WalkerTR77

Point lookout was the most evocative of the traditional fallout 3 experience, I felt like I was playing a brand new fallout 3 with a new world to explore. As someone who mainly enjoyed exploring the wasteland Point Lookout was ideal for me. It doesn't surprise me that mothership zeta has no votes whatsoever, it was atrocious.

I loved Red dead redemption, but gtaIV was the first gta that I actually played to completion/ enjoyed. Not sure how I feel about a new one, I enjoy new york but any other city I probably wouldn't have any interest in. Actually, the exception is gta Glasgow.

 I thoroughly enjoyed Alan Wake, and after finishing it I knew that I absolutely had to get every thermos, sign and achievement point this game had in it. I don't quite know what it is about these collectibles in particular but I feel I need all of them, the points incentive is obvious enough but there's something more at play here. I suppose that knowing that the last few achievements are neither a massive commitment nor incredibly difficult is motivating, and the fact that they are within my grasp makes them that much more alluring. 

At this point though, it is obvious that with this many collectibles they could be tracked better than they are. Knowing that you have 6 more thermoses to find is good, but it's frustrating that you have no idea which chapter of the game they might be in. Nightmare mode might be a stumbling block but hopefully I can muddle through it  without  killing myself in the process. 
 
Are there games that drive you to that Vinny like 100 % anal completion? Are you enticed by the salacious desire to grab collectibles or do you despise them?

 @jmrwacko:  
This is the exact problem I had, it's so frustrating because you cant save in the area and it's also a complete bastard to get up there again. I thought I would have to give up on 100 %, but using this - 
 http://reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Five_Finger_Fillet   and just concentrating on hitting the buttons from that sequence, without looking at the screen, I got through it. 
 
Also - don't bother with rhythm, just hit the buttons as fast as possible.