Here is Yatzee's own review of  Uncharted 2: Among Thieves. 
 
See it...
 

Oh im sorry - someone still thinks yahtzee reviews things?

" Oh im sorry - someone still thinks yahtzee reviews things? "

" Oh im sorry - someone still thinks yahtzee reviews things? "

I can't handle how he speaks, Im not good enough with english to get all of it 
As an excuse, I did learn English from watching TV

lol british accents

He's getting worse. The last couple videos haven't been up to his usual standard.

Still hate this guy, I can't stand listening to him.

if he said the game was good and talked about that for 5 mins, nobody would watch his show. 

I kinda find myself agreeing with everything he said.  It isn't that much better than Uncharted, it doesn't bring anything new to the table and it is a popcorn game - but it is a very, very pretty and well made one.
 
@ChristOnIce said:

" @Jeust:   Something so thoroughly devoid of significance or meaning should not be held in such a high regard.  "

lol Some points of the review were really funny though it did go a bit over the top towards the end. Of course he does have a point, it doesn't bring anything new but who cares the game is fun.

I agreed with him about the first game, it borrowed heavily from certain other genre's and simplified them to a point I didn't like.  I thought the game was good, but I wasn't blown away with it, as most people seemed to be.  The combat felt like a clumsy version of Gears of War and the puzzle/platforming element borrowed from Tomb Raider / Prince of Persia was almost non-existant..  I always loved Tomb Raider for the exploration and puzzle solving, and that just wasn't present here.  The adventuring was very linear and the game itself pracitcally tells you how to complete the puzzles.
 
I still haven't played the second one, so I can't really speak about that, but I get the feeling I'm still going to agree with what he said.
Still, it's just one review and as always he is very critical.  If you disagree, there's no need to take it personally.

That was actually kinda funny. And yeah, I thought it was just my eyes when I noticed Nate's facial hair was green.

Yahtzee does not review things. He comedicaly shits on them.

" Yahtzee does not review things. He comedicaly shits on them. "

So yeah... I just watched it and have come to the ultimate conclusion that Yahtzee may be slightly retarded. I used to chuckle at his stuff, but nothing he has released recently is funny, or... well... Anything really. If you fail at funny, which is all he had going for him in the first place, then you just fail.

yeah, his opinion is just awful..........

yet he says some true things about the game... 

I never really agree with Yahtzee's reviews for one reason: He's hypercritical. It's not a bad thing because it's part of what makes Zero Punctuation so entertaining to watch and Yahtzee is undoubtedly aware of this fact. I very much enjoy his videos but for a fair and balanced review I look elsewhere.

The thing with Yahtzee is that while he obviously focuses on the negatives, he never lies. And that's why some people dislike him. They hate him for shitting on games they love but deep down, they know he has a point, and that irritates them to no end. 
 
I can understand what they feel like, though. Sometimes he'll review a game I really love, and I'll go "Dude, don't be hating my game!". But then, I realize that everything he says is true. The flaws he point out may not bother me, but that doesn't mean they aren't there. 
 
So this is my message to all the Yahtzee haters: Grow a pair.

Yahtzee's "reviews" are not funny, AND do not have any journalistic value. He tries to prove his points in some clever ways, but he is almost always exaggerating to a point that you just hate him.

 In short, he has not integrity, be it comedic or journalistic.

"

Yahtzee's "reviews" are not funny, AND do not have any journalistic value. He tries to prove his points in some clever ways, but he is almost always exaggerating to a point that you just hate him.

 In short, he has not integrity, be it comedic or journalistic.

"

" But it's definitely more fun than it is good. "

And for all my life, I thought a good game is a game that is fun!

@Icemael said:

" They hate him for shitting on games they love but deep down, they know he has a point, and that irritates them to no end. "

Great, if I disagree with Yahtzee's "style", consider his videos pointless as they serve little entertaining values (in contrast to most games he shits on, not all, because he's "Yahtzing" crap too) and that his Zero Punctuations are a lot less natural, funny and insightful as the overrated Angry Video Game Nerd videos (and that guy just keeps falling down since that video where he blasted The Naked Gun for weird sequel numeration. The Naked Gun. Pound bricks, I never thought taking those movies dead fucking serious is possible), I am obviously buthurt because he insulted a video game I like. Clearly.

Well,

I can understand what they feel like, though. Sometimes he'll review a game I really love, and I'll go "Dude, don't be hating my game!".

