I took Taekwondo for about 5 belts and stripes, shoto ryu karate for a few stripes and Kung Fu for a few sashes. All told I have about 7-8 years of adult martial arts experience, with two of those disciplines happening concurrently.
What kind of martial art you want to pick depends on a few things, in my opinion.
1) your body type
2) your level of dedication
3) your intended results
4) your propensity to get bored.
Taekwondo is one of the most popular and cheapest martial arts available because of how easy it is. It's extremely geometric and easy to learn and practice. (the geometric thing will make sense once you start learning an art). With the way you describe your body type, this is a perfect art for you. TKD emphasizes leg work more than anything, and as a result, long legged practitioners will often have an advantage. i had a stubby roomate, one time, though, who took thsi art for a number of years only to realize it was useless to him because of his body type. He literally couldn't touch his toes let alone kick someone above the knee.
Shoto Ryu karate was an unconventional martial art that was much more holistic and practical than TKD. Karate is an art that will build serious, practical martial arts skills into you that will last your entire life and help you in literally every single thing you do for the rest of your life. The problem is that it's not very flashy and gets boring fairly quickly.
Kung Fu is, by far, my favorite martial art and the art I would reccomend anyone take. The problem is that it's far less common than any other art I know of and tends to be the most expensive take. It's one of the most holistic martial arts I know of and as a result, almost anyone can learn and benefit from it. The downside is that it requires you to be in the best shape of any art I know of. We would spend a half hour during every class just doing stances, which can be painful and boring. One, the cross sit, is literally the stance Chun Li takes in her ducking animation for SF3. Think about doing that in like 3 minute intervals for 10 minutes, every other day. Ugh. But learning the forms is an absolutely blast and you feel like you're really doing an art, not just learning to fight. Kung Fu also integrates the most fun weapons I know of such as nunchaku and chinese sword. Kung Fu teaches you a variety of strikes that goes way beyond what you learn in other arts. Seriously I learned about 10x the number of strikes in Kung Fu than I did in TKD or Karate. And in an actual fight, the number of strikes you are comfortable with makes all the difference.
I know MMA is the popular thing right now, but I hate the "bro-ishness" of it. I want to learn an art and the things that go along with it like breathing techniques, biology, healing techniques, balance techniques, etc. I don't just want to puch a tire for 30 minutes pretending it's some guys face.
But, to each his own, I guess.
Log in to comment