Metal Year: Solid 2017 - My Favorite Rock and Metal Albums of the Year
By KillEm_Dafoe 5 Comments
2017 has come and gone...
...another year chock full of heavy metal, rock n' roll, and mosh pit-induced concussions. So let's celebrate and lament a ton of it by going through my favorite records and biggest disappointments of the year! Hail Satan and such. This year was a weird one for me. Many of my most anticipated releases turned out to be duds, or at least disappointing enough to make way for fresher options that I otherwise might not have considered. It sucks that so many things I was looking forward to weren't to my liking, but it allowed me to check out a lot of other things out there, with my premium Spotify account making it super easy to listen to way more than I would've been able to normally. I'm always striving to expand my horizons, listen to new bands and new genres. I hate the idea pigeonholing myself into being the stereotypical metal guy that only listens to thrash, or death, or what have you. That shit is whack. Variety truly is the spice of life, and also, the spice of music. With that in mind, here are my...
Top 10-ish Albums of the Year
10. Seether - Poison the Parish
It seemed like Seether was never going to have their "going back to their roots" moment after releasing a string of albums that, while not bad by any means, kept pushing the band further and further down the commercial rabbit hole. Thankfully, "Poison the Parish" IS that moment. Easily their most aggressive and angry record they've put out since "Karma and Effect," this record sees the band really cut the shit and get down to business. It's not a challenging listen, but it is a satisfying one, full of chunky riffs and memorable grungy hooks. Shaun Morgan no longer tries to stifle his obvious Kurt Cobain influence, and the record is all the better for it. "Stoke the Fire" kicks the door down as the opening track, with "Count Me Out," "Emotionless," and "Something Else" being some of the other highlights.
9. The Black Dahlia Murder - Nightbringers
I'm relatively new to this band. I couldn't really call myself a death metal fan back when they first hit the scene, so I bounced right off of their first couple of releases. Wanting to know what all the fuss was still about after over a decade of ignorance, I decided to check out "Nightbringers" and ... holy SHIT. This album is nasty, an unstoppable blungeoning force of scalding riffs and blast beats galore, rounded out by ferocious vocals seething with spite. But they are used to such good effect, in honest-to-goodness good songwriting that doesn't feel like a complete rehash of the hundreds of also-rans in the scene. "Widowmaker" is the song that DevilDriver would've written if they had adopted a more deathly sound. Admittedly, I don't think the album tops that opening number, but it is at least a high bar to set. The title track and a couple others come mighty close, though.
8. Big Wreck - Grace Street
The Canadian quartet's 5th album, and third since their brilliant comeback "Albatross," continues to solidify the band as one of modern rock's unsung heroes. While I don't think it's as good as "Albatross" or 2014's "Ghosts", "Grace Street" has a lot to offer, with dynamic riffs and melodies at every turn, all beautifully accentuated by Ian Thornley's loose-handed playing and harmonic vocals. Opener "It Comes as No Surprise," along with the jaunty "One Good Piece of Me" and guitar-driven "The Arborist" sit comfortably as a few of the stronger moments. "Skybunk Marche," a 7-minute instrumental, really took me for a ride and will surely appeal to guitar lovers. However, it is with "Useless" that the album makes its strongest stand. I'll elaborate on this a little later.
7.5 Fit for an Autopsy - The Great Collapse
Just gonna sneak this one in here... Fit for an Autopsy is one of the best new death metal bands on the scene with a sound that I think is aptly described as "Gojira meets Kataklysm." "The Great Collapse" is a disgustingly heavy record brimming with groove-laden low-tuned riffs and vocals that inspire one to smash faces with hammers. FUCK ME, it's so good for the first 6 songs. The album unfortunately fizzles out a bit with the last 3, but album comes out strong overall. Can't wait to catch these guys live.
7. The Interbeing - Among the Amorphous
Danish The Interbeing are relatively new, with "Among the Amorphous" being only their second record, but it's a record that hopefully establishes the act as one to look out for in the years ahead. Industrial metal is a peculiar genre as it has a greater level of flexibility than other subgenres. The Interbeing picks up right where fellow Danish metallers Mnemic left off, adding layers of synth and electronics to thick, rubbery riffs and huge soaring choruses with somewhat cynical melodies. It's been done before, but the territory isn't worn out to where this would fail to impress. The writing is razor sharp; "Spiral Into Existence" and "Sum of Singularity" are some of the best the genre have to offer these days. Really, the entire record is obscenely catchy and will serve as a perfect soundtrack to the dystopian future we are hurling toward.
6. Threat Signal - Disconnect
It's been a whopping 7 years since Threat Signal's self-titled record. I was starting to doubt they would ever release anything new, but Disconnect is finally here and it does not disappoint. Really, it sounds like more Threat Signal; it's bouncy djent riffs, lots of double bass, and Jon Howard's alternating barking screams and Chester Bennington-esque crooning, in a mix of death, thrash, industrial, and metalcore. There are a lot of nice choruses and some seriously scalding guitar solos and much of it falls into a familiar formula. I'm perfectly fine with all of that. It's comforting to me. I recently came to find out that it's cool to hate this band in some circles. Why? I haven't the slightest fucking clue. This shit is heavy, catchy as hell, and extremely technically proficient.
That said, there are moments where it strays from the formula and shows a more progressive side to the band. The furious "Aura" half way through the album is easily one of the band's best and most dynamic songs. The 10 minute closing opus "Terminal Madness" is equally as impressive, reaching dizzying heights before it crescendos in a flurry of melodic solos and vocal melodies. It's all beautiful, man. "Exit the Matrix" and 'Falling Apart" are also fantastic.
5. Byzantine - The Cicada Tree
It should honestly be a fucking crime for a band of this caliber to be this underrated. Like, Jesus H. Christ, this band is so damn good. Why aren't they the biggest thing going? Once upon a time, you probably could've described Byzantine as "a more proggy Lamb of God." They've moved forward since then, but The Cicada Tree is still unmistakably Byzantine. It features many slower and even more prog moments than in the past, but the album still has balls to go around with Chris 'OJ' Ojeda's trademark muscular riffs and uniquely varied vocals combined into structurally refreshing songs.
The title track is curiously mellow and really lets Ojeda's singing voice shine. "Verses of Violence" is as epic as they come, building up with acoustic guitars to groovy death riffs and a dreamy chorus over the course of 9 minutes. "Trapjaw" is signature Byzantine at its finest, throwing a flurry of oddly timed riffs at you that inspire some serious headbanging. If you don't know Byzantine by now, I implore you to give 'em a spin. NO ONE FUCKS WITH THE BYZ.
4. Sikth - The Future in Whose Eyes?
What's that? Sikth are back? THE Sikth? If you haven't heard of Sikth before, you've likely heard the seemingly endless dime-a-dozen djent acts that have been dominating the metal scene for awhile now. Sikth released an EP a couple years ago, "Opacities," that let the world know "hey, we're still here and we're gonna show everyone up." And that's exactly what they did. But "The Future in Whose Eyes?" is their first full LP since 2006's genius "Death of a Dead Day." And damn does it slam.
Sikth have always been as weird as they are heavy. Their schizophrenic dual-vocalist approach is a wall that many people have understandly not been able to climb, even if the dizzying guitar work and insane technical flourishes were to their liking. Vocalist Justin Hill has been replaced with newcomer Joe Rosser, and while I think the band is ultimately worse off for it, Rosser still holds his own, while Mikee Goodman brings as manic a performance as ever. The band is definitely not for everybody, and I'm fine with that. "The Future..." is a decidedly even weirder album than their previous work, one that reveals a new layer with each listen. Rare these days to get an album so rewarding with its replayability.
Anyway, I can't express all my thoughts on the album without writing a full review. The guitars are psychotic and on point, especially in the mind-bending "Riddles of Humanity." "The Aura" has a ethereal melodic quality at times that we don't often see from the band. "Weavers of Woe," "Cracks of Light," and "Ride the Illusion" are all incredibly strong tracks. I actually wish this album could've been a little more, but what's here is worthy of singing praise.
3. Stone Sour - Hydrograd
'Hydrograd" has maybe been my most played album all year. I don't think it 100% hits the mark, as there are a fair few filler tracks, but majority of it is just slathered in huge hooks around fun riffs. There's certainly a lot of variety to be had, which I believe is the record's strong suit. It's a little all over the place, particularly with the country ballad "St. Marie," which I'm not too fond of. The album just kind of effortlessly drifts between sounds and writing styles, keeping it fresh even when it's not super exciting. The first real song, "Taipei Person/Allah Tea" kind of sounds like modern Anthrax, but then "Knievel Has Landed" and "Hydrograd" are great mid-tempo rockers with some real ear-worm melodies.
