perhaps im reading too much into this, but when i hear a black character in a game or movie being played by a white actor, it just feels wrong. hearing nolan north voice romeo in odst, hearing him put on a black sounding voice, it just made me feel uncomfortable. to me its one step above actors performing in blackface. does anyone else feel the same way? again perhaps im reading too far into this but im curious to see what you guys think.
edit: judging from your comments you guys have no issue with people of any race or gender voicing any type of character. it seems i was just reading a bit too much into this. ah well.
anyone else take issue with white VAs voicing black characters?
Absolutely, but not quite to the blackface level. Or worse, British black VA's trying to sound like American street thugs (that one single black guy in Heavy Rain) -- WAY too false and cartoony sounding. As if white British folks trying to sound like white American folks wasn't bad enough (everybody else Heavy Rain).
White Americans sound more like Black Americans than Black British sound like Black Americans.
So by this reasoning, you should take issue with Kratos being voiced by a black dude. That said, who cares? Unless the character is supposed to be heavily accented from one of the race's native tongues, just about anyone would be fine.
It's not like the VA is putting on that nasal-ass whiny sounding 'white voice' a lot of black stand-up comedians overuse.
kratos skin tonne was somewhat dark though before his origin story, if you recall. not that it matters.
Meh...grown women voice little boys in cartoons, Europeans voice Americans in Heavy Rain...I'm not at all bothered by it. If it sounds totally wrong, sure it is a bad design choice. But it doesn't offend me or anything, nor should it.
Why couldn't avatar use blue people for VOs? Blueface in 2010 I thought we were above this.
i don't mind it as long as they aren't playing some black stereotype. i don't really like it much when black actors play a black stereotype either.
I have no issue with this. A black guy (Terrence C. Carson) voices Kratos, and last time I checked, Kratos was white. You can't have it one way; it goes both ways.
It's acting. Authenticity is really the only thing that matters for voice acting. The reason blackface is not even in the same ballpark -- isn't even in the same GAME as this voice-acting "issue" -- is because racist whites were stereotypically portraying blacks in film and on stage. Voice acting is a completely different matter. If James Earl Jones can do Darth Vader but...holy shit...Vader's a white guy?...you think we'd be past this by now.
Some Chinese critics had a fucking fit when Chow Yun-Fat and Michelle Yeoh (who did not speak native Mandarin) tried to portray native Mandarin speakers. Cantonese (and western) accents gave them away if you could tell, but here in the western world we couldn't, so we loved it.
By the way, Gollum was not voiced by a Hobbit, but Jack Black was played by a monkey in King Kong.
" @MrKlorox: Again, that has to do more with accents. Not everyone sounds like a stereotype, regardless of race. "Yes. The entire issue is about authentic accents. Not something stupid and shallow as skin color. Unless I misunderstood the OP and he's just a bigot.
Races don't have genetically distinct voice boxes divided by race. There is no type of voice you can only get from one race, there are merely types of voices you associate most with certain races and that's just because of culture and language. James Earl Jones is the only cat on earth who sounds the way he does. Its not a black thing, its a James Earl Jones thing. Someone like Morgan Freeman, say, could very very easily VO for a middle aged man of just about any race. So could Tom Waits.
Nope. White voice actors can provide voices for all kinds of people. Asians, blacks.
As long as they do a good job, then I don't see any problem.
" I have no issue with this. A black guy (Terrence C. Carson) voices Kratos, and last time I checked, Kratos was white. You can't have it one way; it goes both ways. "I was just about to say that. Can't get any whiter than Kratos.
As long as it sounds natural its fine. Its always weird no matter who voices characters to see real people do the voices of beloved characters. When I first saw the cast of the Simpson's blew my mind
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment