Do you PERSONALLY think Red Dead Redemption will be inferior on PS3 ? (Honestly)

" I don't think it will be a game-breaker; the guy who claimed this (David "CheapyD" Abrams) is a guy who probably strips naked and makes love to his three 360 consoles  when his wife and son aren't around. It's disgusting how so many people are madly in love with Microsoft and their products for all the wrong reasons.  Anyway, I'm getting it for the PS3 and don't care about these dumb comparison videos that all the nerds gets worked up over. Let me know when they compare an exclusive PS3 game with an exclusive 360 game.  I like the CAG site but I don't care for CheapyD's incessant lust for the semen-colored wonder. "

" @Ryax said:

" @The_Laughing_Man said:

" @Coombs said:

" I think I don't care, Seeing as how unless your playing them side by side (or an elitist ass) you won't know the difference anyway. "

I might have to block the RDR forums for a wile if people are gonna start this stuff. Which happens with EVERY big game release.  "

im getting to that point mainly because sackmanjones makes a thread on ever red dead thought he has. its gets kinda old.   but no it wont be inferior "

I will say this now.  If you buy a game ONLY on how it looks. You sir are not a gamer. So if you are gonna switch your order because of this. Or spend extra money. GTFO of the forums. *That is just my view*  "

I'd like to say that it would, indeed, be inferior, but I have nothing to back that up with that hasn't already been said.

" Man, people with Linky's avatar throwing me for a loop. "

why would it be?

" Probably, because no one knows how to develop for PS3... "

Only in terms of sales. And no, I don't mean that as a slight against the PS3, it's just a fact that most multi-platform games sell better on the 360.

" @Ryax said:

" @The_Laughing_Man said:

" @Coombs said:

" I think I don't care, Seeing as how unless your playing them side by side (or an elitist ass) you won't know the difference anyway. "

I might have to block the RDR forums for a wile if people are gonna start this stuff. Which happens with EVERY big game release.  "

im getting to that point mainly because sackmanjones makes a thread on ever red dead thought he has. its gets kinda old.   but no it wont be inferior "

I will say this now.  If you buy a game ONLY on how it looks. You sir are not a gamer. So if you are gonna switch your order because of this. Or spend extra money. GTFO of the forums. *That is just my view*  "

" @The_Laughing_Man said:

" @Ryax said:

" @The_Laughing_Man said:

" @Coombs said:

" I think I don't care, Seeing as how unless your playing them side by side (or an elitist ass) you won't know the difference anyway. "

I might have to block the RDR forums for a wile if people are gonna start this stuff. Which happens with EVERY big game release.  "

im getting to that point mainly because sackmanjones makes a thread on ever red dead thought he has. its gets kinda old.   but no it wont be inferior "

I will say this now.  If you buy a game ONLY on how it looks. You sir are not a gamer. So if you are gonna switch your order because of this. Or spend extra money. GTFO of the forums. *That is just my view*  "

no i meant im gonna ignore the red dead forums. i dont give a shit which version looks better. "

" @Ryax said:

" @The_Laughing_Man said:

" @Ryax said:

" @The_Laughing_Man said:

" @Coombs said:

" I think I don't care, Seeing as how unless your playing them side by side (or an elitist ass) you won't know the difference anyway. "

I might have to block the RDR forums for a wile if people are gonna start this stuff. Which happens with EVERY big game release.  "

im getting to that point mainly because sackmanjones makes a thread on ever red dead thought he has. its gets kinda old.   but no it wont be inferior "

I will say this now.  If you buy a game ONLY on how it looks. You sir are not a gamer. So if you are gonna switch your order because of this. Or spend extra money. GTFO of the forums. *That is just my view*  "

no i meant im gonna ignore the red dead forums. i dont give a shit which version looks better. "

Its aimed at anyone who picks a games look over gameplay. Not you.  "

So is Linky slowly taking over? Kinda confused with all the avatars. 
 
Anyway, if we look at what the rumors are, 540p with no AA is less appealing than 720p with 2xAA. If its true then yes the ps3 version will not look as good as the 360. However I don't think it would really matter since most people aren't going to be playing both versions side by side anyway.

I personally don't care...

