oldmanlight's Prototype (Xbox 360) review

This is a good rental.

Picked this game up yesterday on the way home from work.  I haven't completed the game yet but intend to.  From what i've played so far, I know what to expect from the rest of the game.  The story is decent. I'm actually kind of curious as to how the pieces of the puzzle line up with regard to what happened here so the developers did a good job on sort of drip feeding you the story. I feel it's still too early on in the game for it all to make sense yet but i'm hoping it all comes together in the end. 
Graphics wise this game is sort of a mixed bag,  Sometimes you'll be zipping along and the game looks rather nice.  Other times it looks like a high res version of a last gen game.  Art style is pretty bland.  With a game like this, as much as i hate to say it, some extra graphical filters like some bloom or blurring would have gone a long way to help the game establish a graphical style.  Character models are ugly for the most part, not much going on there, most of the blackwatch soldiers look like rejects from past splinter cell games and not in a good way. 
The gameplay for the most part is fun but the thing I fault it for the most is that you never really feel like you have good control over alex.  You're bouncing around so much and so fast that you'll often times overshoot your landing or sprint right of the top of a building or right past an enemy you intended to attack.  The missions so far have been varied enough to where i don't feel like i'll be doing the same thing over and over like in Assassin's Creed.   The game has  only 31 story missions and each mission takes about 5-10 minutes to complete.  I'm 90 minutes into the game and have already completed 6 of the 31 on the normal difficulty and I've been taking my time going from mission to mission.  In the early going of the game you're forced to undertake the side missions to build up Evolution Points (EP, the games version of XP)  in order to unlock certain new powers to enter into the storyr missions.   The side missions are varied, and  consists of checkpoint races, kill frenzy missions, and combinations of the 2.  They're done in a way so that they also feel unique and offer rewards in the form of medals and EP for completing them more efficiently.   Other replay additions are the addition of collectible orbs similar to crackdown,  and additional consumable enemies that have minor pieces of story elements attached to them.
All told this isnt' a great open world game but it's ok.  The city is bland, the character models are bleh,  the animations are decent, the gameplay is fun but can get stale in long sessions,  and you won't have much reason to go back once you've played through it once unless you're a particularly big fan of collectathons.

6 Comments
Edited by reversethedevil

i played this game for hours and hours. They did a great job making you feel all powerful. and when people say the game looks last gen i don't think they've really picked up the original xbox or ps2 in a while. try saying something like, you thought the textures would be higher rez or hoped for crazier lighting effects like (game in similar genre). powers are cool free running is awesome and oh my god the mayhem murder has never been so much fun. Yes i played the hulk i don't feel it's just a reskinned clone.

Posted by OldManLight

to each his own i guess.  It's my way of conveying that I felt a game like should look better having been preceded by games like, Crackdown, Assassin's Creed, Saints Row 1 and 2, Mercenaries 2,  GTA 4 this game should look better than it does or at least have an eye catching art style that fits the subject matter, the graphics look plain and bland to me.

Posted by RsistncE

Seems to me like most people are reviewing only the graphical aspects of this game...and not the actual damn game itself.

Posted by Det1

I blame the unreal 3 engine for the high expectation in lighting effects.

Posted by Lind_L_Taylor

Keep in mind that when you're talking about "better graphics", that you're reviewing a console. At some point the better graphics is going to hit the limitations of the console's hardware itself, if it hasn't already. They might have had to cut back on the details just so the frame rate would not be compromised.

Posted by OldManLight

my point is not that i want photo realism in the graphics, my point is that for the type of game this is, it would've been better served making use of some graphical filters to give the game a more distinctive art style.  i'm perfectly comfortable saying a game that does an interesting job of displaying its assets looks great, this game just doesn't do that,  it looks good at parts but more often than not it looks bland.  I did try to objective look at the game,  i wish people didn't make my review sound like a graphics bitchfest because i clearly mention other reasons for the 3 out of 5 score.

Other reviews for Prototype (Xbox 360)

    But what is the... prototype? 0

    Prototype arrived ridding a wave of hype, but does it deliver its promises or does instead drown in them? The game tells the story of man, Alex Mercer, awaking in the morgue, with no memories, and a question on his mind:"Who did this to me?"In the meantime, Manhattan is put under quarantine by the regular army and a unknown military outfit, called the Blackwatch Special Forces, due to a misterious virus that spread within the city, turning its citizens into disfigured zombies.Are the two related...

    7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.