@ll_exile_ll:
Wow, where to start. First, you say I didn't explain why your list was ridiculous. I did. Read closer. It's about comparing genres.
Second, you say my not explaining myself is hypocritical because I accuse other of not explaining themselves, but the other people no explaining themselves IS part of the explanation for my argument! How can you not see that sentence contradicts itself, by accusing me of not explaining myself WHILST PARAPHRASING PART OF THE EXPLANATION I GAVE!
Third, stop getting defensive because I used you as an example to demonstrate a point. I'm not attacking you personally, or even your list specifically — almost everybody's list looks ridiculous as yours.
Forth, if you think anyone offering a suggestion for improvement is "acting superior" and should be dismissed, you've got the wrong attitude, chap. If I'm talking down to you, I can't apologise. It's so easy to accidently do when you're right and the other person is wrong. Get used to it, and you might learn something instead of writing petty defensive posts.
Fifth "best" and "favourite" mean the same thing in the context of an individual, so, yeah, when you put Mario 64 at no.4 and Mario Galaxy 2 at no.16, you are quite explicitly saying Mario 64 is better than Mario Galaxy 2. To you (which is all I mean).
Sixth, perhaps it would help if I gave some exaggerated examples to demonstrate how I see these lists as ridiculous. What if someone said "I like Civilization better than Half Life 2: Episode 1, but worse than Half Life 2: Episode 2", or "I like Dance Dance Revolution better than Advance Wars, but worse than Advance Wars: Days of Ruin". How can you even compare Civ to Half-Life, let alone be comparing multiple games in the series against each other. If you get it now, that's how I feel when I see these lists.
Log in to comment