People actually don't like the Galactic Punt?!

Avatar image for papercut
Posted by papercut (4079 posts) -

An acquaintance of mine had just started to play Persona 4 for the first time and yesterday I got some shocking news. This person, if you can even call it that, did not like the galactic punt! No, just...no. That isn't possible. How can that be possible?!

The scum's defense for this blasphemy was that in performing the move the end result was less Exp. at the end of battles. As a result, he never let Chie do it anymore.

In my head I thought to tell the ignorant slut that in Persona 4, compared to Persona 3, it is much easier to grind for Exp. since there is no game mechanic that stops you from running through the dungeons like there was in P3 with the risk of getting tired and sick. At worst you run out of SP but at a certain point you can just pay Fox if you are somehow incredibly under leveled.

This is what I should of said. Instead the rage overtook my body and I woke up the the next day with a mixture of mud and blood dried to the insides of my fingernails. Also I can't find my shovel or my bag of lime.

Weird.

Just thought you guys may be interested that there are were people like this out there in the world.

Avatar image for papercut
#1 Posted by papercut (4079 posts) -

An acquaintance of mine had just started to play Persona 4 for the first time and yesterday I got some shocking news. This person, if you can even call it that, did not like the galactic punt! No, just...no. That isn't possible. How can that be possible?!

The scum's defense for this blasphemy was that in performing the move the end result was less Exp. at the end of battles. As a result, he never let Chie do it anymore.

In my head I thought to tell the ignorant slut that in Persona 4, compared to Persona 3, it is much easier to grind for Exp. since there is no game mechanic that stops you from running through the dungeons like there was in P3 with the risk of getting tired and sick. At worst you run out of SP but at a certain point you can just pay Fox if you are somehow incredibly under leveled.

This is what I should of said. Instead the rage overtook my body and I woke up the the next day with a mixture of mud and blood dried to the insides of my fingernails. Also I can't find my shovel or my bag of lime.

Weird.

Just thought you guys may be interested that there are were people like this out there in the world.

Avatar image for immortalsaiyan
#2 Posted by ImmortalSaiyan (4748 posts) -

I see where he is coming form but Galactic punt is too amazing to care about a bit of XP.

Avatar image for linkster7
#3 Posted by linkster7 (1226 posts) -

But she's so excited how could one possibly say no?

Avatar image for mosespippy
#4 Posted by mosespippy (4748 posts) -

Chie is a starting character. She's weak in the end game so she's easy to not use.

Avatar image for infinitegeass
#5 Posted by InfiniteGeass (2150 posts) -

I don't much care for Chie at all to be honest.

Avatar image for winternet
#6 Posted by Winternet (8377 posts) -

@mosespippy said:

Chie is a starting character. She's weak in the end game so she's easy to not use.

@InfiniteGeass said:

I don't much care for Chie at all to be honest.

You guys are bat shit crazy.

Online
Avatar image for yi_orange
#7 Posted by YI_Orange (1326 posts) -

Galactic Punt is cool, but Yukiko's too useful, Yosuke is my bro, and Kanji is Kanji, so I never used Chie anyway. I can understand not using Galactic Punt.

Avatar image for eviltwin
#8 Posted by EvilTwin (3316 posts) -
@mosespippy said:

Chie is a starting character. She's weak in the end game so she's easy to not use.

Err, what?  She's weak in mid game.  Power charge + God's Hand rules end game.
Avatar image for coakroach
#9 Posted by coakroach (2497 posts) -

If you dont like Chie or how she rolls you can eat shit and die.

Avatar image for iburningstar
#10 Posted by IBurningStar (2267 posts) -

If someone doesn't like Galactic Punt then I don't like them.

Avatar image for hailinel
#11 Posted by Hailinel (25787 posts) -

@mosespippy said:

Chie is a starting character. She's weak in the end game so she's easy to not use.

Man, what.

Avatar image for mosespippy
#12 Posted by mosespippy (4748 posts) -

@EvilTwin: Naoto's Mind Charge/Megidolaon is my jam. With Teddie as the stronger healer I don't need another Ice caster so Chie gets sidelined after Teddie joins.

Avatar image for hailinel
#13 Posted by Hailinel (25787 posts) -

@mosespippy said:

@EvilTwin: Naoto's Mind Charge/Megidolaon is my jam. With Teddie as the stronger healer I don't need another Ice caster so Chie gets sidelined after Teddie joins.

Chie isn't a long-term ice character, anyway. Her most powerful attacks are physical skills. She's only meant to fill the gap ice element-specific character until you get Teddie.

Avatar image for mikefightnight
#14 Edited by MikeFightNight (1181 posts) -

I can't min/max games like that, I just don't care enough, especially if I am doing it at the expense fun. If seeing something as awesome and endearing as the Galactic Punt means less xp then be it.

Avatar image for bigheart711
#15 Posted by Bigheart711 (1272 posts) -

Actually, I'm fine with using the Galactic Punt regardless of EXP gain. That's because my team has one less shadow to deal with if it's triggered. Also, Chie's really way more of a physical user than a magic user, so it's okay to scrap her bufu spells once Teddie joins in.

