video_game_king's Zelda no Densetsu: Toki no Ocarina (Nintendo 64) review

A highly well-executed transition into the third dimension.

The jump to the third dimension is always a risky move for a traditionally 2D series. Obviously, the addition of another dimension will drastically change how a series operates, sometimes changing it entirely. In fact, many series received heavy criticisms for their first attempts at 3D ( Sonic, Castlevania, Mega Man, etc.). The Legend of Zelda, fortunately, has avoided this fate with Ocarina of Time, its first foray into the third dimension. Although it’s not perfect, Ocarina of Time manages to capture what made previous Zelda titles so satisfying in the first place.

Obviously, this addition of another dimension adds a lot to the game, and the story makes this clear by changing a lot of Zelda traditions. Yet this is not clear from the beginning; just like past Zelda games, Ocarina of Time begins with Link receiving a call to arms against a great evil. This call to arms entails collecting a small amount of magical trinkets to stop said evil. However, Ocarina of Time also contains many serious changes to the Zelda formula. Both Link and Zelda start off as children, Ganondorf is a human, the traditional overworld theme is nowhere to be found (even though tracks from the previous game abound), and most of all, the story places a larger emphasis on atmosphere than ever before. Characters are not afraid to explain the mythos of Hyrule whenever possible, but it never feels forced or irrelevant to what is happening in the storyline. Overall, the game does an excellent job of making you feel like a hero from a medieval epic.

 Although it looks good artistically, Ocarina of Time does not look as good on a technical level.
Yet the story is not without its flaws. The dialogue moves at a very slow pace, both in game and during cutscenes, and a lot of it cannot be skipped. This becomes especially bad when some characters reverse the yes and no options, almost guaranteeing that their dialogue will repeat. Some of the aforementioned changes to Zelda traditions have also resulted in a plot that, upon examination, is actually very racist. Ganondorf, previously an inhuman pig monster, is now a black villain facing off against two blond-haired, blue-eyed youths trying to stop him. In addition, there are minor continuity errors, such as Kokiri in the ending and slightly odd sequences, but these fail to match the large plot hole to be found about halfway through the game. It is at this point that Link must get the Master Sword, yet he is never given any proper motivation for doing so. While he is on a quest to stop Ganondorf, the Master Sword is irrelevant to this, since his actions and Zelda’s already serve to stop Ganondorf from becoming the King of Evil. This is a particularly egregious example not only because the second half of the plot depends entirely on this event (largely because it causes the events in the second half), but also because for the rest of the game, Link sees an oddly high amount of character development. Despite not uttering a word, the hero subtly matures from a cowardly youth to a brave young adult over the course of the game. Given this, his lack of motivation to obtain the Master Sword seems like sloppy writing.

Contrasting with these plot holes is the world design, which comes across as incredibly refined and replete with side quests and secrets. Navigating the world is easy to do, as warps connect all major areas as early as the first area of the game. These warps are necessary, as Ocarina of Time will lead you to all corners of the map as soon as it possibly can. However, very rarely is the direction of the game hard to ascertain. Through Navi and Saria, it does a great job of leading you into its ten dungeons spread across a large world. This does not include the myriad sidequests and secrets to be found in Hyrule. Just about every area holds some type of upgrade or sidequest to be completed. Even the dungeons contain their own distractions in the form of Gold Skulltulas to be killed. The only exception to these rules seems to be the fields connecting these areas. While there are things to do in Hyrule Field, it can still feel very empty sometimes, making travel through it somewhat boring. This is less a problem in the second half of the game, where travel is made far easier, but it still remains present.

While they look menacing, many of the bosses die easily.
Yet it is harder to find such flaws in the several dungeons, which perfectly demonstrate how well Ocarina of Time transitioned into the third dimension. The dungeons start off fairly simple and easy, not utilizing boss keys and, in some cases, being easy to complete without the map. Yet soon after Link obtains the Master Sword, the dungeons become much harder to complete. Fortunately, for the most part, they are very possible to complete without help; the dungeons manage to find a great difficulty balance that makes completing them satisfying instead of a chore. Part of what makes the difficulty so satisfying is how the inventory is used throughout the game. Every item, no matter how minor it may seem at first, gets an oddly high amount of usage throughout the entire game. Rather than becoming useless after its first encounter, equipment usage builds up as you solve various creative puzzles. Even the songs learned over the course of the game get an oddly high amount of use, even if Zelda’s Lullaby and the Song of Time both feel somewhat forced in comparison to other songs and items.

Better yet, most equipment serves a secondary function in a very robust combat system. Just like in dungeons, every item not only serves a useful purpose, but receives much use over the course of the game. It is not uncommon to switch from one weapon to another mid-battle to defeat an enemy. Surprisingly, even non-combat items like bottles can be used in fights. Part of what makes the combat outstanding is just how it controls. Manually aiming at enemies is easy to perform, and because of the targeting system, it is even easier to strafe, shoot, toss bombs, etc. Unfortunately, the swordplay, a major part of the game, does not fare as well. In theory, everything works fine; enemies show some effort in blocking your slashes, placing a greater emphasis on strafing and striking at just the right time. In fact, performing all these actions is just as easy as performing all others. The biggest flaw, though, is that most enemies die easily either to a jump slash or a slash to their underside. This becomes a particularly major problem in certain boss battles, where three jump slashes is enough to finish them. Fortunately, the other weapons, as stated previously, compensate for this, making the system enjoyable overall.

The result of all of this is an incredibly strong, well executed game. Almost everything in the game demonstrates a satisfying amount of polish, from the elaborate world/dungeon design to the varied combat system. The only crippling flaws seem to relate to the story, although it is not without its merit. Besides, this is not enough to reduce the quality of the game by a significant amount, making it clear why so many people still enjoy Ocarina of Time.
3 Comments Refresh
Posted by sirdesmond

I never had much appreciation for this game back in the day, but I feel like I may have to pick up the 3DS re-release and give it a go now. Maybe, adult-me will be able to enjoy all the stuff everyone else does. At the time, I just found it to be fairly boring.

Anyways, great review! Nice to see someone actually able to see some of the game's flaws amidst its agreed upon greatness.

Posted by Video_Game_King
Let me say this right now: whatever you thought when you first played it is most likely what you'll think when you play it now. The game hasn't changed much in 13 years.
Hooray for writing the one Ocarina of Time review that's worth reading, apparently! (It's my strong opinion that Ocarina of Time always leads to mediocre reviews. I don't know why; it just does.)
Posted by Penelope

Nice review. Made me wish I had thought to bring up the combat uses for the items in my own.

Well done.

Other reviews for Zelda no Densetsu: Toki no Ocarina (Nintendo 64)

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.