I think that part of what murderbunny might be getting at is that, if someone is getting basically universal praise from your peers, then writing a piece which is positive towards them seems "safe" and kind of like the writer is just joining the choir. I totally get what you're saying though - that you get a lot of flak for some of the pieces you write from readers (I heard you ruined GB singlehandedly! ;)), so they're not at all "safe" in the sense that you're writing something which will get you nothing but props from people who read it.
The other thing I think murderbunny is saying is - if you look at someone like Anita Sarkeesian, one would generally think that at least someone who writes for a game website would disagree with her arguments (and write about that), just by sheer probability. But that hasn't really happened (not on any sites I follow, at least), which makes it easy to start writing off the people who praise her work as being a chorus of yes-men simply because you haven't seen any dissenting opinions. I think that your point is totally fair that as a writer, you're going to write from a perspective that is colored by your own opinions on things. It's unavoidable, and I don't think it's any writer's fault that they do so. But I also can understand the frustration that can result from feeling (albeit unfairly) that "man, all these writers are tripping over themselves to agree with Anita, and nobody actually critically examines her arguments and points out the flaws in them" (or any other controversial figure, of course, not trying to single out one person in particular here).
I think you see mostly unanimous praise for Anita's work because it's largely unprecedented. It's A New Idea. That takes time to sink in. I hadn't uttered the word feminism in a serious context until a few years ago. My views on many things will probably change a few years from now, once I've learned more and had a chance to process more. I mean, there's already plenty of challenges to Anita's viewpoints about Bayonetta. Lots of women view Bayonetta as a strong, sexually-empowered character, but Anita doesn't. That seems pretty divergent!
That's a good point, and definitely an angle which had never occurred to me before. Gives me something to think about, thanks!
Even if you are still a Bears fan, and I am required by Wisconsin law to profess loud public hatred for you. ;)
Log in to comment