I don't hate any game websites, but there are certainly some websites which I do not trust. Most of them are the really shady websites, like Gamereactor or YouGamers (which seems to give virtually any game a glowing review) - most of them, sadly, are from Europe. Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of good game reviewers from Europe, and by Jove there are bad US and Australian Game Reviewers, but Europe (especially Eastern Europe) seems to be the focal point of very, very shady reviews. I can't really blame them - Eastern Europe isn't exactly an Economic Paradise, and everyone needs to eat.
I rarely visit IGN or Gamespot, but I don't hate those websites. Gametrailers doesn't seem terribly good to me either, but again, I don't hate that site. It just doesn't appeal to me.
Giantbomb is the place I go to, because of the Quicklooks - better than reviews, in my opinion. I don't agree with quite a lot of the games that the GB staff like (I, for instance, really, really don't care for any of the Assassin's Creed Games, and I question some of the games Brad likes (Dead Island? Four Stars? Seriously?)) but I respect their honesty. I truly do believe that Brad liked Dead Island, even though I can't really understand why. I honestly believe Ryan likes Assassin's Creed, even though that entire series is a sedative to me.
But GB has shown me some wonderful games through Quicklooks and TNT. I would not have got XCOM: Enemy Unknown if it wasn't for that Quicklook. I wouldn't have bothered with Max Payne 3 (a game I liked), without that Quicklook. I would never have touched Bastion, one of my favourite games of all time, without the coverage that GB provided. The most recent game that GB illuminated me to buy was Hotline Miami and goddamn if that isn't a fun (if short) game.
Other sites don't do that - the reviews they write read as if they were written by robots with no personality. When someone from GB says they like or dislike a game, I can get a good sense as to WHY. I don't, and never have, gotten that from other sites, whose rotating mass of come-and-go freelance writers and personality-devoid staff members leaves me feeling that I am being barked at by TOTAL STRANGERS.
About the only other site I like is Rock-Paper-Shotgun.
Log in to comment