Hot cleavage, bro!

@MrKlorox: Bioshock wasn't really all that linear.

Generally open environments. It's fairly open with out being an open world game. what more did you want?

im liking this open world feel much more than the claustrophobic feel of the first two. 

Hope it's better than the first, I got really bored of it towards the end.
 
2 played better.

Looks amazing.

Damn, I thought it was going to be Uncharted 3.

Damn, I thought it was going to be Uncharted 3.

That girl has boobs.

it says a ot about how far the games industry has come when you look at the stark contrast between this ( bioshock ) and the just released ( started design in the 90's  ) duke nukem forever. 
 
That games of this or any format can provide such a classy and interesting experiance can exist is a grand thing indeed. Its just a shame that the specters  of the past are still around bothering us all.

Definitely a game that I'm looking forward to. 

Doesn't hurt having a Game of the Show award, gets Giantbomb on the back of the box perhaps? Aside from Uncharted, which is a known quantity, I can't think of anything being an outright "Game of the Show" from the top of my head.

Honestly thought Battlefield 3 is the game of the show. You guys sure love your Ken Levine and Bioshock, too much. Sell outs...

@texaseanacre said:

@Marino: Let's hope it's out by then, but if it isn't, I wouldn't be surprised if it was!

I would be very surprised if it was out by next E3. It's due out in 2012, and I'm expecting it to be a holiday release. I could even imagine it slipping into 2013.

Looks good and all but didn't blow me away at all.

@Saltank said:

Honestly thought Battlefield 3 is the game of the show. You guys sure love your Ken Levine and Bioshock, too much. Sell outs...

Look at this guy!

@Saltank said:

Honestly thought Battlefield 3 is the game of the show. You guys sure love your Ken Levine and Bioshock, too much. Sell outs...

Honestly, I thought that Battlefield looks really boring in what was shown.

I was super excited when I saw the first Bioshock game, but this one doesn't really grab me.

sure its probably great but i just wished they had showed the public more of what they showed the journalists, its a tad unfair that we have to accept the game plays great by word of mouth alone.

@Saltank said:

Honestly thought Battlefield 3 is the game of the show. You guys sure love your Ken Levine and Bioshock, too much. Sell outs...

So, because you disagree with their pick, they are sell outs? Somehow that doesn't add up.

For sure, Bioshock Infinite isn't my game of the show but I don't see anything wrong with them picking that game. Oh and Battlefield 3 seems technically impressive, I thought the environments and actual game (from what they've shown) looks bland as fuck.

This game looks incredible, and Bioshock is an all time great game, so I can't disagree. It was either this, Prey 2 or Skyrim for me.

I suppose this is as good a place to ask as any:

Have you guys spent any time with the new Deus Ex?

Knew this wold win but I have to say I totally agree. The game demoed great, it looked great, and its got a lot of great ideas behind it.

@RVonE said:

@Saltank said:

Honestly thought Battlefield 3 is the game of the show. You guys sure love your Ken Levine and Bioshock, too much. Sell outs...

So, because you disagree with their pick, they are sell outs? Somehow that doesn't add up.

For sure, Bioshock Infinite isn't my game of the show but I don't see anything wrong with them picking that game. Oh and Battlefield 3 seems technically impressive, I thought the environments and actual game (from what they've shown) looks bland as fuck.

I admit, I should have been a little more sarcastic with my comment, however, from a viewer's point of view I'm still seeing the same thing I saw last year from BioShock Infinite, and there's absolutely nothing too incredible at E3 that gives the game any more merit. And the lengthy interview with the creator seems to give an impression that GB's opinions are not as independent as I would have thought before, because ..maybe they're good friends with the creators, for one.

I liked what Levine had to say, especially the bit where he admitted that they couldn't figure out what to do with BioShock and underwater combat, which makes me believe that Infinite will be GREAT. However, everyone else seems to think BF3 is the game of the show. Why? Because it's the most hyped. Because it had the longest line ups. Because it looks and plays incredibly. Because the developers know what the players like and this is going to be appealing to such a wide audience. BS Infinite - its single player experience will enthral us and then that's it, we're done. Doesn't sound like the sort of game that should be objectively considered as the best of E3 based on normal judging merits. Doesn't seem like it's important or 'big' enough as some of the other stuff we've seen.

@Saltank: And BF3 will be revolutionary? It's all opinions in the end, no reason to jump to that type of conclusions just because you disagree. What is this? That OTHER website? Your definition of "game of the show" is not something I agree with.

The Sony presser was the first time I saw any footage of this.

Can't say I'm surprised this was game of show for GB. Can't wait to get for my PS3 so I can also play the original Bioshock. (Which I am ashamed to say I haven't played).

Wish they would've shown that demo.

I love Bioshock 1 and 2 and I'm ready for some more!

Safe choice

For me, this winning game of the show is as weird Battlefield 3 winning game of the show. Both will likely be very good games, but what was shown at E3 wasn't all that spectacular. Perhaps the giant bomb dudes got a better look at the game than I did, but everything I saw of the game at E3 just made it look like a shooter with a nice art style and well designed on-rails segments.

@MattyFTMsaid:

@texaseanacre said:

@Marino: Let's hope it's out by then, but if it isn't, I wouldn't be surprised if it was!

I would be very surprised if it was out by next E3. It's due out in 2012, and I'm expecting it to be a holiday release. I could even imagine it slipping into 2013.

Hmm, you're probably right but I would still want to play it earlier in the year! Ha ha ha.

Same choice I would have made, can't wait for this game

Understandable, Ken Levine seems pretty cool. Game'O show for me obviously Mass Effect followed by Resident Evil: Revelations. Now I just need a 3DS, preferably the lite model.

Not BF3? This is an outrage. Yellow journalism at it's finest.

Should've picked a game that was out this year and that you actually got to play rather than watch someone else demoing it.

Honestly thought Battlefield 3 is the game of the show. You guys sure love your Ken Levine and Bioshock, too much. Sell outs...

@SpacePenguin said:

@Saltank said:

Honestly thought Battlefield 3 is the game of the show. You guys sure love your Ken Levine and Bioshock, too much. Sell outs...

Oh ye because that tank sequence they showed really deserves game of the show, are you serious? And anyway why would they be sellouts just because they picked a game you didnt like?

It's more impressive because it's breaking the same old rhythm set by MW games. Read previous comments for explanation.

@Nadafinga said:

That's hilarious.

@Gargantuan said:

I love Bioshock 1 and 2 and I'm ready for some more!

this!

Most anticipated by far.

After reading a couple comments on this thread i believe some people need to learn what an "opinion" is.

Remember that this is the best SHOWN GAME at E3.

I'm a Bioshock fanboy, so I have been really looking forward to this, though I still haven't bothered to look up the release date.

I bet Vinny's Dark Souls suggestion was downvoted