I don't think that horror games necessarily have to incorporate bad gameplay to make them scary. For example, FEAR1 for me at least was somewhat horrifying especially on the first playthrough. There was a bit of a dichotomy between the great fps gameplay which was tense in its own right and the creepy paranormal parts. The STALKER series on PC has had some great horror moments such as lab x16 etc while having good gameplay. I would say that atmosphere is the most crucial aspect of a horror game. You can make a game that has good action combat and smart puzzle solving but it must be paced correctly. The player needs to feel vulnerable at all times as well. I don't think horror games are going anywhere soon and welcome them if they have good gameplay. However, they must retain the pacing and atmosphere of the old classic horror games.
Log in to comment