"I can't at the moment but I can think of the reverse - I thought Alan Wake looked like *ass* and I remember a number of reviews I read specifically praising the graphics. "
That's because they chose to use graphics in their video sequences that were 4 years old.
But I have to agree with the reviewers on the in-game stuff, they made it look great.
In answer to the guy that made this forum post, I thought and still think the guys at Atari did a great job on Neverwinter Nights 2.
Yet it wasn't praised for its graphics.
Oh and Lost Odyssey, that game looks amazing, and for me Lost Odyssey is my FF XIII since the real FF XIII was so terrible.