Endurance Run: Persona 4 - Part 132

" @Scooper said:

" It's kinda sad how obviously Jeff has known who's the killer ect for a while now. I wish he was completely blank and hadn't been spoiled. "

Better this than them not knowing and getting the bad ending. "

" @sixghost said:

" @Scooper said:

" It's kinda sad how obviously Jeff has known who's the killer ect for a while now. I wish he was completely blank and hadn't been spoiled. "

Better this than them not knowing and getting the bad ending. "

No it is not.  I'd rather them get the bad ending and find out for themselves, giving natural reactions as opposed feigned ones.  They should have played this game how they would have without all of this help and spoiling. "

I imagined the game would be less obvious about who the kiiler is. All the sentences before it asked you for a name where so clearly saying it´s Adachi.
 
There were MULTIPLE POLICE CARS ALL OVER TOWN, but nobody saw the killer. Could it have been a cop, maybe?
 
He knows where you live, and he dropped the warning letter in without raising suspicion. Hey, what about the COP who has been coming to your house every week?
 
Ah, I´m just imagining things. It was the fat girl.

Ah, why'd you have to end it there!!

should of totally picked shu.

" @Scooper said:

" It's kinda sad how obviously Jeff has known who's the killer ect for a while now. I wish he was completely blank and hadn't been spoiled. "

Better this than them not knowing and getting the bad ending. "

 @Mysterysheep: Tomorrow's ep is going to have alot of exposition, so they want to save it for tomorrow's thrill ride.

I had it spoiled for me a long time ago, not through the comments but from searching this site.
 
Was interested in the Character at hand and so searched for his Character page on here where without warning it basically said "HE IS THE KILLER!". Was pretty pissed off to be honest, although I guess I shouldn't have been looking any of the characters up.

" @sixghost said:

" @Scooper said:

" It's kinda sad how obviously Jeff has known who's the killer ect for a while now. I wish he was completely blank and hadn't been spoiled. "

Better this than them not knowing and getting the bad ending. "

No it is not.  I'd rather them get the bad ending and find out for themselves, giving natural reactions as opposed feigned ones.  They should have played this game how they would have without all of this help and spoiling. "

" @Blair:  Do you even know he was spoiled about him? He may of gotten the hint way back when.  Also, GIant Bomb probably wouldn't of been as huge as a community 6 months ago. Numbers my friend, numbers.  Why don't you email them and ask if they knew about him? Maybe you can feel better knowing your heart was crushed sooner than later.  Don't mean to be a dick about this Blair but....BAWWWWWWWWWW  "

AWH MAN. Ended on such a tease. Longer episodes pleaaase.

Alot of you seem to forget that Adachi is with the team when Rise was kidnapped, so either you ruled him out there or you thought he was working with someone else.
 
Of course as soon as Namatame is confirmed to have kidnapped Rise it was fairly clear who the culprit was.

Wooooooo! was hoping we'd get the whole big scene in 1 great video. But all the more to look forward to tomorrow

" It sucks how painfully obvious the killer's identity is.  I havent played P4, but I knew about 30 or 40 hours in to the ER.  I dont know why writers think that making the culprit the "least likely" character works, but whatever.  I just hope that I am wrong. "

Well they are both on the same page now. Does it really matter anymore if jeff knew who the killer was? It was only recently that any of their reactions to the events of the game even dealt with the real killer.
 
@InvestigationTeam: why even tell them all that stuff, how bout they do things on their own now?

I'm just venting: I was at the point where there were going through all of the names and I got duder'd. So tense.

" It's kinda sad how obviously Jeff has known who's the killer ect for a while now. I wish he was completely blank and hadn't been spoiled. "

@InvestigationTeam: why even tell them all that stuff, how bout they do things on their own now? "

" @ZmillA said:

@InvestigationTeam: why even tell them all that stuff, how bout they do things on their own now? "

I agree, please stop controlling how they play and let them do things on their own. "

" @egads said:

" It sucks how painfully obvious the killer's identity is.  I havent played P4, but I knew about 30 or 40 hours in to the ER.  I dont know why writers think that making the culprit the "least likely" character works, but whatever.  I just hope that I am wrong. "

There is more to the mystery than just who the killer is. That is where the True Ending comes in. "

" It sucks how painfully obvious the killer's identity is.  I havent played P4, but I knew about 30 or 40 hours in to the ER.  I dont know why writers think that making the culprit the "least likely" character works, but whatever.  I just hope that I am wrong. "

Watching this part was somewhat more boring, as it's pretty obvious Jeff knew the whole time. 
 
