Recommend a game based on previous poster's top 3 faves

I'm thinking it might be fun to share some recommendations based on each other's favourite games.

HOW IT WORKS:

- List your top 3 favourite games of all time

- Recommend a game you think the previous poster would enjoy, based on his/her top 3 favourites.

- If someone recommends a game for you that you've already played, reply to that post, stating what you thought about the recommended game.

I'll get this ball rolling!

1. Shadow of the Colossus

2. Journey

3. Final Fantasy IX

ps: try not to be too obvious with your suggestions: if someone says Half LIfe 2 is their fave game, assume they've probably played episodes 1 and 2, along with HL1. Or in my example, obviously I've played/love ICO, Flower and most FF titles :P

@RainVillain:

Ys: Origins or Ys: The Oath in Felghana. You can get them on Steam for really cheap and they are awesome. They have the JRPG mechanics similar to FF9, great visuals, and incredible combat.

1) Doom

2) Lunar 2: Eternal Blue

3) King's Field 2

Quake. You've probably already played that, but anyway, you never know...
 
1. Company of Heroes: Tales of Valor
2. Grand Theft Auto IV
3. Call of Duty: Black Ops

I'll have a guess, have you played Brothers in Arms?

1) Persona 4

2) Final Fantasy X

3) Mass Effect 2

Kinda obvious I love RPGs.

Post edit:

@Timing: Good call, played the game and loved it. Very old school but definitely worth it.

I'll have a guess, have you played Brothers in Arms?

@VaddixBell said:

1) Persona 4

2) Final Fantasy X

3) Mass Effect 2

Have you played Lost Odyssey? If not, maybe you should.

Okay now do me.

1. Paper Mario
2. Demon's Souls
3. Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon

Hmm, Dragons Dogma?

1. X-Com (UFO DEFENSE)

2. Starcraft Broodwar

3. Baldurs Gate 2

@JacobShOckgosu said:

Hmm, Dragons Dogma?

1. X-Com (UFO DEFENSE)

2. Starcraft Broodwar

3. Baldurs Gate 2

Front Mission, the original one on the DS

Metroid Prime, Shadow of the Colossus, and Metal Gear Solid.

@BoG:

Majora's Mask? Because of the atmosphere running through them?

As for me...

1. Fire Emblem: Seisen no Keifu
2. Super Smash Bros. Brawl
3. Conker's Bad Fur Day

And as an added rule, no Nintendo games. Can't use that as your basis.

@Video_Game_King: For some reason Command and Conquer: Red Alert 3 comes to mind.

• Portal 2
• Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge
• Mass Effect 2

...no I don't know why they're all sequels. Just seemed like the best cross-section of my favourites I could think of.

@devotfeige: Hmmm... you seem to like puzzles, with a good dose of narrative and character development. I was going to say Shadow of the Colossus but I bet you've already played it. How about Jeanne D'Arc instead?

My top three are all over the place.

• Valkyria Chronicles
• GTA Vice City
• Need For Speed High Stakes.

@mosespippy:

Hmmm...Midnight Club Los Angeles?

For me:

1) Max Payne 2

2) Half Life

3) The longest Journey

Bioshock?

- Max Payne

- GTA: San Andreas

- Mass Effect 2

I'm bumpimg this thread because I think it's a cool thread that not a lot of people saw.

@Daiphyer: I'll assume you've already played the other Rockstar open world games like Red Dead Redemption and Bully so why not try Borderlands?

Um...well, I'm just going to post my list, since there's no one before me >_>

1. Bioshock
2. System Shock 2
3. Braid

@BeachThunder: Dark Messiah of Might and Magic

• The Command and Conquer games before EA got their filthy hands on them
• Dragon Age: Origins
• Final Fantasy Tactics Advance

• Persona 4
• Red Dead Revolver

• Kenka Bancho

Dragon Quest VIII

1. Kingdom Hearts

2. Half-Life 2

3. StarCraft 2

@GunslingerPanda: Hmm, you seem to like strong narrative with action elements (while digging a casual RPG experience.) I'd say check out The Witcher 2.

1. Battlefield: 1942
2. Age of Empires 3
3. Lunar: The silver star story complete

And P.S....I'm not a fan of modern shooters per se. So no Call of Duty for me.