If I could only pick one game...

Allright, if you guys could pick only ONE game to have this time of year (new releases and such) which game would you buy? 
 
I don't have as much time for gaming as I used to. So I kinda wanna get some bang for my buck. Do you think Borderlands might be my best bet?  (I love me some co-op and I love guns, I mean who doesn't love guns?! Hippies, that's who)
 
Give me your opinions
 
Love,
Justin... Sala..
 
EDIT Shit, sorry, I forgot I only have 360/PC/DS!  But if you would still like to voice your opinion on other systems, please be my guest!

Tough Pick.
 
I'd either go with Borderlands, or Brutal Legend.
MAYBE Uncharted 2.

Had I played the first Uncharted, I'd say Uncharted 2. 
 
Brutal Legend is great, but unless you have a love for RTS it probably won't have that much sticking power. 
  
So I'd say Borderlands, or maybe hold out for Modern Warfare 2.

Left 4 dead 2 is coming.

Dragon Age Origins is interesting me the most at the moment, but I have to say I'm not impressed with the visuals. 

" @DanielJW:  Yeah my only problem is that I've been reading Brutal Legend's single player (My main interest in that game) is only like 6 hours long... I feel like that game warrants a rental. Man, I love Tim Schafer so much it makes me sad that I don't want to buy that game so much. "

" Dragon Age Origins is interesting me the most at the moment, but I have to say I'm not impressed with the visuals.  "

Modern Warfare 2 for sure.

L4D2 or MW2. Both are co-op games with guns.
 
EDIT: By that I mean MW2 has a co-op mode.

I'm not sure...Borderlands, L4D2?

Uncharted 2 right now, amazing game.

Dragon Age: Origins.

Modern Warfare 2.

From the games that were released this year, I would have a tough time picking between Batman: Arkham Asylum and Uncharted 2, but I think I'd take Uncharted. For games to come, definitely Assassin\s Creed 2.

I'd have to go with Borderlands. You will most definitely get your money's worth.  Although Dragons Age will also be a good one, tough decision you have to make.

Even though it isn't out for a few more weeks, Modern Warfare 2.

Modern Warfare 2

as it stands right now, Uncharted 2.  
 
Although you are gonna get more longevity from MW2.

Demon's Souls
Because I like causing myself to become incredibly angry at video games. :)

Uncharted 2

Forza or Tekken could last me all winter. Toss up, but I'll go with Forza.

I think if you dig multiplayer games then go for either Borderlands or Left 4 Dead 2 but if you don't really care for multiplayer games then go for Batman Arkham Asylum.

" I think if you dig multiplayer games then go for either Borderlands or Left 4 Dead 2 but if you don't really care for multiplayer games then go for Batman Arkham Asylum. "

I'm getting Borderlands and Dragon Age, so my suggestion is one of those.

It's a tie between Bad Company 2, MW 2, and Assassin's Creed 2

If you play online, Modern Warfare 2.  If that's not your thing, then Borderlands or maybe Assassin's Creed 2.