The album knows when to get heavy, too, with "Whiplash Pants" being balls-to-the-wall pissed and the closest thing to Slipknot material on the record. "Fabuless" is also quite badass for being one of the lead singles. "Song #3" is generic radio rock fodder and does nothing for me really, so it makes sense that that song was fucking HUGE. The record closes with "When the Fever Broke," a haunting and depressing ballad that fits in neatly with "Bother" or "Through Glass," though less poppy.
The absence of guitarist Jim Root, for many, posed a potential problem. I think his absence is certainly felt, but I would not call it a problem. The songwriting isn't always consistent, but when it shines, it shines very bright. "Hydrograd" is enthusiastic in its catchiness and clever lyrics. So yeah, I think this is a great record. BUT WHAT DOES COREY TAYLOR THINK?
...I'll see myself out.
2. Trivium - The Sin and the Sentence
It wasn't until I saw Trivium live last year until I realized how spectacular they are. Before then, they were on my radar but never anyone I gravitated towards. Maybe I just didn't give them enough of a chance. Now I can't get enough. "The Sin and the Sentence" is the album that encapsulates their entire career up to this point. It mixes the adventurous prog nature of "Shogun" with the accessibility of "Vengeance Falls" and "In Waves," with hints of everything in between. The result is arguably their strongest record since "Shogun." The title track opens is a remarkably strong opener, trading in melodic verses and a heavy pre-chorus that has the most screaming Matt Heafy has done in years.
Much of the record is the same way, combining the various styles that band has incorporated over the years into single songs. But then you have stuff like "The Wretchedness Inside," one of the heaviest songs of the band's career. Closer "Thrown Into the Fire" has an almost Gothic black metal feel at times. And if "Beauty in the Sorrow" isn't made a single, then what the hell is their label even doing? "The Sin and the Sentence," front to back, is a total banger of a record and a sound I hope the band strives to continue to achieve.
1. Body Count - Bloodlust
It's all come to this. The fact that Body Count has become a legitimate contender in the metal scene over the last few years with their last couple records is both astounding and frankly, over due. The ingredients were always there, the talent was there, but the music was hit and miss and relegated to being a trashy gimmick with no real value. The release of 2013's "Manslaughter" put those notions to rest. Where "Manslaughter" was a riotus satire on crime, violence, social media, the music industry and more, the follow up in "Bloodlust" takes its time to relay serious messages about the state of the country and controversies within, and it's done in the only way Ice-T and gang know how: unpologetically vulgar and in-your-face. Fuck, "All Love is Lost," a vitriloic ode to backstabbing, traitorus scumbag friends may be my anthem for 2017.
It's not poetic, but rather simple and to-the-point. Not only that, the production is as slick as ever. Guitars and drums are crisp and pack serious punch. The furious hardcore/crossover/thrash riffs power this beast of a record from front to back, and the songwriting is seriously catchy and fun, even with the heavy subject matter. Getting guests like Dave Mustaine, Randy Blythe, and Max Cavalera elevates it being a celebration of metal as a whole.
"The Ski Mask Way" trades in the hilarious and over-the-top themes of the "Manslaughter" record (and has one sick breakdown), but tracks like "Civil War," "Black Hoodie," and "No Lives Matter" take a surprsingly level-headed view on senstive social issues, much in the same way that the often misinterpreted "Cop Killer" did so many years ago. For as silly, vulgar, and aggressive as Body Count can get, there is so much honest emotion and passion running througout "Bloodlust" that its infectious. It is, undisputedly, my favorite record of 2017. It's so heartwarming to see that Ice-T is still a hard motherfucker at his age, I just hope BC can keep this train rolling.
Best Song
Big Wreck - "Useless"
It's hard to describe how this song makes me feel. The first time I listened to it, I actually had to stop what I was doing and just sit and listen. It's a relatively simple song compared to every other tune on "Grace Street," but it's the weight the song carries that makes it special. "Useless" is somber, melancholy, honest, depressing, haunting, introspective, and probably a ton of other adjectives. Every time I listen to it, it rips into my soul and lets every pain I've ever felt spill out of me. The goosebumps are real. I can't recall a single song that has ever had such a lasting and repeating effect on me with every last listen. It's not always the easiest song to listen to, either, but it's something cathartic even on the worst of days. Ian Thornely's emotional delivery is really what drives "Useless," especially as his voice rings out that high note in the final chorus, like watching the love of your life leave you for the last time. Christ... what a tune. I think I need to go lie down.
I Am Disappoint
So, I guess they can't all be winners. In this case, it was some of the albums I looked forward to most that didn't quite hit the mark. They aren't necessarily bad, just not quite to par with their bands' respective pedigrees.
36 Crazyfists - Lanterns
I have bittersweet feelings on this one. "Lanterns" let me down because their 2015 comeback record, "Time and Trauma," was so fucking good, arguably their best work. "Lanterns" continues the bleak, atmospheric, and more metallic approach their last few albums have had, but with muddier guitar tones and some less memorable riffs and hooks than they usually have. That said, this is also likely my 11th (or 12th) favorite album of the year because I've given it a fair few spins and it's grown on me. "Death Eater" is a huge song with a darkly cinematic tone, "Sea and Smoke" builds and builds to one of the catchiest choruses they've done that would've been even bigger with better production. "Sleepsick" is one of the band's most badass tunes as the groovy intro gives way to driving double bass. And the second half of "Below the Graves" is so fucking angry it will peel the flesh from your bones. There's a lot of good stuff here, but there are also enough recycled ideas and uninspired parts to make it not a consistent enough record.
Nothing More - The Stories We Tell Ourselves
I must be losing my damn mind because people are going apeshit over this record and for me, it's probably my biggest let down of 2017. I fucking adored their self-titled record from a few years ago and this... I dunno what this is. Not that it's terrible or anything, but it is over-produced to a disgustingly off-putting degree. Their trademark electronic elements, instead of being seamlessly integrated into the band performance like usual, almost take front and center. the bass and drums sound sublime, but the guitar tone is like at half distortion the entire time, becoming buried in the mix. They may as well be non-existent half the time. There aren't really any memorable riffs, and although mostly very catchy, the songs are a lot more poppy this time around. For all intents and purposes, this is a pop record with heavy production. So much of the human element has been removed that I just can't get down with it. The two songs that Sevendust's Clint Lowery helped write, "Funny Little Creatures" and "Tunnels," are easily the best and most straightforward rock songs on the record. Beyond that, I casually like the album but I don't understand how so many of fallen head-over-heels for it.
Demon Hunter - Outlive
Demon Hunter has been a hot streak for a number of years with a long string of really solid albums. "Outlive" is good, but it's a record that shows a band maybe slowing down a bit now for whatever reason. On top of being a softer and more melodic effort, I just don't think the writing is strong enough to carry it. This band usually delivers on catchy hook front, and the album is not without them, but it simply isn't up to par. "Patience" is one of the band's best songs, though, and a fine display of the classic DH sound.
Red - Gone
The first three tracks of "Gone" made me go "Holy shit...this might be their best record." Then the next three songs played and proved to be the absolute worst material the band has done to date. Then the last four songs are pretty good but merely textbook Red. Then it's over. The title track is so bafflingly terrible and out-of-character for the band that you have to wonder who exactly this was for. Who's coming to this band for bland, auto-tuned electronic pop? That's not even mentioning the atrocious cover of Sia's "Unstoppable" that comes after. After "Of Beauty and Rage" was a huge, sprawling and beautiful record, "Gone" is the direct-to-DVD afterthought that the fanbase did not ask for.
The Haunted - Strength in Numbers
The Haunted have put out some of my favorite records of all time. They're the band that has given me my online moniker that I've been using for a number of years now. They were Swedish thrash titans a decade ago, so it's a sad day when they put out a record and I am no longer excited. "Exit Wounds" wasn't perfect, but it got the point across efficiently and marked a stampeding return of vocalist Marco Aro. "Strength in Numbers" is their attempt to write a more complex and dynamic record but forgetting to make it memorable. I was surprised to see so many give this album praise and compare it to "One Kill Wonder." It might take a few more spins to get into it, but the album gives a seriously lackluster first impression.
Queens of the Stone Age - Villains
I admittedly have not given this album much of a chance. Upon first listen, no songs really stuck out to me, and the piss-poor guitar tone really kills it. I will go back to it soon but after the genius "...Like Clockwork" I found this to be a bummer.
Runners Up!
Black Map - In Droves
Cavalera Conspiracy - Psychosis
Nightflight Orchestra - Amber Galactic
Sepultura - Machine Messiah
Kublai Khan - Nomad
2017 Metal Year - diagnosis: SOLID.
Log in to comment