This review is just plain lame, it's nowhere near fun and having the reviewer acting stupid is just annoying.

Hey guys, did you know almost everybody is a dick in some way? Let's boycott everything.

That was really uncalled for terraria devs. I mean it's just a joke review.

Is he trying to be funny in his review?  

Haha! The review is awesome! If you don't get sarcasm then I don't know what to tell you...

@Pinworm45: Ah make sense. In that case, it wasn't funny or clever. 

I'm all for the silencing of assholes on the Internet, personally. Terraria, you say? Sign me the fuck up.

@Getz said:

@Pinworm45: Ah make sense. In that case, it wasn't funny or clever. 

I agree with that.The dev is still a bitch for going out of his way to get it removed. It'd be like if Bungie called the Escapist to get yahtzees review of Halo removed.

I want those eight minutes of my life back.

I don't agree with what the developer did, and yet I can't side with "TheBestGamers" either. Yes, I'm well aware they are satire, however, they're also equally as childish, if not moreso, than the developer in how they handled things as well. All in all, I think the whole thing is stupid and the game itself looks interesting if you look past the petty shouting match going on.

Haha, The Best Gamers is a fake community set up for shits and giggles. All you motherfuckers got trolled.

Wow. Great skit/review. Very funny. Must check out more of their stuff.

I can see why he'd want it removed tbh. Not for the game review part but the personal insults towards the end.

The worst thing about that video is how unfunny it is. 

Blue isn't the developer. He's PR, and an ideas man. Re-Digit did most of the work on the game, and Blue got all of the shit for it, even though there shouldn't have even been shit in the first place, because they both did a great job.

just because you buy something, it doesn't mean you support their views and ways.  I just means you like the product, making blanket statements like "If you buy [insert product] then you support [insert negative action]!" utterly stupid.

The Best Gamers USA are satire and Blue is just butthurt since he(I assume it's just one guy) doesn't get it

 Notch certainly didn't give a damn about the review of his game.

Honestly, the game looks p. lame.  Haven't touched the thing, obv.

Also, that "review" is p. lame as well.  Stop trying to be an angry video game nerd ripoff.  There are enough of those out there already.

You realize for like 3 minutes at the end he was just laughing at the guy.

You realize for like 3 minutes at the end he was just laughing at the guy.

Making personal attacks against the developer was pretty lame.
Filing a DMCA complaint against the video was pretty lame too.

I wonder why Youtube removes videos so easily.

This matter won't change my feelings towards Terraria, though. I haven't played a game this much for a long long time.

Well, the reviewer is trying to be funny and is failing miserably.  But he has every right to state his opinion however he wants.  If it is true that the game's developer was able to get youtube to take the review down (which is weird if he did since you have that review on the OP linked from a youtube page) then he sounds like a wimp.  Whenever you create something and release it for public consumption you need to be ready to deal with all of the people who are inevitably going to say that what you created is bad in one way or another.  Those people will always be there.  If he wants to stay in the video game business he needs to get thicker skin. 

that review wasnt funny and your not funny posting about it

@LordXavierBritish: I don't support what they did however, you're a bitch.  You probably should have said that you won't be buying it and left out that someone will buy it for you.  Your still supporting their cause so stfu and gtfo.

The guy got this taken down because of how he poked fun at the guy himself, not because of the review of the game. He showed some of his most personal things to the thousands of viewers on his video, I can't blame him to have it removed.

You Tube has a perfectly clear stance on bullying, and that's pretty much what I would call this.  Ignoring the whole "review" part of the video, If this was a 14 year old kid who killed himself after someone put up a you tube video making fun of his appearance and poetry, I think people would be screaming for blood. This is obviously somewhat different, but it's still clearly a form of harassment.

You Tube has a perfectly clear stance on bullying, and that's pretty much what I would call this.  Ignoring the whole "review" part of the video, If this was a 14 year old kid who killed himself after someone put up a you tube video making fun of his appearance and poetry, I think people would be screaming for blood. This is obviously somewhat different, but it's still clearly a form of harassment.

And while I wouldn't support any sort of law making it illegal to say anything said in this video, I do fully support You Tube if they've decided to remove the video for violating their terms of service.

This is one of the worst threads I've read on Giant Bomb.

I wonder why Youtube removes videos so easily.

This is one of the worst threads I've read on Giant Bomb.

HOLY FUCK MY HEADPHONES WERE TURNED UP PRETTY LOUD AND THAT SKELETON SCARED THE FUCKING SHIT OUT OF ME. JESUS CHRIST.

A really unfunny review. I have no idea why would anyone be offended by this.

I tried to look at the best gamers forums and it said "  Scrub detectors are scanning positive here. The Best Gamers Forums are to remain as a scrub-free zone, so get lost loser."

"Professional journalists"
 
You lost me.

Terraria has only a little in common with Minecraft. Blocks, Crafting, and Building. This game is more focused on killing and adventure. Where as Minecraft is mostly a building game. Please show me the NPC's in MineCraft. Or the Demon Alters. Horrible review. Minecraft is not an original either. Infiniminer was first.

Well the developer himself was being personally bashed in the video that's why it got pulled. Trolls are trolls move on.

@Infininja said:

This is one of the worst threads I've read on Giant Bomb.

Good.

In other news, Japanese developers have abandoned technology and time; thus relying on the redefinition of "japanese" games. "Shit is a genre, now."

terraria is a bad game, it's good to see there are still honest game reviewers out there

I'd remove this video just solely for trying to hard to be funny. Ugh. 

At first I thought Destructoid had started doing video "reviews". 
 
All of the children screaming Minecraft clone need to stop.  http://twitter.com/#!/notch/status/74176814997704704

Why does this keep getting bumped.

devs should have ignored it. but still, that "review" is unfunny and untrue on pretty much all aspects.

I'm not defending the game although I am enjoying it. However this guys review is pretty nonprofessional. That mixed with his annoying voice, if I was the dev I'd force that garbage off youtube as well.

Is the creator actually trying to deny that it's a Minecraft clone?

Is the creator actually trying to deny that it's a Minecraft clone?

I don't care if it's a comedy review or not, saying that some part of a game is "gay" is not funny once you graduate from elementary school. It's just kinda rude.