DEBATE: Assassins Creed good or No?

I liked it a lot in fairly short stints, like one assassination per sit down. I loved the control scheme though, it fit perfectly for the action.

I really didn't like AC. I think it was really boring, I could not get into it at all. I think it was a really bad game that people only like because they paid money for it.

I loved it.I loved causing trouble.

It's a good/above average game but not a great one. Always wondered why so many had a big boner for it.

It was fun at first, but then it got repetitive.

it's good but the combat is way too complex for its own good unless you take a few hours to get used to it

Haven't played it, but I have seen a lot of mixed reactions to the game.

Mixed reactions out the ying yang

It was alright for the time being that I played it, It got repetitive after awhile.

I loved the game. One the best games I have ever played. I loved climbing the walls and the story was pretty good until the end.

High production Values, okay gameplay, Repetitive mission design.

I gotta go with:  "...meh"

I bought it (used), I played it (a little while), I moved on (with my life).

There's nothing inherently WRONG with the game, so I'm not  complaining, but I just expected more than shiny graphics from this one.

The ending of the game was an insult, and the gameplay got repetetive.

But overall a pretty good game. Especially the animation, it was a treat to watch

"Mixed reactions out the ying yang"

game had great controls, graphics, interface, exploration.  it had everything but good missions.  the pickpocket missions were a joke.  the eavesdropping missions were a joke.  the interrogation missions were a joke.  the minor assasination missions were too easy not to get spotted.  they should have stuck with what made the game fun - the free running - the assasinatins and the fighting.  i thought the missions where you had to collect the flags in the time limit were fun but there were only a couple of those.  as a result the game becomes boring and waaay to easy.  they coulda done way more with it.

Assassin's Creed was far too overhype and the gameplay is just too damn repetitive (that's the biggest knock on it's Assassin's Creed, amongst other things.) There are many games on the market that's better than AC, but it's an solid game (if nothing more).

PS... I like the fact that UbiSoft did try and do something different, maybe the sequel will get it right.

No, didnt like it.

Summary: Visuals and plot make up for the poor gameplay.

its bad (confirmed)

Honestly, no.

D:

One of the best games this console generation. It baffles me that some people don't seem to like creativity and innovation. They want the same game with better graphics and new features.

No it's a repetitive pos.

All in all its a good game. i'd give it 3.5/5. Repetitive and Boring at times, but the combat system and graphics are phenominal.

Good for 30 mins untill you find out that it is the same exact thing over and over and over....

It is one of the best games ever created. Only thing people seem to complain about is repetition but, in my opinion GTAIV is more repetitive.

Way too repetitive, and the acclaimed crowd system wasn't all that great... But I loved the combat, which everyone apparently hated. Climbing was fun for a while too. And nothing beats free-running on roof tops.
But the story ruined it for me, I hated it, and the AI was something along the lines of 'WTF'.
7/10

good game

It looks really good (I've never played it) and I would have gotten it had I not heard that it was repetitive from even my real life friends

Yes, but it's really repetitive.

Holy fuck no. The most repetive, shallow game ive ever played. Do the same 3 tasks over and over, lather, rinse, repeat.  The ai was retarded as well. The story was literally written by a four year old on cocaine, and the ending pissed me off so badly. How do you have a cliff hanger on such a crappy story? 1/5 The graphics were good though. :) 

It was pretty good, but got extremely repetitive.  The ending was horrible, but the graphics were good as someone said.

It was awesome, but  repetitive and not too much replay value

I had hyped this game pretty much since it was announced, and I love it. Even though I don't play it anymore, it is easily up with my top favorite games of 2008 (my brother bought the game on like New Year's Day).

I liked it a lot.

i liked it and i also liked the ending really mysterious

I thought it was good enough.

"Assassin's Creed forum.
"

I loved Assassins Creed. It was one of my favorite games of last year.

Same here, in the top 5 maybe.

It was good, but it didn't reach expectations. It nailed the atmosphere and visuals but fell flat on fighting mechanics. Climbing was fun and stuff but the missions were too similar.

A great game, ruined by its repetitiveness. The first few assassinations are fun. But it was all, pickpocket this guy, interrogate this dude, climb building and press Y (360 version). It gets boring after a while.

So much potential, almost wasted. Hopefully a sequel will have more things to do. The gameplay is fun though. a 4/5 seems appropriate though.

it's fun, but really repeditive, definitely a rent.

At LEAST a rent.

Very good game, abit short and gets quite repetitive after awhile. But was still an extremely good game.

Its a decent game, though the gameplay gets repetitive.

i dont know why people hated it so much, aside from riding around the kingdom, I thought it was repetitive, but not tiresomely so...my gripe is that the combat is far too forgiving.

its good but not great

"Very good game, abit short and gets quite repetitive after awhile. But was still an extremely good game.
"

I played it at a friends house for awhile. Its an OK game. I wouldn't blow $60 bucks on it though.