Avatar image for daveg_DEFUNCT
#16 Posted by daveg (46 posts) -

Kanji vastly outdmgs Chie at end game.

Avatar image for mraristocrates
#17 Edited by MrAristocrates (196 posts) -

I got pissed when using Galactic Punt recently because I was grinding item drops for a quest, and she Punted one of the enemies that dropped the item.

EDIT: Chie is also not that great in the mid-to-endgame. She has basically one move to justify using her, and Kanji is just an all-around better character.

Avatar image for laserbolts
#18 Posted by laserbolts (5506 posts) -

Why are people treating persona 4 like it's a difficult game where min/maxing is relevant?

Avatar image for narx
#19 Posted by Narx (195 posts) -

When a woman kicks a 20 feet tall robot out into space...

it's always worth it

Avatar image for natetodamax
#20 Posted by natetodamax (19462 posts) -

Chie sucks, duder.

Avatar image for irvandus
#21 Posted by Irvandus (3170 posts) -

@IBurningStar said:

If someone doesn't like Galactic Punt then I don't like them.
Avatar image for mutha3
#22 Edited by mutha3 (5050 posts) -

@papercut said:

The scum's defense for this blasphemy was that in performing the move the end result was less Exp. at the end of battles. As a result, he never let Chie do it anymore.

Hm? I'm pretty sure that shit ain't true, your friend is crazy!

@mosespippy said:

@EvilTwin: Naoto's Mind Charge/Megidolaon is my jam. With Teddie as the stronger healer I don't need another Ice caster so Chie gets sidelined after Teddie joins.

That is the worst jam possible, son. Naoto is a tremendous SP hog, and she loses out in the damage department to every other character.....even with Mind charge+Megidolan. She's OK for random encouters, but boss battles?

@mosespippy said:

Chie is a starting character. She's weak in the end game so she's easy to not use.

Chie is one of the best in the endgame. Its the middle-game where she blows.....to be fair "the middle-game" means 80% of the game's length in this context, but still!

Avatar image for siroptimusprime
#24 Edited by SirOptimusPrime (2043 posts) -

Chie is a good character, but a meh character for battle. I prefer Kanji in just about every way possible, and I use the MC for Ice spells by that point.

However, some dude rocking Naoto for boss battles? Yo, that's insane. She's an item-user/assist character for boss battles for me. However, for randoms, she's literally one of the best characters in the game with the SP-halver and dark/light spells. Grinding/Dungeon runnin' takes minutes.

Avatar image for tehflan
#25 Posted by TehFlan (1954 posts) -

Dude be trippin.

Avatar image for dagbiker
#26 Posted by Dagbiker (7038 posts) -

I played p3&p4; the right way, with a gameshark.

Avatar image for silvaruslupus
#27 Edited by SilvarusLupus (313 posts) -

@mutha3 said:

@mosespippy said:

@EvilTwin: Naoto's Mind Charge/Megidolaon is my jam. With Teddie as the stronger healer I don't need another Ice caster so Chie gets sidelined after Teddie joins.

That is the worst jam possible, son. Naoto is a tremendous SP hog, and she loses out in the damage department to every other character.....even with Mind charge+Megidolan. She's OK for random encouters, but boss battles?

I used Naoto on the last boss, true ending boss, and had no SP problems. It also helps to get the item that halves SP cost. Did the final boss with Naoto, Chie, and Yukiko.

Also, Naoto is amazing for random encounters. There are quite a few enemies weak to light and dark when you first get her and not having any weaknesses right off the bat is a big plus for me.

Avatar image for commisar123
#28 Posted by Commisar123 (1926 posts) -

Eisenhorn says burn the heretic

Avatar image for arbitrarywater
#29 Posted by ArbitraryWater (14472 posts) -

@laserbolts said:

Why are people treating persona 4 like it's a difficult game where min/maxing is relevant?

This. If Vinny and Jeff can stumble their way through Persona 4 on normal difficulty, not understanding some fairly basic gameplay concepts until a few dozen hours in, then it doesn't really matter that Chie is technically the worst party member for most of the game because the game isn't some sort of insurmountable obstacle to begin with. If anything, min/maxing kind of ruined Skyrim for me because of how easy it got by the end, when I was one-shotting people with 15x backstabs and basically otherwise being invisible

Avatar image for shirogane
#30 Posted by Shirogane (3620 posts) -

Oh wow, it does? I never realised that. I thought it counted as an instant kill, not eject from battle.

Avatar image for mutha3
#31 Posted by mutha3 (5050 posts) -

@ArbitraryWater said:

@laserbolts said:

Why are people treating persona 4 like it's a difficult game where min/maxing is relevant?

