After finishing the game there are two things about the story that are really bugging me.
First off, Talbot. There are two points in the game where they seem to imply something is unusual about this character, both are in the section of the game that takes place in Syria. In the scene where Talbot drugs Cutter and takes his notebook he then walks into a small alcove out of sight of the three other characters and disappears. This seems in important because Drake specially remarks, "Where the hell did he go?" Naughty Dog clearly sets Talbot up to be a mysterious character, but vanishing like that in front of 3 people is far fetched and seems to imply something more. Then later on, Cutter shoots Talbot in the chest in one scene, but Talbot appear completely unharmed in a later one. Again the game highlights how this is strange, Cutter makes some remarks about it after he falls and breaks his leg. I guess he could be wearing a vest, but I could have sworn I saw blood from the bullet hit. In the end there is no payoff or explanation for either of these things, its really weird. I could see maybe suspension of disbelief for the disappearing thing, maybe he climbed the wall really fast, but getting shot in the chest and then being perfectly fine minutes later, no way.
Second, theres a brief scene in the France section where Drake and Sully find the corpse of one of the bad guys that appears to have been here for some time. In the scene they both remark how its weird that this guy is here. And thats it, again there's no payoff or explanation. It seems to set up that there is something strange about the bad guys, but then nothing is made of it. Are we supposed to assume the spiders got him or something? Only thing I can puzzle out is that they're supposed to be the same secret society that John Dee was in, so they already knew about the secret lab that was here. But then why did they just leave one of their dudes there dead? You'd think that they would be a bit more careful.
These two things bother me because the game seems to put them both into focus briefly, but then never does anything with them. This seems really odd for a Naughty Dog game as typically they are very careful with story details. It feels to me like there was something more to this but it was cut out.
Am I missing something here?
Log in to comment