once he could never produce a biased review? Most of the writing in my opinion leads to his game being rated a 3star title. Its a complete rehash of Halo 3 there is nothing majorly different about its values. Im pretty sure Jeff doesnt want to be looking for another job so soon im not oging to say he completely copped out but with all the things he writes that relates this game to being just a Halo 3 Expansion especially the points at which he says he felt like their trying to justify the price tag by adding additional content (Reach beta, Halo 3 Multiplyer) ontop of the game itself.  Im sorry but if he had that many complaints about the game how could it have possibly been a 4Star game? He even said its more of the same, how does more of the same correlate to a 4star game? This is a below the level rehash in my opinion instead of adding new features they took them from you. How is that a improvement on what has been proven to be a solid formula? Nonsense you people need to take a dose of reality for once and realize that even your almighty Jeff can sell out just a bit from time to time. For a person to have that many problems with a title and then give it a 4star is ridiculous. Oh Im going to say this a games price should also be considered apart of a review simply because its the value of the game; and the standalone ODST does not equal 60$ in my eyes. The fact that the developer tacked on extras shows how much confidence they have in the original product itself; very little. "
You have obviously not played the game, please refrain from speaking.  Thank you.
Avatar image for mrzwij
MrZwij

11

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By MrZwij

Some fool told me you can sprint in ODST. True?

Avatar image for coiin
CoIin

91

Forum Posts

46

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 2

Edited By CoIin

That Yahtzee guy has more ads than this site for ODST. I guess I trust the GiantBomb guys because generally speaking if they like a game - so do I. Reviews are never individualized. You'll have to actually play the game if you want a perfect assessment.

Avatar image for comradecrash
comradecrash

603

Forum Posts

40

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

Edited By comradecrash

Great review. It looks different enough to warrent a rental.

Avatar image for stinky
stinky

1564

Forum Posts

2

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By stinky
@Lind_L_Taylor: its a good story for a shooter. 
 don't waste any valuable time researching into it.
Avatar image for lind_l_taylor
Lind_L_Taylor

4125

Forum Posts

6

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 5

Edited By Lind_L_Taylor

I never paid attention to the Halo story line while playing through it. I started with Halo 2 & never played the first one. I should probably read the back story for a few more details, if there are any.

Avatar image for mpasseri
MPasseri

4

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By MPasseri

Does anyone know if the multiplayer disc on odst integrates with Halo 3 original multiplayer ? Rankings , achievements, etc ?
 
I like Halo, I played 1 and 2, Still did not have time to finish 3, mostly because I don't have as much time to play games as I did before , but I guess the change of pace and mood in ODST is welcome. 

Avatar image for mrbasehart
mrbasehart

97

Forum Posts

4

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 4

Edited By mrbasehart

So, wait.  A reskinned page (pretty!) a disclaimer, and a four star review = CORRUPTION! 
 
Is that right? Or is that how crazy people think?

Avatar image for vasta_narada
vasta_narada

765

Forum Posts

735

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 4

Edited By vasta_narada
@PolyesterPimp: Unless I forgot something, the scores on Giantbomb are supposed to be based off how much the reviewer enjoyed the game, not whether the game makes significant advances.
Avatar image for coleslaw893
Coleslaw893

459

Forum Posts

226

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 17

Edited By Coleslaw893

Pretty much what I expected. Will get, but when the price drops.

Avatar image for wintersnowblind
WinterSnowblind

7599

Forum Posts

41

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 4

Edited By WinterSnowblind
@PolyesterPimp said:
"  @mythrol said:

" @PolyesterPimp said:

" Oh and something inside makes me feel like Jeff wanted to give this game a 3Star rating... but didnt because of the obvious ad's across the whole site... "
Yeah I mean it's not like Jeff was fired for being honest and not giving a game high ratings due to ads on a site or anything. . .   Oh wait. At this point, Jeff has to be one of the most trusted reviewers on the entire internet.   He might have certain preferences, but as far as honesty goes, Jeff is way up there. "
SO your honestly going to say just because he bit the hand that fed him once he could never produce a biased review? Most of the writing in my opinion leads to his game being rated a 3star title. Its a complete rehash of Halo 3 there is nothing majorly different about its values. Im pretty sure Jeff doesnt want to be looking for another job so soon im not oging to say he completely copped out but with all the things he writes that relates this game to being just a Halo 3 Expansion especially the points at which he says he felt like their trying to justify the price tag by adding additional content (Reach beta, Halo 3 Multiplyer) ontop of the game itself.  Im sorry but if he had that many complaints about the game how could it have possibly been a 4Star game? He even said its more of the same, how does more of the same correlate to a 4star game? This is a below the level rehash in my opinion instead of adding new features they took them from you. How is that a improvement on what has been proven to be a solid formula? Nonsense you people need to take a dose of reality for once and realize that even your almighty Jeff can sell out just a bit from time to time. For a person to have that many problems with a title and then give it a 4star is ridiculous. Oh Im going to say this a games price should also be considered apart of a review simply because its the value of the game; and the standalone ODST does not equal 60$ in my eyes. The fact that the developer tacked on extras shows how much confidence they have in the original product itself; very little. "
The game is an expansion.  Why should it deviate massively from Halo 3's formula?
 
