Cake or Pie?

whoever says pie, must be eliminated

Cake!

Pie! I thought this was all sorted on the old GS anyway??

Pie

Brown Sugar>any kind of cake

Cake of course.  The real question is, would you rather have a cake pie or a pie cake?

Pie, for sure. That said, my girlfriend is currently baking a cake!

Pie hands down.

Cake anytime, pie in the winter.

Pie definitely.

Pie!

Blueberry pie = win
meatloaf pie = win

meaning...
PIE = WIN

simple. :)

-

I will always and forever be a CAKE man! Buttercreme frosting for the win!

Never been a fan of pies. Apple Pie is the closest I've come to enjoying a pie. And then there's the other pie that The Rock loves. :D

A Pie with a cake inside it.

But Seriously, probably pie, because apple pie is supreme, however cake implies such great things as Battenburg, Cheesecake, and Jaffa Cakes, so i guess i cant choose at all, Im having my cake and eating it so to speak.

Pie, it covers way more area. Steak and kidney pie, banana cream pie, apple pie, pizza pie, chicken pot pie. You could live a healthy, happy, life eating nothing but pies.

Cake!

Anyone who votes pie is a communist.

A COMMUNIST I SAY!

Thumbs up for cake.

Both?

What a dumb question. Pie.

"Anyone who votes pie is a communist.

A COMMUNIST I SAY!
"

Depends on the weather.

Don't make me choose. It's like a desert based Sophie's Choice. In the bakery of life. ;_;

what? you cant compare a cake with a pie! i mean... what the hell is a wedding-pie.

anyway: cake all the way!

Pork Pie every time.

Or if it has to be fruit... Damson Pie and Ice cream; Cooked damsons should be a class A.

Cake is easily better than pie.

Cake all the way.

Cake is the pinnacle of awesomeness. Pie is... dry.

cake 99% oreo pie 1%

Cake, its like bread, but 10 times better.

Cake FTW!

Okay theres only one way to settle this Lets ask Cake and Pie
Me:Cake what do you like Cake or Pie
Cake:Cake
Me:Pie what do you like Cake or pie
Pie: Pie
(Hits Pie with a baseball bat)
Pie: I mean Cake
There You Go Your winner and heavyweight chapion of food CAKE!!
Lets Start the cake parade

Cake.

So tough, I'm going to have to pussy out and say tie.

Cake, it the best thing since...um...well cake.

I am not a fan of either.

apple pie

cake is the chuck norris of desserts

that is all...

Cake

Pie takes way to long to manufacture.
You need +1 skills in baking for that. 

"Someone had to make one.

CAKE FTW"

Pie

Pie.

'Nuff said.

Pepperoni pie from Peppes for the win!

Oh for the love of God, Cake! D=<

While I enjoy cake more, you can never go wrong with pie either.  They are both awesome.

Cake generally, sometimes pie.

Got to be cake for me.
And now I'm all hungry for cake...

Pie is the best.

Wow, most people said cake =D