Epic Games announced today that fans of the Gears of War series will have the opportunity to decide the fate of the Carmine brother in the upcoming sequel. Fans can cast their vote by purchasing one of two avatar t-shirts available in the marketplace on July 29th. While this feels like a cash grab, all proceeds will go to the Child's Play Charity.

     This of course, raises two questions. First and foremost, should Clayton Carmine live or die? There are four Carmine brothers in the Gears universe and one has died in each game thus far. Should history repeat itself or should the finale be marked with a living Carmine?  
 
     Question number two: Should fans be allowed to decide the fate of any characters? Gears is not Mass Effect, with infintie choices and a uniquely shaped storyline. Epic has shown themselves capable in the storyline department with the first two entires in the series, especially the second game. Is this necessary? Like many avid gamers, I know what I like and I know what I want, and personally I'd be more comfortable with any direction Epic took here.  Gamers don't need another debate to yell at each other over.

Perhaps this stems from my concern other companies might see the buzz and possible revenue such a move might generate and emulate it. I think everyone has an example of taking an idea too far. I simply hope that video games don't become 'choose your adventure' novels months before their release date.