" The thing with Yahtzee is that while he obviously focuses on the negatives, he never lies. And that's why some people dislike him. They hate him for shitting on games they love but deep down, they know he has a point, and that irritates them to no end. 
 
I can understand what they feel like, though. Sometimes he'll review a game I really love, and I'll go "Dude, don't be hating my game!". But then, I realize that everything he says is true. The flaws he point out may not bother me, but that doesn't mean they aren't there.  So this is my message to all the Yahtzee haters: Grow a pair. "

" if he said the game was good and talked about that for 5 mins, nobody would watch his show.  "

"I have one thank you, although I would not consider my self a hater. More like a recent convert into the I do not like him anymore camp. And also no, some of his complaints are lies. Blowing something way out of proportion and exaggerating is not telling the truth, and therefore it is lying. Or it is more lie then truth. "

Ahh there's no point in watching it, I don't need to hear him hate on one of my favourite games.

" @LiquidPrince said:

"I have one thank you, although I would not consider my self a hater. More like a recent convert into the I do not like him anymore camp. And also no, some of his complaints are lies. Blowing something way out of proportion and exaggerating is not telling the truth, and therefore it is lying. Or it is more lie then truth. "

Exaggeration used for emphasis(and in Yahtzee's case, comedic effect) is called hyperbole. Deviation from the truth intended to deceive is called lying. Hyperbole =/= lying. "

Yahtzee reviews are the shit. I still enjoy games that he destroys, but he often does have a point.

" @Icemael said:

" @LiquidPrince said:

"I have one thank you, although I would not consider my self a hater. More like a recent convert into the I do not like him anymore camp. And also no, some of his complaints are lies. Blowing something way out of proportion and exaggerating is not telling the truth, and therefore it is lying. Or it is more lie then truth. "

Exaggeration used for emphasis(and in Yahtzee's case, comedic effect) is called hyperbole. Deviation from the truth intended to deceive is called lying. Hyperbole =/= lying. "

Hyperbole is different then bending the truth and blowing it out of proportion. Saying I can eat a horse because I am hungry is hyperbole. Saying that you get stuck to every surface and can not get unstuck without pressing the opposite direction for an extended period of time is lying. "

" @LiquidPrince said:

" @Icemael said:

" @LiquidPrince said:

"I have one thank you, although I would not consider my self a hater. More like a recent convert into the I do not like him anymore camp. And also no, some of his complaints are lies. Blowing something way out of proportion and exaggerating is not telling the truth, and therefore it is lying. Or it is more lie then truth. "

Exaggeration used for emphasis(and in Yahtzee's case, comedic effect) is called hyperbole. Deviation from the truth intended to deceive is called lying. Hyperbole =/= lying. "

Hyperbole is different then bending the truth and blowing it out of proportion. Saying I can eat a horse because I am hungry is hyperbole. Saying that you get stuck to every surface and can not get unstuck without pressing the opposite direction for an extended period of time is lying. "

I dunno about you, but to me, that was a pretty obvious exaggeration. "

"Just so you know, I am not really going to argue, because what is the point right, but no, that is a lie. It is an exaggeration, but exaggerating beyond a point becomes lies. It is both. Ultimately the point is though, that he is not funny anymore. At least not to me."

" @Jeust: Just because some of the things he said may have been true, that doesn't mean they're valid criticisms of the game. He seems to really like blowing small gripes way out of proportion and ignoring a fair amount of the good points.  I guess that's just the nature of what he does though... seems kind of pointless to me. "

Yahtzee never fails to give me a laugh but I can never take him seriously after his Halo 3 'review'. 

Meh...his "reviews" are tired and not as funny as they used to be.

" Yahtzee never fails to give me a laugh but I can never take him seriously after his Halo 3 'review'.  "

" @Zereta said:

" Yahtzee never fails to give me a laugh but I can never take him seriously after his Halo 3 'review'.  "

I think that's the review I had the biggest problem with too, mainly because he complained about not understanding the story after saying he hadn't played the first two games.  Of course he wasn't going to understand the character motivations, etc.. it's the equivalent of watching Return of the Jedi or Return of the King before the first two Star Wars / Lord of the Rings movies.  You'll pick up things, but the conflict and drama just isn't going to be there.  He also totally ignored the fact that the reason it may have felt so similar to most other FPS'.. is because most other FPS are based on Halo.  Again, probably because he hadn't played the original to notice this. "

Yahtzee dosent review.. He lies, exaggerates and put's things out of context to create an entertaining video. Just like the Angry video game nerd and stuff like that. 
 
Yahtzee's a moron.

Man, I really hate Yatzee.