Is there any real choice here? The Federation of Planets is the only one on the list where neither the majority (or all) of humanity ends up dead (Halo, Mass Effect, especially Dead Space) and isn't the personification of corporate corruption (Weyland-Yutani) Killzone is a bit harder to pin down, but we're still talking about a war essentially designed as WW2.0 and it has one fatal flaw: you'll be working with Rico. Really, I'd rate the Helghast over the UCN due to that fact alone.
Now that I think about it a lot of science fiction employers are either stuck in Dystopian fiction or suffer horrendous casualties. Hell, not even Star Wars gets a free pass on that one, Rebel or Empire. The Federation of Planets are one of the few that dares to be Utopian. Probably why it's still going strong.
It's as if writers feel an uncontrollable urge to either have a stable, Dystopian society where the hero is used as a shining beacon fighting against evil and tyranny or sacrifice HUGE amounts of people in non-Dystopian fiction just to hammer home how big the threat and the current crisis is, where either the hero is used as a shining beacon protecting a struggling humanity or the life-affirming message for some reason is that humanity will always continue to fight.
Halo does both of these with Master Chief and the heroic marine supporting characters. And the death toll in that universe is insane - extended fiction puts it at over half the human population, or some 23 BILLION people.
Log in to comment