Alan Wake or Red Dead Redemption (what to buy???)

ok i cant make my mind up on what game to buy what game should i buy.i like both titles but cant buy both.they both look really great.soo what do you think i should buy.also reasons for buying ether game is a plus.thanks

Red Dead Redemption.

Alan Wake.
 
Or both.
 
But probably Alan Wake.

Red Dead Redemption! Or both..

so RDR is kinda being more favored over Alan Wake.so on another point what has a longer story

If you want the most content for your dollar, go with Red Dead.

Well Red Dead Redemption is an open world game with a lot of content to do. I heard it's around 15-40 hours, depending on what you go for.
 
Meanwhile Alan Wake is a linear but very well put together story.
 
Fuckin hell I hate these threads, decide for yourself mang.

Ive been checking out the quick look of RDR and so far seems like i will probably buy RDR then alan wake.alan wake looks great and all by might be a short game with hardly any replay value.where RDR has a lot more to offer then just story with alot of side quest and other things like hunting and what not so i think im gonna go with RDR and pick up Alan wake some other time.thanks for your help :)

Bought RDR because of the replay value. I'll just wait awhile and get Alan Wake through Gamefly.

"

Red Dead Redemption.

"

Get RDR, alan wake just looks boring imo

Both.

Buy RDR and Rent Alan Wake

whatever you buy, make sure you PLAY Alan Wake. I'm almost done with it, and it might just have passed ME2 as my GOTY so far. Havent played RDR yet tho.

Both games are top notch.  
 
Horror or open world cowboy stuff.  
 
Red Dead gives more bang for the buck.  Will last a lot longer, has online ect ect
Alan Wake is just a spectacular game but it is more linear and has no online.  
 
I bought Split Second, RDR and Alan Wake.  Actually Split Second has been sucking me in the most.  Alan Wake has sucked me in really well.  RDR I started but I seem to be drawn to the others more.   But RDR is in the XBOX right now and I am about to play it also.  
 
Can't go wrong with either one but for value for the buck it is RDR all the way.  Why not wait 3 to 6 months and buy both when the price drops 50 percent. 

READ DEAD! 

Buy Red Dead, rent Alan Wake.  Alan Wake seems cool and all but not long enough to justify 60 bucks.

Alan Wake is one of the best games I've played.

  @KnifeySpoony said:

"Fuckin hell I hate these threads, decide for yourself mang. "

I plan on getting both. I think Red Dead Redemption should last you a bit longer though, however Alan Wake also looks fkn amazing.