This. If Vinny and Jeff can stumble their way through Persona 4 on normal difficulty, not understanding some fairly basic gameplay concepts until a few dozen hours in, then it doesn't really matter that Chie is technically the worst party member for most of the game because the game isn't some sort of insurmountable obstacle to begin with. If anything, min/maxing kind of ruined Skyrim for me because of how easy it got by the end, when I was one-shotting people with 15x backstabs and basically otherwise being invisible

Eh, I think that's more a sign of the game being well-balanced than it being easy. The game is actually fairy challenging by the genre's standard. Its no Nocturne or whatever, but its no final fantasy either.

Also, Jeff and Vinny had people writing long paragraphs of text explaining what they did wrong on a weekly basis. And they read it.

Also, min-maxing is fun.

Avatar image for vexxan
#32 Posted by Vexxan (4631 posts) -

Always be Galactic Punting. Who cares about the XP, it's all about the animation!

Avatar image for vyse
#33 Posted by Vyse (76 posts) -

Once Kanji and Teddie come into the picture, Chie just doesn't cut it for me. I think Galactic punk is an awesome looking skill, but I think Kanji's Hit-All Insta-Knockdown move is much better (I forget its name). Not to mention that Kanji is a better character overall since he gets access to all levels of Zio and he has good psychical attacks.

I just rolled with Yousuke, Teddie, and Kanji throughout and had little to no problems. Still, this is probably the easiest SMT game so you can probably go with any group and still do fine.

Avatar image for milkman
#34 Posted by Milkman (18856 posts) -

Kill this person.

Avatar image for quististrepe
#35 Posted by QuistisTrepe (633 posts) -

@EvilTwin said:

@mosespippy said:

Chie is a starting character. She's weak in the end game so she's easy to not use.

Err, what? She's weak in mid game. Power charge + God's Hand rules end game.

Those attacks don't matter much if she lacks the attack power to put them to use. Even power charge doesn't make a significant difference.

Avatar image for chop
#36 Edited by Chop (2012 posts) -

Chie is the most effective physical party member end game. Kanji can out damage her but you end up having to heal him every round...

Anyways, I agree with the others. Persona 4 isn't the type of game where you have to worry about having an optimal party or the most exp. YOUR FRIEND IS CRAZY.

Avatar image for eviltwin
#37 Posted by EvilTwin (3316 posts) -
@QuistisTrepe said:

@EvilTwin said:

@mosespippy said:

Chie is a starting character. She's weak in the end game so she's easy to not use.

Err, what? She's weak in mid game. Power charge + God's Hand rules end game.

Those attacks don't matter much if she lacks the attack power to put them to use. Even power charge doesn't make a significant difference.

I suppose it would be more accurate to say that physical damage rules end game.  I'm not a Persona 4 theorycrafter, but her damage seemed just fine to me.  Who keeps up with her besides Kanji and the MC?  And since you have 4 party members, what reason would there be not to bring her other than personal preference? 
Avatar image for eightbitshik
#38 Posted by EightBitShik (1484 posts) -

I could of sworn I got the exact same xp from a battle that I did GP to the one I didn't do GP. I don't care who is in my party as long I have Yuki sorry I have to go everywhere with my girlfriend.

Avatar image for quististrepe
#39 Posted by QuistisTrepe (633 posts) -

@EvilTwin said:

@QuistisTrepe said:

@EvilTwin said:

@mosespippy said:

Chie is a starting character. She's weak in the end game so she's easy to not use.

Err, what? She's weak in mid game. Power charge + God's Hand rules end game.

Those attacks don't matter much if she lacks the attack power to put them to use. Even power charge doesn't make a significant difference.

I suppose it would be more accurate to say that physical damage rules end game. I'm not a Persona 4 theorycrafter, but her damage seemed just fine to me. Who keeps up with her besides Kanji and the MC? And since you have 4 party members, what reason would there be not to bring her other than personal preference?

I was comfortable with the lineup that I had. I didn't even use Kanji much by games end. My lineup was mostly Yukiko, Teddy, and Naoto.

Avatar image for the_patriarch
#40 Posted by The_Patriarch (300 posts) -

Dumped her for Kanji, because he's fucking Kanji, but I am pro galactic punt, exp loss or not.

Avatar image for silvaruslupus
#41 Edited by SilvarusLupus (313 posts) -

Next time I play though the game, I think I'll use Kanji. I've just never seem to use him and don't know why...

Still prefer Yukiko to Teddie so that will stay the same.

And Naoto will have a spot, so Yosuke is gonna have to sit out.

Anyone else notice that the males get the buffs and the females get the charges?

  • Yosuke -> Masukukaja and he also gets Dekaja
  • Kanji -> Matarukaja
  • Teddie -> Marakukaja and Matarukaja
  • Chie -> Power Charge
  • Naoto -> Mind Charge

Weird.

Not like it matters by the end since I will just provide the buffs, debuffs, and resets.

Oh god, if Yukiko got mind charge everything would be doomed.

Avatar image for hailinel
#42 Posted by Hailinel (25787 posts) -

@SilvarusLupus said:

Oh god, if Yukiko got mind charge everything would be doomed.

She would set fire to ALL THE THINGS.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.