I slightly agree with this, however I went through Demons Souls for the most part, without a guide.
On my second playthrough I used a guide and no joke cut my time by about 70%.
What I mean by this is using a guide for basic knowledge, some layouts and basic direction is a good thing but using it as a crutch of what exactly to do/go isn't.
I find much more enjoyment in simply "referring" to the guide when needed and have a good time soaking in the knowledge that it can provide for tons of other basic stuff and to make my mind familiar to the elements of the game that I may have otherwise missed.
I still do a massive amount of exploring even with the guide, because like I said, I use the guide as a basic "beacon" if you will, to simply point me in the right direction and I do the rest of the work.
Even on bosses, I'll go at them a few times and if I'm still stuck with no hope in sight, I'll refer to the guide to help make my experience a little less time consuming/frustrating because let's face it..it all comes down to skill in the end and how you developed your character.
I have a hard time retaining some of the more simple game knowledge and it's a large reason why I could never keep up with games like WoW, etc.
I learn a bunch of things, don't apply those things for a long time and then forget those things.
This game however brings me back to that "old fashion" feel of resorting to my Nintendo Power magazines before the internet was around, to get tips, hints and maps and it leaves me with still a great satisfaction for my experience with the game because I still feel "rooted' in the risk/reward and punishment of the game.
But I understand what you're saying though and this may apply to some people but not always everyone, especially people brand new to the series who will likely get frustrated and quit early on in the game. (because I'm sure there is already a bunch of people doing this, mainly on the xbox 360 which is a platform that I feel this game was never designed for and just doesn't seem like a "360" type of game.
But that's just me, all fanboyism aside.
Log in to comment