@Moonshadow101 said:
@Berserker976: I've played over 100 hours of Morrowind in 2011 alone, and I can't even say how much before that, if we're going to get into that contest.
Now that I'm thinking about it more intensively, though, I think I might be a bit off here. It's possible that the limited amount of VO allowed for the impression of more variety, even if it was actually the same voice actor. I distinctly recall the female Dunmer having at least two modes of speech: the raspy one and the smooth one. It's possible that they were the same voice actor in different "modes," but they came off as being pretty different to me. Its possible that this effect would have been more difficult to sustain if the VO had been more extensive.
On the other hand, I really hope you're not seriously trying to say Oblivion was more varied. Oblivion had these voices: Male Elf, Female Elf, Male Breton/Imperial, Female Breton/Imperial, Male Orc/Nord, Female Orc/Nord, Male Khajiit/Argonian, Female Khajiit/Argonian. (Plus the uniques, of course). Oblivion was absolutely less varied.
You're a fair bit off in your list of Oblivion VA's. Breton and Imperial males had two different VA's, not the same one (only the females used the same VA between them). And you left out the Redguard male and female. There are 11 standard Oblivion voices, not 8 (there are 10 actual VA's, though, since the Nord/Orc and Khajiit/Argonian voices are done by the same actor).
Morrowind absolutely has the same voice for each race/gender, same as Oblivion, but it does have more variation in the voices because there is much less crossover between races. So you are correct that Oblivion was less varied.
Imperial male
Nord male
Orc male
Breton male
Redguard male
Khajiit/Argonian male
Dark Elf male
Wood Elf male
High Elf male
Imperial female
Nord female
Orc/Argonian female
Breton/High Elf female
Redguard female
Khajiit female
Dark Elf female
Wood Elf female
That's 18 voices, 15 actual VA's (Imperial and Dark Elf male voices were by the same actor, Orc and Breton male voices were by the same actor [the Imperial male in Oblivion], Argonian/Khajiit and Nord male voices were by the same VA that does them in Oblivion). That's still a far cry from this figure of 70 for Skyrim, though, and it's still doing the same thing that Oblivion did of having the same actor do every single member of a given race/gender.
Log in to comment