@CH3BURASHKA said:
@bartok said:
I wish more people had the balls to write reviews like that Halo 4 one.
There needs to be a clear and definite division between what qualifies as a "review" and what qualifies as an op-ed piece. While I enjoy and appreciate interesting, off-the-wall opinions, the purpose of a review is very tangential and measurable - whether or not to invest money in a product. People like Chick and Sterling are entertaining to read, whether because you agree with them or they ruffle your feathers, but they do a greater disservice than a, well, service to the review "industry". In the days of Metacritic, a 4 for Assassin's Creed 2 makes much less sense when every single other fucking outlet gives it a 9 or 10, not because they have the wool pulled over their eyes but because it's a quality product. I don't give a shit if some internet asshole wasn't completely satisfied with what they imagined they were getting into.
It doesn't take balls to write an inflammatory "review" and rile up gamers. It takes balls to put your ego in its fucking place and do your fucking job. The GB crew have more "balls" than Chick or Sterling can ever hope to have.
Correct. The entire point of a review is to allow a consumer to make an educated judgement of whether or not they will enjoy a particular game, and this article here made me doubt if Patrick gets that....particularly this line: "What do you want from your reviews? Do you want someone to reaffirm your preconceived notions about a game, or do you want to be challenged, and look at a game in a new light?"
I don't like the fact that a journalist defines reviews this way, because it isn't at all what I want from them. Patrick seems to get a hard-on for this type of journalism, which is fine, but it IS NOT what reviews are meant for. Hate to say it, but Patrick doesn't really have much credibility from me as far as objective analysis goes...I don't think he's capable of it. I tried reaching out to Patrick through a PM to see how exactly he defines a review, and what he believes their purpose to be, but as of yet I haven't received a response.
Log in to comment