That point aside, it is a very different game.  Open world, very character based, even many of the gameplay mechanics are completely changed for this such as the health and speed of the character, forcing you to play at a much more tactical pace.
 
I actually agree that adding on the multiplayer was an obvious ploy to boost the price of the game, Halo 3's multiplayer is still one of the best online games out there and allowing more people to play it is no bad thing.  If you don't already own the map packs, getting them here is great value and actually completely makes up for the cost of the game in the UK/Europe.
Avatar image for polyesterpimp
PolyesterPimp

279

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By PolyesterPimp

 @mythrol said:

" @PolyesterPimp said:

" Oh and something inside makes me feel like Jeff wanted to give this game a 3Star rating... but didnt because of the obvious ad's across the whole site... "
Yeah I mean it's not like Jeff was fired for being honest and not giving a game high ratings due to ads on a site or anything. . .   Oh wait. At this point, Jeff has to be one of the most trusted reviewers on the entire internet.   He might have certain preferences, but as far as honesty goes, Jeff is way up there. "
SO your honestly going to say just because he bit the hand that fed him once he could never produce a biased review? Most of the writing in my opinion leads to his game being rated a 3star title. Its a complete rehash of Halo 3 there is nothing majorly different about its values. Im pretty sure Jeff doesnt want to be looking for another job so soon im not oging to say he completely copped out but with all the things he writes that relates this game to being just a Halo 3 Expansion especially the points at which he says he felt like their trying to justify the price tag by adding additional content (Reach beta, Halo 3 Multiplyer) ontop of the game itself.  Im sorry but if he had that many complaints about the game how could it have possibly been a 4Star game? He even said its more of the same, how does more of the same correlate to a 4star game? This is a below the level rehash in my opinion instead of adding new features they took them from you. How is that a improvement on what has been proven to be a solid formula? Nonsense you people need to take a dose of reality for once and realize that even your almighty Jeff can sell out just a bit from time to time. For a person to have that many problems with a title and then give it a 4star is ridiculous. Oh Im going to say this a games price should also be considered apart of a review simply because its the value of the game; and the standalone ODST does not equal 60$ in my eyes. The fact that the developer tacked on extras shows how much confidence they have in the original product itself; very little.
Avatar image for deactivated-5f8ac39b52e76
deactivated-5f8ac39b52e76

2590

Forum Posts

1360

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 3

@tlt said:
" I think it worked with ad and review this time but what will happen if you sell ads for a bad game that should have one or two stars? "
That won't happen. They can simply opt to not review it at all - problem solved.
Avatar image for automaticsnake
AutomaticSnake

404

Forum Posts

9

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 2

Edited By AutomaticSnake

well looks like it sucks. trey 4 life!!!!!

Avatar image for tlt
tlt

13

Forum Posts

27

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By tlt

I think it worked with ad and review this time but what will happen if you sell ads for a bad game that should have one or two stars?

Avatar image for earthborn
Earthborn

395

Forum Posts

277

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 3

Edited By Earthborn
@Depeatch said:
"  I'm sorry but you're all over-board on the subject of critique and marketing.   These sites get paid by the gaming companies so that they give decent reviews.  This rings obvious and true when the game in question actually has paid advertisements on the site.  That was the whole problem with the Kane and Lynch situation on GameSpot.   These sites can never be unbiased because they'd end up biting the  hand that feeds them.   That's why these "journalists" (what a laugh) need to find alternative funding.   Some sites already have that but they're still restricted in the review process when it comes to games that companies have paid advertising for.  In other words, don't believe the hype, especially when you see adverts plastered for the game in question.    The only real reviewer, or perhaps the only honest video game reviewer out there is Yahtzee who utilizes his Zero Punctuation review format to get his point across.   You don't have to agree with what he has to say, but you can't deny that he's being totally honest and he's very uncompromising.   I'm sure he even cleans up some of the things that he would actually like to say about some games and the development choices made by some of these companies.  So back to the point, it doesn't really matter what the fuck Jeff says.  You either like his writing, agree with most of his opinions on games, or you don't.  Don't go believing that his view hasn't been compromised by the thought that these same companies are paying his bills though...  in other words, don't be idiots!  Wake up people. "
I'm not sure Yahtzee is being completely honest all the time. He's the king of embellishment, though. So if hyperbole is what you consider honest, I'm curious to hear what you think a lie is.
Avatar image for stinky
stinky

1564

Forum Posts

2

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By stinky

i think everyone is right to question the review, as they should always with any site. 
 
i love giantbomb. but i really think Bungie's marketing did a miss step here being so flagrant with the advertising. reskinning the entire page for the review? yikes.

that has to raise an eyebrow. 
 
but  to giantbomb, i say take the money and run. 

Avatar image for deactivated-5f8ac39b52e76
deactivated-5f8ac39b52e76

2590

Forum Posts

1360

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 3

@Depeatch said:

"he only real reviewer, or perhaps the only honest video game reviewer out there is Yahtzee who utilizes his Zero Punctuation review format to get his point across. "

You are not seriously preferring a youtube comedian over professionals who have years of experience with the business, are you?