Whether they were removed from Melee or you just think it'd be awesome to play as them, make your opinion heard in this thread.  Just try to be as practical as possible.  Note:  Do not list characters already in the game.  What's the point of wishing you could play as a character if you already can!

Personally, I'd like to see:
Leon (Resident Evil 4)
Jack (Harvest Moon.  I'm pretty sure this is the standard name for the protagonist)
Megaman (Megaman series)
Zero (Megaman X series)
Ryu (Street Fighter Series.  And with an alternate color that matches Ken)
Knuckles (Sonic series.  And honestly with gliding and wall clinging why ISN'T he in this game!!!)
Baby Bowser (Maybe with the paintbrush from Sunshine?)
Pichu (Come on.  You know he was adorable.  And there should be characters that are complete jokes)
Mii (I would love playing as myself with no special abilities or powerups.  A great joke character)
Toad (I know Peach is holding one but HONESTLY.  He needs to be playable!)


Maybe I'll think of more later on, but tell me what characters you agree with or mention your own ideas!

Paper mario.

Cervantes (from Soul Calibur)
Mario Kart (like a Mario that permanently drives around in his Kart shooting shells etc...)
Grey Fox as the Cyborg Ninja (from MGS...I know he was in Brawl, but he wasn't playable)
Diablo
Sephiroth (FFVII)
Cloud (FFVII)

just some ideas

I wanted to see Shadow from sonic in the game.

Sora (from Kingdom Hearts)
Megaman
Either Tails or Knuckles

Jeff Gerstmann

^^ you win the internet. Have a cookie

Tom Nook from Animal Crossing.

Iwazaru (Killer 7)
ToeJam (ToeJam & Earl)
Beat (Jet Grind Radio)

Toad

a gta character, or pac man or a football mascot.

I'd agree with Megaman and Knuckles.

I wanted ridley to be playable

I still hate how Megaman didn't make it in Brawl, so him (Megaman X preferably)

More Fire Emblem chatacters, like maybe Eirika or Eiphram, or maybe Princess Elincia, I mean, Mario and Link get to have their princesses in SSB, why not Ike?

and Isaac should have been playable, not an assist trophy. Though I suppose Felix would have worked as well.

Megaman and Cutman.

Isaac definitely.  And Tom Nook too!  I'd imagine that he'd pull out bags of coins from the ground and when you hit your opponent with it, coins spill out even if it's not a coin match =-D. 

I thought about Mario Kart too.  The more I thought about a Toad moveset the more I considered Toad's forward B to be similar to Wario's Motorcycle except he rides his go-kart instead.

I would've liked to see another Metroid character.  Maybe one of the hunters from Metroid Prime: Hunters DS?  I think Ashley from Warioware would've been another great character.

Well, some people have been posting characters that obviously will never be in a Smash Bros game, like a GTA character.

So I'm going to play it safe and say...

Impa
Megaman
Airman
Tom Nook

One person I want playable actually ended up as an Assist Trophy. Saki Amamiya.

I've even thought up an entire moveset for him. Final Smash and everything.

I would have loved to see Isaac/Felix from Golden Sun in the game. It's too bad they didn't get in, although it's nice that Isaac is an Assist Trophy.

I'd settle for them adding a "fun" or "enjoyment" mode.

Or megaman.

Animal Crosser

Travis Touchdown

Girl Pokemon Trainer

Tails and Knuckles, for sure.
Bomberman would work well enough, with different bombs reserved for the B button, and standard kicks and punches on A.
Pokemon combat on Brawl is really ace, too.  Any number of Pokemon would work fucking brilliantly - Mew, Raichu, Golem, any of them.  Maybe with the ability to evolve/devolve mid-match.
Ryu and Ken would be great.
I guess a lot of comic book characters would work, as they've appeared on most Nintendo platforms.  Spiderman, X-Men, etc.

Kung Fu Panda and Kratos
Blood and Pandas = Win

Ooh so many possiblities.

• Frank West (Dead Rising, Dead Rising : Chop 'till You Drop)
• Travis Touchdown (No More Heroes)
• Sora (Kingdom Hearts)
• Isaac (Golden Sun)
• Megaman (Megaman)
• Krystal + Midna (Zelda: Twilight Princess)
  

• Kratos (God of War)

• James Earl Cash (Manhunt)
• Master (Fallout)
• Cacodeamon (Doom)
• The Postal Guy (Postal)
• Scorpion (Mortal Kombat)

Roy

A different mix for Pokemon trainer.

Say Bulbesar, Charmeleon and Blastoise.

Everyone knows that Blastoise is the best evolved starter pokemon. :)

Kratos and Cloud would be pretty cool.

Chargin' Chuck would be the ultimate addition to this game.

9 volt!! yeaah

"Chargin' Chuck would be the ultimate addition to this game."

Create your own character soul calibur IV style but different options and unlocks of course

I want both the original Megaman and X.... and Zero

Mega Man is the one I want to see the most.

"Jeff Gerstmann
"

Poison Ivy.

Characters that could make it in:
King K. Rool
Little Mac
Pac-Man
Waluigi

Characters that will probably never make it in, but I'd love to see:
King Leonidas
Abraham Lincoln
Doctor Doom
God
The Lich King

• Midna
• One of the Koopa Kids (preferably Larry)
• Mouser
• Simon Belmont
• Billy Lee (alt costume of Jimmy Lee)
• Birdo
• Captain N

Zack Fair,Genesis(Crisis Core)

Cloud,Sephiroth(FF: VII)

Dark Samus(Metroid Prime 2)

Roy(Fire Emblem)

And if it would be allowed: Master Chief and Kratos

"Roy"

There should be a mode where you would be a mode where you would play a boss against other bosses.

"Cervantes (from Soul Calibur)
Mario Kart (like a Mario that permanently drives around in his Kart shooting shells etc...)
Diablo
Sephiroth (FFVII)
Cloud (FFVII)"

I agree that Shadow, Sora and Baby Bowser shouldn't be in there. I wouldn't mind Krystal being in though.

"Whether they were removed from Melee or you just think it'd be awesome to play as them, make your opinion heard in this thread.  Just try to be as practical as possible.  Note:  Do not list characters already in the game.  What's the point of wishing you could play as a character if you already can!Personally, I'd like to see:Leon (Resident Evil 4)Jack (Harvest Moon.  I'm pretty sure this is the standard name for the protagonist)Megaman (Megaman series)Zero (Megaman X series)Ryu (Street Fighter Series.  And with an alternate color that matches Ken)Knuckles (Sonic series.  And honestly with gliding and wall clinging why ISN'T he in this game!!!)Baby Bowser (Maybe with the paintbrush from Sunshine?)Pichu (Come on.  You know he was adorable.  And there should be characters that are complete jokes)Mii (I would love playing as myself with no special abilities or powerups.  A great joke character)Toad (I know Peach is holding one but HONESTLY.  He needs to be playable!)Maybe I'll think of more later on, but tell me what characters you agree with or mention your own ideas!"