I think it depends on the game and the details of the scene. I think it is difficult to have a non-pornographic sex scene in gaming (particularly when your list reads like a porn checklist), but I don't think it's completely impossible. The only example I can think of off the top of my head was in the original God of War, where Kratos gets greatly rewarded if he satisfies Venus in bed. At first I interpreted it as "gratuitous", but the fact that it's a game that can be repeated endlessly (and if you fail the first few times, you start being impressed by his stamina), and the only reward comes from her satisfaction (not yours) seemed to build Kratos's character and emphasized his frustration. Removing the player view from the bed and putting it instead on the vase on the nightstand pushed the scene away from pornographic and into artistic. I haven't played the other God of War games, and cannot comment on anything they contained, but some basic clips of the scenes out of context looked decidedly less artistic.
Spore had some "sex scenes" of the most abstract sort that played between generations... but they were really boring after watching them the first time.
The Sims 2 had some pretty dramatic intimate scenes, particularly for a game with its rating. There was some artistic license to the interpretation of sex in it (what did you think those fireworks exploding were?), but there was never any doubt what was happening. There were even sims whose goal was to Woo-Hoo with as many people as possible, which is like a script for a porno, but the game managed to avoid being pornographic. I mention this because there's not anything too significant to the sim who wants another conquest -- nothing intimate or romantic about it. They are literally like "Seventeen down, three more to go!"
In general, sex scenes are there to let us look into a character's intimate life. I think these scenes fit more into the story-telling side of gaming. I have difficulty imagining a game that includes the copulation in detail that isn't pornographic on some level, but it's clearly possible.
Log in to comment