Its between GTA IV, RDR and The Warriors.

Well since Max Payne doesn't really count then its GTA Vice City or The Warriors.

Red Dead, or Vice City

The only R* game I have is San Andreas. That is, until Red Dead Redemption gets here...hopefully today.

" Was gonna say San Andreas or Red Dead Redemption, but it's been brought to my attention that Max Payne counts as a Rockstar game? Hmm... "

Traditionally I've usually said Vice City, but when I think about it, I think I had more raw fun with San Andreas.
Bully & RDR are indeed awesome, but GTA is truly outstanding.

Vice City

RDR or Vice City for me

Vice City or GTA:IV. I've yet to play RDR.

RDR and GTA 1/2/3/Vice City oh and Max payne 2. Fuck it, all of them. I love Rockstar!

Really hard to choose but it has to be Vice City.

Max Payne 2.  Then The Warriors.

I am not a fan of Rockstar.

GTA: Vice City

" @Rhaknar: Max Payne 1 shouldn't count, because Rockstar had nothing to do with that one. But second one it was released by Rockstar. They didn't actually make the game I think. Not sure if that counts. "

Strong tie between San Andreas and Red Dead Redemption.

I have to go with Bully.  It was a treat to play from start to finish.  So well realised and so funny.

Bully.
 
I'm hoping to get the 360 version soon. I want to replay it really bad.

GTA IV is probably my favorite. GTA III comes pretty close though.

Regretfully missed out on Bully.
 
I'll go with San Andreas followed closely by RDR. Red Dead has the atmosphere and story with some excellent touches to push rockstar's games forward, but the missions and variety in San Andreas were too awesome. I spend like 150 hours playing that game. So much potential to just screw around.

" @inkeiren said:

" @Laketown said:

" @inkeiren said:

" Red Dead Redemption. I was expecting more of that in this thread. "

bully has one of the best settings i've ever seen in a game. RDR is a western "

How much of RDR have you played? Not being confrontational, just wondering.  The setting is the thing I liked least about RDR. I do not like westerns. It really had to be a game that is great in every other aspect to win me over. I prefer the settings of all other Rockstar games. Every single one. I like RDR because of the gameplay, graphics, soundtrack, voice acting, and characters. "

I haven't played any of it, actually. A good and imaginative setting is more important the graphics, the soundtrack (bully has a better one, probably), or the voice acting. I'm honestly just shitting on it because people keep hyping it up, but it's still a post GTAIV Rockstar game... I don't really expect much from it when I do play it. and of course bully had a slingshot and this weird launcher thing and also panty raaaaaaids. "

" they are all so much fun "

gt4

GTA 3. That game blew my mind when I first played it. Oh man, it was so good.

I was a big fan of GTA2, Vice City, IV, and Chinatown Wars. I guess I would have to go with IV.

Vice City all day..

" @Laketown said:

" @inkeiren said:

" @Laketown said:

" @inkeiren said:

" Red Dead Redemption. I was expecting more of that in this thread. "

bully has one of the best settings i've ever seen in a game. RDR is a western "

How much of RDR have you played? Not being confrontational, just wondering.  The setting is the thing I liked least about RDR. I do not like westerns. It really had to be a game that is great in every other aspect to win me over. I prefer the settings of all other Rockstar games. Every single one. I like RDR because of the gameplay, graphics, soundtrack, voice acting, and characters. "

I haven't played any of it, actually. A good and imaginative setting is more important the graphics, the soundtrack (bully has a better one, probably), or the voice acting. I'm honestly just shitting on it because people keep hyping it up, but it's still a post GTAIV Rockstar game... I don't really expect much from it when I do play it. and of course bully had a slingshot and this weird launcher thing and also panty raaaaaaids. "

Is setting more important than story and gameplay? Red Dead Redemption has both of those in spades. I'm not saying Bully doesn't, but RDR is one of the most universally loved games I've ever seen in my entire life. I know of nobody who has played the game and didn't like it, save perhaps Jeff. "

" @inkeiren said:

" @Laketown said:

" @inkeiren said:

" @Laketown said:

" @inkeiren said:

" Red Dead Redemption. I was expecting more of that in this thread. "

bully has one of the best settings i've ever seen in a game. RDR is a western "

How much of RDR have you played? Not being confrontational, just wondering.  The setting is the thing I liked least about RDR. I do not like westerns. It really had to be a game that is great in every other aspect to win me over. I prefer the settings of all other Rockstar games. Every single one. I like RDR because of the gameplay, graphics, soundtrack, voice acting, and characters. "

I haven't played any of it, actually. A good and imaginative setting is more important the graphics, the soundtrack (bully has a better one, probably), or the voice acting. I'm honestly just shitting on it because people keep hyping it up, but it's still a post GTAIV Rockstar game... I don't really expect much from it when I do play it. and of course bully had a slingshot and this weird launcher thing and also panty raaaaaaids. "

Is setting more important than story and gameplay? Red Dead Redemption has both of those in spades. I'm not saying Bully doesn't, but RDR is one of the most universally loved games I've ever seen in my entire life. I know of nobody who has played the game and didn't like it, save perhaps Jeff. "

oh no, bully has a great story (I'm not going to say it compares to RDR because obviously I haven't played it) and from what I saw in the TNT the gunplay looks extremely dull (not like bully's combat was the greatest either, but eh)  I guess I should stop talking about it, but GODDAMN am I tired of hearing of that game. "

The Warriors

I haven't played RDR yet, since my x360 is away for repairs.
 
But I'll say San Andreas, since it was so amazing and lasted me so long when it came out. Generally I have fond memories of every GTA game ever made, least for IV (a step backwards gameplay-wise imo. Was a good story though.)

Red Dead Redemption

I've only played the GTA games and Max Payne and I have to say Vice City is my favourite. I just got 100% complete for the 6th time yesterday.

Vice City > RDR > The Warriors

Probably San Andreas. RDR would be runner up.

That's difficult to decide between GTA 1 and Manhunt because they're both so different. It'll probably end up being Manhunt for me - that is one of the most intense and challenging games I've ever played to completion while still enjoying my time very much! It's incredibly satisfying and well-designed if you can get into the stealth mechanics and sick universe.
I don't really consider Max Payne a rockstar game but it's certainly one of the best shooters I ever played. Don't know if it beats Manhunt though in terms of entertainment I got from it.

I haven't really played a lot of rockstar games, I'm not really a big fan of sandbox, but vice city was the most enjoyable game and one I liked from start to finish. 

I guess Vice City. Red Dead Redemption comes a close second, as being the only other Rockstar game I played to completion.

Red Dead Redemption or GTA 2

I'd say San Andreas if it weren't for those damn plane missions.

Grand Theft Auto San Andreas.

Does Lemmings count as a Rockstar game, since DMA Designs (now Rockstar North) developed it? If so, I'm going with that. Lemmings is an absolute classic.