A-anyways.. looking forward to tomorrow's episode.

" @toadstule said:

" @ZmillA said:

@InvestigationTeam: why even tell them all that stuff, how bout they do things on their own now? "

I agree, please stop controlling how they play and let them do things on their own. "

Exactly. "

No one is forcing them to play the exact way suggested in the comments. If they are willing to go to outside sources to help out, they would be capable of doing that whether or not people were posting suggestions in the comments.

Jeff and Vinny are big boys, they can decide how they want to play the game for themselves.

" @Blair said:

" @toadstule said:

" @ZmillA said:

@InvestigationTeam: why even tell them all that stuff, how bout they do things on their own now? "

I agree, please stop controlling how they play and let them do things on their own. "

Exactly. "

No one is forcing them to play the exact way suggested in the comments. If they are willing to go to outside sources to help out, they would be capable of doing that whether or not people were posting suggestions in the comments.

Jeff and Vinny are big boys, they can decide how they want to play the game for themselves.

"

Get the bad ending, it's definitely the best.  The story gets terrible when you do the good ending, and worse when you do the true ending and they draaaaaawwwwwww the story out as painfully long as they can. 

" I imagined the game would be less obvious about who the kiiler is. All the sentences before it asked you for a name where so clearly saying it´s Adachi.  There were MULTIPLE POLICE CARS ALL OVER TOWN, but nobody saw the killer. Could it have been a cop, maybe?  He knows where you live, and he dropped the warning letter in without raising suspicion. Hey, what about the COP who has been coming to your house every week?  Ah, I´m just imagining things. It was the fat girl. "

" @sixghost said:

" @Blair said:

" @toadstule said:

" @ZmillA said:

@InvestigationTeam: why even tell them all that stuff, how bout they do things on their own now? "

I agree, please stop controlling how they play and let them do things on their own. "

Exactly. "

No one is forcing them to play the exact way suggested in the comments. If they are willing to go to outside sources to help out, they would be capable of doing that whether or not people were posting suggestions in the comments.

Jeff and Vinny are big boys, they can decide how they want to play the game for themselves.

"

Good thing you said that, otherwise they wouldn't have known "

"You could easily have not taken ANY of the part-time jobs, therefore NONE of those characters could be the killer as you might not have ever met them.  With just those two criteria, only ONE of the characters on that list makes any sense whatsoever.

" @Ventilator said:

" I imagined the game would be less obvious about who the kiiler is. All the sentences before it asked you for a name where so clearly saying it´s Adachi.  There were MULTIPLE POLICE CARS ALL OVER TOWN, but nobody saw the killer. Could it have been a cop, maybe?  He knows where you live, and he dropped the warning letter in without raising suspicion. Hey, what about the COP who has been coming to your house every week?  Ah, I´m just imagining things. It was the fat girl. "

See, but all of that same evidence also points to Dojima.  Actually, if the player selects Dojima as the most likely culprit, the game explains how well he passes all the checks: the connections to the two victims, the ease with which he could have observed your actions and dropped the warning letters into your mailbox, and the fact that his position as a detective wouldn't arouse suspision.  The only thing that didn't add up was how dumbfounded he sounded when your character tries to explain Personas and the TV world to him.  But that could just have easily been an act, right? He's basically "the next best guess," but he ended up being my first choice when I played.  Lots of people would point out that he couldn't be the culprit after what happened to Nanako, but he still could have iced the first two victims before letting Namatame take over the kidnapping duties.  It wasn't until Nanako became a victim that Dojima would have had to draw the line and take Namatame down.  I'm probably reaching there on that last one, but... well it made sense to me at the time.  Luckilly the game gives you three chances to pick the right choice. "

" @ZmillA said:

" @sixghost said:

" @Blair said:

" @toadstule said:

" @ZmillA said:

@InvestigationTeam: why even tell them all that stuff, how bout they do things on their own now? "

I agree, please stop controlling how they play and let them do things on their own. "

Exactly. "

No one is forcing them to play the exact way suggested in the comments. If they are willing to go to outside sources to help out, they would be capable of doing that whether or not people were posting suggestions in the comments.