" So is Linky slowly taking over? Kinda confused with all the avatars.  Anyway, if we look at what the rumors are, 540p with no AA is less appealing than 720p with 2xAA. If its true then yes the ps3 version will not look as good as the 360. However I don't think it would really matter since most people aren't going to be playing both versions side by side anyway. "

Better not be.

No I do not. No reason to assume anything yet.

At the end of the day, if it's the same game at heart then it'll be just as good. 

" @wolf_blitzer85 said:

" So is Linky slowly taking over? Kinda confused with all the avatars.  Anyway, if we look at what the rumors are, 540p with no AA is less appealing than 720p with 2xAA. If its true then yes the ps3 version will not look as good as the 360. However I don't think it would really matter since most people aren't going to be playing both versions side by side anyway. "

Linky got banned. Changing our avatar's to his is one way of commemorating his existence as an awesome user of the site. He will be missed. "

Stop using Linkyshinks avatar you nerds. 
 
Linkyshinks was an oversensitive troll.

"Well if the rumours about the resolution and AA are true yes, however if the game play is solid enough the graphics can certainly be overlooked. "

As long as it's not Bayonetta-different, it shouldn't matter. 

What other way is there to think besides personally?

" I hope not. My 360 recently died and I'm getting the PS3 version. "

" @wolf_blitzer85 said:

" So is Linky slowly taking over? Kinda confused with all the avatars.  Anyway, if we look at what the rumors are, 540p with no AA is less appealing than 720p with 2xAA. If its true then yes the ps3 version will not look as good as the 360. However I don't think it would really matter since most people aren't going to be playing both versions side by side anyway. "

Linky got banned. Changing our avatar's to his is one way of commemorating his existence as an awesome user of the site. He will be missed. "

i dont really give a fuck
besides all my friends are getting it on PS3 so that's what matters, if i can't play with them i wont even play it.

" @ajamafalous said:

" Man, people with Linky's avatar throwing me for a loop. "

Yeah, same here.  Anyway, I voted no. Why would it be? "

" @arab_prince:  He wasn't acting any different than any of the other regional trolls we have here, the only difference is he did it to a staff member. "

uh....

Would everybody please stop talking about linkyshinks or whatever in a RDR thread. As for the question I do not see a who cares option, so I chose yes.

" @ajamafalous said:

" Man, people with Linky's avatar throwing me for a loop. "

"

Even if both versions are identical, I'm buying it for 360, as I do for 99% of my multi-console purchases.
 
I've just become to comfortable on the 360, with the controller, my friends list, achievements, etc
 
I like my PS3 and all but.. come on

Everyone this thread was created to discuss the significance between the two console versions of Red Dead Redemption. This thread is not to become the center of dicussing recent events. If you wish to discuss or ask questions about any recent forum events then please feel free to direct them to us mods privately via PM.

" @Ahmad_Metallic: What is the goal with that avatar? "

I chose no, because how the fuck am I supposed to know?

" @Godlyawesomeguy said:

" @Ahmad_Metallic: What is the goal with that avatar? "

Its to make sure people don't forget about an amazing user who got banned for stupid petty reasons . by using the avatar im simply spreading awareness . "

" Man, people with Linky's avatar throwing me for a loop. "

For goodness sake - we've cleared this up in other threads. I don't even know how this "RUMOUR" gathered traction. Bloody hell.

" I just bought a PS3, and RDR is gonna be my GOTC  (Game of the Century), but for some reason i think it will be :( "

Personally I think the PS3 is still only catching up to the XBOX360 in quality.  I own all the systems.  Like all of them.  But the XBOX360 still seems to hold the lead when it comes to games working and looking their best.  I buy most games on my XBOX360.  I think Blu-ray will come into play a little more and possibly PS3 games will be better then XBOX360 games down the line but so far the PS3 is only just saving face when it comes to dual releases.   I voted No as I think the differences will be negligible.  But I wouldn't be surprised if the differences do prove to be somewhat significant.     

It's not 2007 anymore, come on dude. Multiplatform games look great on PS3 these days, I've got a 360 and I usually pick up the PS3 copy of games. Do not feel like I've been burned in any way as of yet.

I don't care about graphics, so it doesn't bother me. And I prefer the Dual Shock as a controller.

It will be the same core game with the chance of some minor technical differences. I don't think it will ruin your enjoyment too much.