So I made and ate the sandwich today.
 
I tried it with:
Capn Crunch
Rice Crispies
Oatmeal Crisp
 
I used blueberry jam instead of strawberry(which I believe is what was used in game). Oatmeal Crunch was the best of the single cereals but all 3 was the best over all.
 
 
 

Prop to you for making the sammich AND a video documenting it! I just might try it.

WTF Captaine Crounche?

That would be 'sandwich'.

" WTF Captaine Crounche? "

I prefer York's name for the sandwich: The Sinner's Sandwich.

" @Axxol said:

" WTF Captaine Crounche? "

I'm Canadian. "

THREE cereals in ONE sandwich are you crazy?

" @CoverlessTech said:

" @Axxol said:

" WTF Captaine Crounche? "

I'm Canadian. "

Oh okay. Do you think Peanut Butter Crunch would go great with jam? "

" THREE cereals in ONE sandwich are you crazy? "

" @ryanrulez said:

" THREE cereals in ONE sandwich are you crazy? "

I live on the edge. "

i dare you to make the broodwhich.   
 

I'm tempted to make that now.

Brb making sandwich

"Texture-ous" ? You done gone made a word.

" "Texture-ous" ? You done gone made a word. "

" @ryanrulez said:

" THREE cereals in ONE sandwich are you crazy? "

I live on the edge. "

I wanna have your bravery one day. "

" @TotalEklypse: 
Beelzebub is still in the bread making business? 
   

" @Axxol said:

" @CoverlessTech said:

" @Axxol said:

" WTF Captaine Crounche? "

I'm Canadian. "

Oh okay. Do you think Peanut Butter Crunch would go great with jam? "

Never been a big fan of Peanut Butter flavored cereal. But PBaJ is amazing. The only problem I see with it is the size though.   Could be good. "

" @Axxol said:

" @CoverlessTech said:

" @Axxol said:

" WTF Captaine Crounche? "

I'm Canadian. "

Oh okay. Do you think Peanut Butter Crunch would go great with jam? "

Never been a big fan of Peanut Butter flavored cereal. But PBaJ is amazing. The only problem I see with it is the size though.   Could be good. "

" THREE cereals in ONE sandwich are you crazy? "

I'm both tempted to try it, and horrified at what it sounds like at the same time. I'm conflicted.

SAMMICH!!! :D

Captain Crunch was exactly the cereal I pictured when this sandwich popped up in the endurance run. However, I'm too old school with sandwiches to try something so crazy. My sandwiches have cheese, turkey, lettuce and boring junk like that. Good show trying this crazy concoction out, though!

Made the sandwich with grape jelly instead because I have no strawberry. 
 
The sandwich RULES.

Awesome man. 
 
Oh and btw, I had a sandwich that consisted of 2 bread slices, 1 slice of cheese, and strawberry pixi-stick dust. It was faaaantastic...ly terrible.

Seriously though. Cheerios. It's all about Cheerios. This sandwhich with cheerios. Cheerios Cheerios Cheerios. 
 
 
Cheerios. Fucking, delicious. This is now my favourite sandwhich, ranking even above my personal creation The Awesome (2 slices granary/brown bread, toasted on outside, brown sauce on one, cream cheese on other. Filled with Bacon, lettuce, tomato slices and pickles. Named so, because it is fucking awesome).

" they should try the sandwhich on the podcast. also props for trieing it "

I applaud you on this, I'm half tempted to do this myself now (>_>)

LEGEND

" @kous18 said:

" they should try the sandwhich on the podcast. also props for trieing it "

Trying it on the podcast wouldn't be as good as them making a video of it.
 
@The_A_Drain: You tried it with Cheerios? Honey Nut or Regular? "

Props to the OP.
 
I'm tempted to try this with Cinnamon Toast Crunch, though I have no turkey.

Good work bro. I think it would be better with the jam and cornflakes on top though sort of like a frosting like it appears to be in the game. Also you should have had some ginger in between sandwiches to cleanse your palate. Otherwise an excellent taste test!

"Someone should be brave enough to take the black forest route and use Cocoa Puffs. "

" Br/b/ making sandwich "