Jeff and Vinny are big boys, they can decide how they want to play the game for themselves.

"

Good thing you said that, otherwise they wouldn't have known "

I'm looking forward to their future posts complaining about the existance of internet FAQs if that's the case. "

oh sweet, there so close to the end now

I like how they give you the list of every single goddamn character you sneezed on as culprits for the case. I'm kinda bummed they didn't let you choose yourself, even if for a laugh. Go get whoever the killer is! Investigation Team Go!

hmmmm i cant wait to see how this one unfolds!

Damn it, guys...stop killing the fun of the ER.

" @sixghost said:

" @ZmillA said:

" @sixghost said:

" @Blair said:

" @toadstule said:

" @ZmillA said:

@InvestigationTeam: why even tell them all that stuff, how bout they do things on their own now? "

I agree, please stop controlling how they play and let them do things on their own. "

Exactly. "

No one is forcing them to play the exact way suggested in the comments. If they are willing to go to outside sources to help out, they would be capable of doing that whether or not people were posting suggestions in the comments.

Jeff and Vinny are big boys, they can decide how they want to play the game for themselves.

"

Good thing you said that, otherwise they wouldn't have known "

I'm looking forward to their future posts complaining about the existance of internet FAQs if that's the case. "

Why don't you just copy and paste an entire FAQ into the comments section for their next endurance run, you'd save them all of that time searching through individual comments.   You'd make pushing 'X' even less fun. "

There's already 2 different guides on their own website that explain how to get each ending. I'm not advocating the spoiling of the game to people, I'm just pointing out how futile it is to get mad at the people posting advice/spoilers in the comments when there are tons and tons of resources Vinny and Jeff could use to get the same information. And it honestly wouldn't be that hard for them to completely avoid all spoilers and help if they really wanted to.

I don't understand what the appeal is of seeing them playing through the game completely ignorant. Have you considered the possibility that Jeff and Vinny are just like the majority of gamers out there, and wanted to get the best ending?

Whoa, heavy, anyone think that maybe, they're cutting the episodes short, to stall the ending until friday???

" @sixghost: I think you're giving the killer too much credit here... he doesn't have any influence over who appears on the Midnight Channel.  That gets explained later. "

Well then the only other possibility is that the killer also watches the midnight channel, and murders whoever appears on it.  And I think it's pretty safe to assume Dojima wouldn't kill Nanako regardless of whether she appeared on it or not. Also, don't you think if Dojima was privy to the reality of the midnight channel, he would have been ultra-protective of Nanako in the time following he appearence on the channel, especially knowing that someone besides the killer was kidnapping the people appearing on the channel.

Whatever the relation is between the midnight channel and the victims/murderer is, i think it's pretty safe to assume that whoever was doing the killing was aware of the midnight channel, and I think Dojima's complete lack of response to Nanako appearing there rules him out.

Wonder what happens if you pick Chie as the culprit......
 
Steak Attack!

" Whoa, heavy, anyone think that maybe, they're cutting the episodes short, to stall the ending until friday??? "

" Whoa, heavy, anyone think that maybe, they're cutting the episodes short, to stall the ending until friday??? "

Oh that's great now where's ma Bombcast

And reading some of the stuff here...
 
We should let the staff know before any next ER is going to take place that the comment section should be blocked.
 
It´s for the greater good.

Hah I fucking knew it. YEAH. Straight out of an Agatha Christie novel. All this TV world shit is still yet to be explained, and why the fog has leaked out is another question.

You didn't ask the shopping woman the second question, you missed her the first time.  That's why you couldn't progress, didn't have to ask everyone the question twice.