Cake vs Pie

Pie for me. As long as it's not Pumpkin anyway...

The sponginess of cake lofts it above pie, however pie is also very delicious.

Cake.

I don't really eat pie.

but a three layer devils food cake with chocolate fudge icing is just awesome.

You mean to say that someone already said "the cake is a lie?" damn...too late!

Oh and PIE!

I'm going with cake (icing on top).

"Aussie Meat pie = Win

"

Cake for me

Cake, I hate Pies.

Pie FTW!!

Key-lime pie

Pie.

Cake is great.

So..is Pie.

I prefer cake.

Cake

I haven't had either

I choose chocolate cake with mini chocolate bar filling with chocolate covered sauce

It's a hard decision. I love pie, but cake is great too.

I flipped a coin, heads for pie, tails for cake. It was tails, so cake it is.

It might be a lie, but it's a delicious one.  Cake is my choice.

Pie.

poontang pie!!!

I like pie. That sounds dirty.

Pie all the way

Hmmm, can't decide, both are delicious!

 I'd go for a cake pie?  just putting it out there.

pie is clearly the best since you can eat it warm cake tastes funny if its heated up.

cake

..!?

Pie is way better than cake! Pie can be whatever you want it to be. You can have a sweet pie but you can't have a meat cake. Therefore cake is the loser in this contest.

Never heard of a sweet potato cake so it's pie my friend pie!!!!

Cupcakes

Cake

Be careful and check who the chef is before you eat your pie...



I'm partial to cake, to be perfectly honest; at least I won't find fingers in one....

Good cake can be really good, especially when it's cold, but it just can't compare to a good pie... blueberry, chocolate cream, banana cream, just too good.

Cake is only good when its moist and covered in icing but even a dry cake is better than most pies.

Cake ftw!

Well i think we can all finally agree that cake does indeed pwn pie.

Depends entirely on my mood. Not is greatest.

Man, come on, that debacle has been over already.....

If we have to settle this go to the "Everybody Votes Channel" on the Wii console and create "another" Cake vs Pie debate....

Cake!

Cake FTW!

Cake. I dont like pie

pie ftw

Cake is win.

If it's a lie, then the lie is quite delicious.

Really heavy cakes. Like... pound cakes... and... coffee cakes... None of this fruity-tooty angel food bs.

Cake....

cake.

Cake = WINNER

Nailed it.

Holy Necro Batman! This thread is almost 6 years old!

These thread necros keep getting weirder and weirder.