@Fockinator: I'm surprised this thread is still around, but seeing that it is, I suppose it's worth commenting.
I think it's clear that you deserved punishment of some sort, but I agree that banning was over-the-top. (though, I don't exactly have the records of what you said to that other person and whether you have a history with PSN that we are not privy to) When your name became the issue, I somewhat understood that, as well. Though, again, I don't think that's ban worthy. Instead, they should just force you to change your name, and perhaps throw in a short suspension for good measure.
As far as enforcement, though, I think that's a separate problem from all of this. You were rightfully punished for things you said and the infringing name you chose. Now, we can debate whether banning is the appropriate punishment; I happen to think it is not. Whether your punishment was rightful or not has nothing to do with possible lacking enforcement though. I think that's the part sticking in many people's craw. This insistence on everyone else paying, as though that would make you feel better about your own banning. Instead, this really should just be a discussion on why banning isn't the proper response and no one should be banned for this nonsense. We should encourage Sony to change their policy.
Beyond that, I'm not sure you've really "learned [your] lesson", as it were. I mean, redirecting your anger at yourself over making this stupid mistake toward trying to get more people banned seems like the actions of someone who hasn't honestly admitted that they are the one at fault in this scenario. Even if someone pushes your buttons, you are still responsible for yourself. And in this life, and even in a game chat, things won't always be fair. The guy who started it won't always be the one punished. That's common. The key is just not be the one who swung back. It's a lot easier online or in a game than in person.
I suggest you allow this thread to die off and you make new thread about why you think banning is not an appropriate punishment for name violations. Write something substantive and make it compelling. Not just "I was banned, so banning sucks." Your story isn't exactly the poster child of wrongful banning. So, find other examples and get people interested. Then perhaps your horrible turn of events can start a nice conversation on banning, policy enforcement, and the need for greater accountability in game services like PSN and XBL, without all the baggage of your personal story here.
Log in to comment