#1 Edited by Atary77 (502 posts) -

So here's something I thought might be a little fun for the forum. Basically how this works is that you'll see a game title suggested in the very last post and you have to say one positive thing and one negative thing about it. After that you give the title of the next game you want the person after you to comment on.

I will say while the positive and negative comments can be brief I'd prefer that people don't simply post "This game sucks" or "It's just Awesome". Just don't be vague.

Since I'm starting I'll just give and example like say a previous post said

Transformers: Fall of Cybertron

Then I'd simply post

+ Great fan service with call backs and homages to Generation 1

- No local multiplayer

and finally I'll give a game title that I'll want the person after me to post one negative and one positive comment about to start this ball a rolling!

Twisted Metal (PS3)

#2 Edited by csl316 (10046 posts) -


I spent the whole Twisted Metal TNT playing with the crew and it was amazing (my only TNT experience).

But I wasn't as big on the art and music. Just didn't have the charm of that 90's Singletrac sound.

Up next:

The Simpsons Game!

#3 Edited by connerthekewlkid (1844 posts) -

The gameplay was kinda bland, but the writing was like a really good episode of the show. Big Rigs

#4 Posted by Video_Game_King (36272 posts) -

Big Rigs:

+ It is a game.

- That game happens to be Big Rigs.

Master of Epic.

#5 Edited by connerthekewlkid (1844 posts) -

-Seems pretty generic for an MMO +Seems pretty Kawaii. Chaos Wars

#6 Posted by Jozo (11 posts) -

Chaos Wars:

- Appalling voice acting.

+ Appalling voice acting is worth a good laugh.

The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct.

#7 Posted by dagas (2970 posts) -

The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct.

+ It is the Walking Dead!

- It is the bad Walkind Dead game.

Persona 4 Golden

#8 Edited by Emoney244 (167 posts) -

Persona 4 Golden

+ Kanji is cool.

- Rise is annoying.


#9 Posted by Glottery (1423 posts) -


+ Looks...well, if not pretty, then at least somewhat unique from what I've seen.

- Has a very odd sense of hum...oh wait, I was actually thinking about Killer Is Dead, not Killer7. Well shit, let's just leave it to nice visuals then.

Syndicate (The FPS)

#10 Posted by Captain_Felafel (1622 posts) -

Syndicate (FPS)

+ Is an awesome cyber-punk game, which there aren't enough of.

- Is not Syndicate.

Pokémon X/Y

#11 Posted by BeachThunder (12739 posts) -

Pokémon X/Y

+ It seems to have kept the rabid fans happy

- They replaced the wonderful pixel art with polygons. Boo-urns.

Limbo of the Lost

#12 Edited by GnaTSoL (836 posts) -

Limbo of the Lost

+ Been to limbo. Nice place..... I'm there right now.

-- its a point n click adventure. That's why it gets a double negative.

SUPER METROID!!!!!!!! There is no negative people. ;-)

#13 Posted by Sinusoidal (2029 posts) -

+ It's Super Metroid.

- Nintendo followed it up with the worst Metroid game: Other M.

Dark Souls!

#14 Posted by mercutio123 (473 posts) -

+Vinny loves it

- its a bad game

Burnout Paradise

#15 Posted by TheManWithNoPlan (6172 posts) -

+ 60 frames a second and almost perfect driving control/ It still holds up remarkably well

- There's no direct sequel in the foreseeable future.

Dead Space

#16 Posted by BeachThunder (12739 posts) -

+ Great atmosphere, the closest thing to a third-person SS2.

- Lots of cheap jump scares.


#17 Edited by Sanj (2623 posts) -

- Stereotypes Mexicans

+ Mexican stereotypes


#18 Edited by Ghostiet (5509 posts) -

+ It's a very well made game in all regards.

- The plot, while epic in scale, seems underdeveloped and too short.

Jak II

#19 Posted by connerthekewlkid (1844 posts) -

+Great Platforming - Sewer Level

Record of Agarest War

#20 Edited by PinkFloydPLA (26 posts) -

+Hot Anime Girls

-Almost Naked Underage Anime Girls

Return to Castle Wolfenstein

#21 Edited by Atary77 (502 posts) -

Return to Castle Wolfenstien

+ Satisfying FPS game play and action!

- Rather than screaming at you in German, the Nazi's scream at you in German accented English which just seems silly.

Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King

#22 Edited by Nekroskop (2786 posts) -

+DBZ inspired characters

-DBZ inspired characters

Hotline Miami

#23 Posted by peritus (1091 posts) -

+ Great soundtrack

- Repetitive gameplay

Dragon's Dogma

#24 Edited by TurboMan (7866 posts) -

+ Surprisingly fun game

- AI is insanely dumb

The Lost Vikings

#25 Edited by BillyMaysRIP (325 posts) -

+Great Puzzles to play on a rainy day and space vikings

-Distinctly average in most respects, with no replay value at all

Shining Force 2

#26 Posted by MegaDigim (2 posts) -

+Really interesting plot

-Translation isn't very good.

Metal Gear Solid 4

#27 Edited by Ramone (2989 posts) -

+Kojima somehow managed to wrap all that crazy shit up

-Snake should have killed himself

The Last of Us

#28 Edited by MaxOpower (244 posts) -

+ Great story. With some of the strongest individual scenes of the generation. It both ends and begins better than maybe any other games ever.

+Great gameplay loops. "Fun" combat, with a lot of variety.

+Amazing world, with great exploration.

- TOO LONG. Well, too much filler.

- Repeating ladder and water crossing puzzles.


#29 Edited by Grissefar (2830 posts) -

+ Some fantasical elements that can be amusing

- Terribly tedious game design all around

Trash Panic

#30 Edited by MikkaQ (10346 posts) -

+ Absurd and amazing and fun

- Unnecessarily difficult and unreasonable

Marc Ecko's Getting Up: Contents Under Pressure

#31 Edited by connerthekewlkid (1844 posts) -

+Pretty Cool spraying mechanic like JSR

- Stealth was kinda broke

Hatoful Boyfriend

#32 Edited by Ramone (2989 posts) -

+ Funny as hell

- Creepy as fuck

Ni No Kuni

#33 Posted by Kidavenger (3682 posts) -

-Beautiful art design

-Obtuse combat


#34 Edited by Whamola (133 posts) -

Puzzle games are cool.

Phone games suck.

Shellshock: Nam '67

#35 Posted by bluefish (591 posts) -

- Woefully poor as a game while being disrespectful to people still suffering as a result of the war

+ Jungles

Geometry Wars

#36 Edited by beard_of_zeus (1715 posts) -

+ A timeless twin-stick shooter with a fantastic aesthetic.

- Not a ton of content to it, the gameplay has a pretty narrow scope.


#37 Edited by Jocund (125 posts) -

+ That motherfucking soundtrack is phenomenal.

- While the story, characters and setting are exceptionally well-realized, playing the game is a bit dull.


#38 Edited by Tonylope (194 posts) -

+ A consistently funny and enjoyable platformer.

- The meat circus (at least in it's original incarnation).

Tomb Raider: Legend

#39 Posted by Shaunage (752 posts) -

+ An enjoyable return to form for the series that changed core mechanics in smart ways.

- But man, is it short.

Killzone 2

#40 Edited by OrangeSponge (51 posts) -
#41 Posted by Inkerman (1455 posts) -

Godzilla: Destroy All Monsters Melee

+ It's a Godzilla game!

- Man...that box art.

The Sims

#42 Edited by RPGee (763 posts) -

The Sims

+ For a lot of kids at its release, it was pretty much the Minecraft of its time in terms of how many people played it and shared rad stories (or at least it seems like that in retrospect).

- It could feel either too slow in the progressive building up of resources, or too fast by cheating and breaking it.

Fragile Dreams: Farewell Ruins of the Moon.

#43 Posted by CooVee (146 posts) -

Fragile Dreams: Farewell Ruins of the Moon

+ Interesting storyline and overall unique experience.

- Combat isn't great and the inventory management could be better.

Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon

#44 Posted by Video_Game_King (36272 posts) -

+Pretty damn funny

-I think it was difficult?

Tarot Mystery

#45 Posted by Example1013 (4807 posts) -


#46 Posted by Video_Game_King (36272 posts) -

I did it! I broke the chain!

#47 Posted by Example1013 (4807 posts) -

No, I broke the chain. This whole thread is a shining example of why forum games aren't allowed on this site.

#48 Edited by StarvingGamer (8704 posts) -

This thread

+ A fun exercise in saying something nice and obscure game recall

- Like all things internet related, brings out the trolls


#49 Edited by weegieanawrench (1945 posts) -


+ Looks like a neat Fortune Street-esque rpg hybrid with monster fightin'

- The Mystic Egg stares into my soul. Now it stares into yours.

Max Payne 1

#50 Edited by Lydian_Sel (2506 posts) -