I don't think Tomb Raider should be compared with Heavy Rain in any way. Two completely different games in terms of genre and tone. Also I wouldn't single out the female characters in Heavy Rain as being particularly mistreated, because pretty much everyone in that game gets fucked up.So I don't think the violence towards the female character stands out when you look at the whole game and in context.
The Tomb Raider stuff is weird because you get the sense that the developers are putting her through so much _because_ she's a female protagonist. Like they're saying "Yeah you weren't expecting us to do this to her, right?!" It's obvious they're trying to ride on Uncharted's success and that includes what that series has put Nathan Drake through. He get's pretty beat up, but only just enough to make it seem like he's not a superhero. But the abuse Lara takes, seems almost comical. She can't just take a fall without getting impaled, can't parachute without hitting every tree on the way down and of course every enemy is a potential rapist as well. Everything that could go wrong, does and it does so times ten. I like the idea of a different Tomb Raider and the game looks nice anyway. But I don't think this way of portraying women and violence is that groundbreaking as the developers seem to think it is. Having seen The Descent, it has been handled sooo much better. It doesn't matter if it's a dude or dudette falling 50 feet in a dark cave, limbs will be broken regardless and we're not afraid to show it. But right now, the sole focus of the game seems to be "How many terrible things can we put Lara through". So I guess the potential rape was the thing that finally took it over the top.
Log in to comment